This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Optimal Substitution of Lightweight Materials in Automobiles
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Development of lightweight materials has provided the automotive industry with numerous possibilities for vehicle weight reduction. The usage of these materials will depend upon their economic feasibility as well as their material properties. Often, managers will compute the penalty-per-pound saved in a given application for a number of competing materials to determine which is cost-effective. However, this method has limited usefulness in larger dimensioned problems where an overall weight requirement is to be met by employing a large number of candidate materials in any number of component applications. When there are several component-material combinations under simultaneous consideration, attention should focus on; (1) which set of materials minimize total cost while meeting a particular weight constraint and; (2) how the solution set of materials changes as the weight constraint is varied.
This paper presents a relatively simple technique useful for determining the most economically attractive materials mix given the weights and costs of all material-component combinations and an overall weight target. The technique has been applied to a production mid-sized vehicle to obtain optimal material mixes for 26 structural components. The competing materials include mild steel, aluminum, high strength low alloy steel (HSLA), E-glass and five different graphite reinforced plastic hybrids. A computer program was developed to perform the necessary calculations. The results of several cases are presented and analyzed.
Authors
Citation
Reid, D. and Stevenson, P., "Optimal Substitution of Lightweight Materials in Automobiles," SAE Technical Paper 800828, 1980, https://doi.org/10.4271/800828.Also In
References
- Artinian L. Terry S. L. “The Total Cost of Weight.” Presented at SAE National Automobile Week Detroit March 1961
- Harvey H. R. Chopinsky D. J. “Development of a Motor Vehicle Materials Historical, High Volume Industrial Processing Rates Cost Data Bank (Intermediate Type Car),” December 1976
- Chang David C. Justusson J. William “Structural Requirements in Materials Substitution for Car-Weight Reduction.” Paper No. 760023 presented at SAE Automobile Engineering Congress February 1976
- Kliger H. S. “Development and Experimental Verification of Design Values for Carbon-Glass Hybrid Sandwich Composites,” 1978
- Kaiser R. “Automotive Uses of Advanced Composite Materials,” December 1978
- Society of the Plastics Industry, Inc 1976
- U.S. Department of Labor Wholesale Prices and Price Indexes--Data for July 1977 Washington, District of Columbia Bureau of Labor Statistics
- Williams G. L. “A New Approach to Sheet Molding Compound (SMC) Molding,” Proceedings of the 31st Annual Technical Conference, Reinforced Plastics/Composites Institute, The Society of the Plastics Industry, Inc Washington, District of Columbia 1976
- Simko T. D. “Automotive and Commercial High Strength Molding Compounds,” Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Technical Conference, Reinforced Plastics/Composites Institute, The Society of the Plastics Industry, Inc Washington, District of Columbia 1978
- Ackley R. H. “XMC TM Structural FGRP for Matched Metal Die Molding,” Proceedings of the 31st Annual Technical Conference, Reinforced Plastics/Composites Institute, The Society of the Plastics Industry, Inc Washington, District of Columbia 1976
- PPG Industries, Inc Phase II--Fast Cure Automotive SMC May 31 1978
- Fesko D. G. Mallick P. K. Newman S. “Automotive Composites-- Manufacturing and Materials Interactions,” Composite Materials in the Automobile Industry New York American Society of Mechanical Engineers 1978
- Martin J. “Pultrusion--An Overview of Applications and Opportunities,” Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Technical Conference, Reinforced Plastics/Composites Institute, The Society of the Plastics industry, Inc., Section 8-H Washington, District of Columbia 1978
- Tickle J. D. “Pultrusion--Step Up the Challenge to Structural Steels,” Machine Design October 2 1977 163 167
- Wood A. S. “Pultrusion Is Poised for New Growth,” Modern Plastics June 1976
- Rolston J. A. “Process and Economic Factors for Pultrusion,” Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Technical Conference, Reinforced Plastics/Composites Institute, Society of the Plastics Industry Washington, District of Columbia 1978
- Sanada M. “Economics of Plastic Molding Processes,” Proceedings SPI 31st Annual Technical Conference Montreal, Canada May 7–10 1973 237
- Haddad G. N. “Recent Innovations in PVC-FRP Composite Pipe,” Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Technical Conference, Society of the Plastics Industry, Reinforced Plastics/Composites Institute, Section 5-F Washington, District of Columbia February 1977
- Lionetta, W. G. Jr. “Sources of Innovation Within the Pultrusion Industry,” June 1977
- Adams D. G. DiCello J. A. Hoppe C. Kaiser A. S. Kersoglanand A. N. McVinnie W.W. “High Strength Materials and Vehicle Weight Reduction Analysis,” SAE Paper 750221 1975