This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Car Occupant Fatalities and the Effects of Future Safety Legislation
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
This paper describes an analysis of a sample of over 300 fatally injured occupants of cars involved in accidents mainly between 1969 and 1976 in urban, rural and motorway environments of the United Kingdom. The sample is drawn from a retrospective field study of collisions conducted by examining cars at garages, and correlating that information with medical and road user data obtained from hospitals and by questionnaires. The sample is thought to be broadly representative of the U.K. occupant fatality situation.
The injuries to all the fatally injured occupants are described in detail using the A.I.S. and the I.S.S. procedures. These injuries are then related to their most common sources, for specific crash configurations. The vehicle deformation is described in terms of the frequency and severity of various collision types, and then both injuries and deformation are reviewed in the light of existing and proposed safety legislation in Europe.
The effect of compulsory seat belt use on this sample is estimated, and the consequences for other safety standards and their relative priorities are discussed. In particular the increased relative importance of side impact protection is noted. Other conclusions drawn are the need for improved passenger compartment integrity, and better compatability between trucks and small cars.
Recommended Content
Authors
- D. K. Griffiths - Accident Research Unit, University of Birmingham
- H. R. M. Hayes - Accident Research Unit, University of Birmingham
- P. F. Gloyns - Accident Research Unit, University of Birmingham
- S. J. Rattenbury - Accident Research Unit, University of Birmingham
- G. M. MacKay - Accident Research Unit, University of Birmingham
Topic
Citation
Griffiths, D., Hayes, H., Gloyns, P., Rattenbury, S. et al., "Car Occupant Fatalities and the Effects of Future Safety Legislation," SAE Technical Paper 760811, 1976, https://doi.org/10.4271/760811.Also In
References
- Gloyns P. F. “The Impact Performance of Some Designs of Steering Assembly in Real Accidents and Under Test Conditions.” University of Birminghan England December 1973
- Siegel S. “Nonparametric Statistics for the Behavioural Sciences.” London McGraw-Hill Book Co. 1956
- Newby R. F. Transport and Road Research Laboratory March 1976
- “Road Accidents in Great Britain 1974.” London Her Majesty's Stationary Office April 1976
- Mackay G. M. Ashton S. J. “Injuries in Collisions Involving Small Cars in Europe.” Paper 730284 , International AUtomotive Engineering Congress Detroit January 1973
- Seiffert U. “Compatibility on the Road.” Fifth International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles London June 1974
- Ventre P. “Proposal of Methodology for Drawing up Efficient Regulations.” Fourth International Congress on Automotive Safety San Francisco July 1975
- Joint Committee on Injury Scaling of Society of Automotive Engineering American Medical Association American Association for Automotive Safety “The Abbreviated Injury Scale (1975 Revision).” Nineteenth Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine San Diego November 1975
- Baker S. P. O'Neill B. Haddon W. Long W. B. “The Injury Severity Score: Development and Potential Usefulness” Eighteenth Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine Toronto September 1974
- Gissane W. Bull J. “A Study of Motorway (M1) Fatalities.” British Medical Journal 1 11th January 1964 75 80
- Mackay G. M. “Causes and Effects of Road Traffic Accidents - Part III - The Vehicle.” Department of Transportation and Environmental Planning, University of Birmingham England June 1969
- Kihlberg J. K. “Multiplicity of Injury in Automobile Accidents” Impact Injury and Crash Protection Gurdjian E. S. et al Springfield, Illinois Charles C. Thomas 1970
