This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Practicality of Alcohols as Motor Fuel
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Several alcohols have been or are being used as motor fuel in limited applications where their unique properties provide a specific benefit. Recently, proposals have been made to manufacture methyl and ethyl alcohols from nonpetroleum feedstocks for use as a primary energy source. Such a program, it is claimed, would reduce U.S. dependence on foreign oil; manufacturing ethanol would also stabilize prices of farm commodities.
An economical and abundant feedstock for methanol manufacture is North Dakota lignite. In a plant consuming lignite and self-sufficient in utilities, energy in the methanol would represent about 45 per cent of the energy in the feedstock. The cost of energy from the methanol produced would be about twice that from gasoline at 1979 prices. Liquefaction of lignite or coal to a synthetic crude with subsequent refining by conventional processes would provide motor fuel at somewhat higher energy efficiency and lower cost than by methanol synthesis. Municipal solid wastes could also be used as feedstock for methanol manufacture, but the cost would be even higher than with lignite as feedstock.
The lowest cost and most abundant feedstock for ethanol manufacture is corn. With current farming and ethanol manufacturing practices, which use mainly petroleum-based fuels, energy in the ethanol plus that in the byproducts is only about 55 per cent of the energy in the petroleum fuels consumed. If the ethanol plant used only nonpetroleum fuels such as coal or agricultural wastes for process energy, the efficiency based on just the petroleum fuels used in farming and collection of wastes would range from 130 to 160 per cent; overall efficiency would remain at 55 per cent or less. Energy in the byproducts represents about 40 per cent of the energy output, which greatly complicates evaluation of the efficiency of the plant. In any event, the cost of energy from the ethanol produced would be at least four times that from gasoline. The high cost results from large capital charges, large operating costs and, especially, large raw material costs.
While both methanol and ethanol have characteristics that complicate distribution and detract from product quality, poor energy yield and high cost are the most serious deterrents to commercialization of either alcohol. Methanol is definitely preferred, but neither represents a practical alternative unless the price of petroleum-based fuels rises markedly relative to that of the alcohols.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Wagner, T., Gray, D., Zarah, B., and Kozinski, A., "Practicality of Alcohols as Motor Fuel," SAE Technical Paper 790429, 1979, https://doi.org/10.4271/790429.Also In
References
- Chemical and Engineering News January 22 1979 13
- Chemical and Engineering News December 18 1978
- Hagen, D. L. “Methanol: Its Synthesis, Use as a Fuel, Economics, and Hazards,” ERDA NP-21727 December 1976 University of Minnesota
- Barr, W.J. Parker, F. A. “Sources of Alcohol Fuels for Vehicle Fleet Tests,” ERDA CONS/2693 August 1977
- Clark, F. C. Ushiba, K. K. “Methanol Fuel: Its Manufacture and Utilization,” Stanford Research Institute March 1977
- Alich, J. A. Witmer, J. G. Solar Energy 19 625
- Ernest, R. Kent Proceedings of the Second Pacific Chemical Engineering Congress 1977 I 187
- Park, W. R. Second Annual Fuels from Biomass Symposium Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute June 1978
- Hokenson, A. E. et al. “Chemicals from Wood Wastes,” Raphael Katzen Associates Cincinnati December 1975
- David, M. L. et al. “Gasohol Economic Feasibility Study” Energy Research and Development Center University of Nebraska Nebraska Agricultural Products Industrial Utilization Commission July 1978
- Todisch, M. R. et al. Fuels and Chemicals from Biomass Purdue Agricultural Experimental Station
- Scheller, W. A. Mohr, B.J. “Gasoline Does, Too, Mix with Alcohol,” Chemtech October 1977 616
- Scheller, W. A. Mohr, B.J. “Net Energy Analysis of Ethanol Production,” 171st National meeting of the American Chemical Society New York April 1976 21 2 29
- Inman, R. E. “The Cost of Plant Biomass Production,” Biotech and Bio Engineering, Symposium 5 1975 43
- Brinkman, N.D. et al. “Exhaust Emissions, Fuel Economy and Driveability of Vehicles Fueled with Alcohol/Gasoline Blends,” Society of Automotive Engineers
- Koenig, A. et al. “Technical and Economical Aspects of Methanol as an Automotive Fuel,” Society of Automotive Engineers
- Demel, J. R. May 8 1978
- Analysis of Gasohol Fleet Data to Characterize the Impact of Gasohol on Tailpipe and Evaporative Emissions U.S. Environmental Protection Agency December 1978