- Mackay G. M. Gloyns P. F. Hayes H. R. M. Griffiths D. K. “European Vehicle Safety Standards and their Effectiveness” Fourth International Congress on Automotive Safety San Francisco July 1975
- Henderson M. Wood R. “Compulsory Wearing of Seat Belts in New South Wales, Australia - An Evaluation of the Effects on Vehicle Occupant Deaths in the First Year.” The Medical Journal of Australia 2 October 27th 1973 797 801
- Foldvary L. A. Lane J. C. “The Effectiveness of Compulsory Wearing of Seat Belts in Casualty Reduction (With an Appendix on Chi-Square Partitioning-Tests of Complex Contingency Tables).” Accident Analysis and Prevention 6 1 September 1974 59 81
- Crinion J. D. Foldvary L. A. Lane J. C. “The Effect on Casualties of a Compulsory Seat Belt Wearing Law in South Australia.” Accident Analysis and Prevention 7 2 June 1975 81 89
- Henderson M. Freedman K. “The Effect of Mandatory Seat Belt Use in New South Wales, Australia.” Seventeenth Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine Oklahoma City November 1973
- Mackay G. M. Gloyns P. F. Hayes H. R. M. Griffiths D. K. Rattenbury S. J. “Serious Trauma to Car Occupants Wearing Seat Belts” Second International Conference of the International Research Committee on the Biokinetics of Impact Birmingham September 1975
- Henderson J. M. Wyllie J. M. “Seat Belts - Limits of Protection: A Study of Fatal Injuries Among Belt Wearers.” Paper 730964, Seventeenth Stapp Car Crash Conference Oklahoma City November 1973
- Shiels A. C. Watson L. G. “How Many Needed to Die?.” Nineteenth Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine San Diego November 1975
- Mackay G. M. “Airbag Effectiveness - A Case for the Compulsory Use of Seat Belts.” Fourteenth International Automobile Technical Congress of FISITA London June 1972
- Warner C. Y. “Belt Occupant Restraint Effectiveness.” Seventeenth Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine Oklahoma City November 1973
- Huelke D. F. Gikas P. W. “Causes of Deaths in Automobile Accidents.” Journal of the American Medical Association 203 13 25th March 1968 1100 1107
- Huelke D. F. Gikas P. W. “How Do They Die? Medical Engineering Data from On-Scene Investigations of Fatal Automobile Accidents.” Paper 650039 , Society of Automotive Engineers Transactions 74 1966 212 216
- Ryan G. A. “A Study of Seat Belts and Injuries.” Paper 730965, Seventeenth Stapp Car Crash Conference Oklahoma City, Oklahoma November 1973
- Herbert D. C. Stott J. C. Corben C. W. “Head Space Requirements for Seat Belt Wearers.” Paper 751164, Nineteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference San Diego November 1975
- Huelke D. F. Sherman H. W. O'Day J. “The Hazard of the Unrestrained Occupant.” Eighteenth Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine Toronto September 1974
- Henderson M. Sims A. “Heavy Vehicle Crash Injury.” Traffic Accident Research Unit, Department of Motor Transport New South Wales January 1970
- Smith H. P. Ruffell “A Study of Fatal Injuries in Vehicle Collisions Based on Coroners' Reports.” Road Research Laboratory, Ministry of Transport U.K. 1970
- Croney D. Watkins L. H. “Heavy Vehicles - Research Aspects.” Journal of the Institution of Highway Engineers XXI 7 July 1974 34 44
- Gissane W. Bull J. “Fatal Car Occupant Injuries After Car/Lorry Collisions.” British Medical Journal 1 13th January 1973 67 71
- Gloyns P. F. Mackay G. M. “Impact Performance of Some Designs of Steering Assembly in Real Accidents and Under Test Conditions.” Paper 741176, Eighteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference Ann Arbor, Michigan December 1974
- Gloyns P. F. Mackay G. M. Chatterjee S. “Post Collision Vehicle Fires.” Department of Transportation and Environmental Planning, University of Birmingham April 1975
- Hartemann F. Tarriere C. Mackay G. M. Gloyns P. F. Hayes H. R. M. Cesari D. Ramet M. “How to Further Improve the Protection of Occupants Wearing Seat Belts.” Nineteenth Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine San Diego November 1975
- Waters P. E. Department of the Environment April 1976