This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
AUTOMOTIVE SEAT DESIGN AND COLLISION PERFORMANCE
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Eighty-five laboratory full-scale force-deflection tests were conducted on passenger vehicle seats, foreign and domestic, for purposes of evaluating specific resistance to a collision environment and mechanisms of collision induced seat distortion. These tests evaluated seats that span the past thirty years; additionally, seat design studies were conducted evaluating basic features of automotive seating during the past eighty years.
Data from full-scale collision experiments and from a large number of actual accidents facilitated the establishment of seat design criteria for greatly improved collision performance. Evolution of seat and head support standards in the United States and Europe are presented with evaluation of their relative significance to the requirements of automotive seat collision performance.
The foregoing research provided foundation for modification of a production automobile seat into an integral safety seat, based on a design concept that minimizes bending moments during collision. The modified seat was subjected to the same laboratory test procedure applied to the 85 non-modified production seats and results of its performance is given.
Design concepts are presented that would serve to mitigate undesirable seat distortions during collision and thus improve seat restraint capabilities without compromising the important factors of comfort and cost.
ALTHOUGH SAFETY IS A BASIC CONSIDERATION in all aspects of automotive engineering, it is a fact of life that safety advances are not uniformly accomplished. Some essential aspects of motorist protection have in the past, and probably will in the future, continue to be greatly outstripped by advances made in other areas. In some instances, the design challenge simply exceeds current technology; on other occasions an adequate safety standard and concerted industry interest can correct obvious safety deficiencies. For example, although improved tires resulted only after new materials evolved, a greatly improved motorist restraining system resulted from industry initiated research that culminated in a standard requiring installation of combination cross chest lap belts for all outboard front seat locations.
During the past 20 years, new materials and techniques have improved the comfort and wear resistance of automotive seats while simultaneously reducing their weight and cost; however, significant safety related improvement in seat design during this period has not been accomplished. A summary of findings from prior research (1)* published in 1966 classified a structurally redesigned Integral Seat with built-in 3-point belt restraint as critically important for reduction of motorist injuries; this summary also pointed out the lack of safety-seat research up to that time. Although some research has been conducted since that time, the development of a safety seat still has not been accomplished. In the same study special devices, including the air bag, were rated as only of moderate relative importance.
After 10 years of government regulated safety standards and nearly that many years of intensive air bag development sponsored by both government and industry, the consensus of many automotive safety researchers in Europe (2), (3) and elsewhere is to change the emphasis back to development of active restraint systems and to increase effectiveness by means of mandatory use laws. Air bags, if used, would serve a supplementary function in conjunction with active systems. Progress in safer seat design has been impeded throughout a decade of automotive safety standard making, and many lives have been lost that could have been fully protected with a fraction of the inventive genius and funding lost to air bag development. A basic common sense approach to motorist protection from collision trauma calls for special attention to design of the critically important structure nearest the motorist, his seat.
A vital consideration of seat design is its capacity to protect motorists, to the extent practical, from all types of collision injury exposures. This paper provides basic design data for crashworthy automotive seat systems with integral active restraints, as determined from the authors' collision research and laboratory studies as well as experience gained from investigation of relevant accidents.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Safer Seat Designs |
Technical Paper | Automotive Seat Design Concepts for Occupant Protection |
Technical Paper | Study of Seat and Head-Support Performance During Full-Scale Rear-End Collisions |
Citation
Severy, D., Blaisdell, D., and Kerkhoff, J., "AUTOMOTIVE SEAT DESIGN AND COLLISION PERFORMANCE," SAE Technical Paper 760810, 1976, https://doi.org/10.4271/760810.Also In
References
- Severy D. M. “Collision Performance of the Motorist's Compartment,” Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan Ann Arbor, Michigan April 1967
- “Fifth International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles,” U. S. Department of Transportation Washington, D.C. U.K. Department of the Environment London, England 1974
- Langwieder K. “Car Crash Collision Types and Passenger Injuries in Dependency Upon Car Construction,” Sixteenth Stapp Conference, SAE No. 720968 Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, Pennsylvania 15096 1972
- States J. D. et al “Injury Frequency and Head Restraint Effectiveness in Rear-end Impact Accidents,” Sixteenth Stapp Conference, SAE No. 720967 Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, Pennsylvania 15096 1972
- Severy D. M. Brink H. M. Baird J. D. “Collision Performance L.M. Safety Car,” SAE No. 670458 , presented at SAE Mid-year Meeting Chicago, Illinois May 1967
- Severy D. M. Brink H. M. Baird J. D. Blaisdell D. M. “Safer Seat Design,” SAE No. 690812 , Proceedings of Thirteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference Harvard School of Public Health December 1969
- Babbs F. W. Hilton B. C. “The Packaging of Car Occupants - A British Approach to Seat Design,” Proceedings of Seventh Stapp Car Crash Conference University of California Los Angeles, California October 1963
- Severy D. M. Brink H. M. Baird J. D. Blaisdell D. M. “Active Versus Passive Motorist Restraints,” SAE No. 70024, International Automobile Safety Conference Compendium Detroit, Michigan May 1970 Brussels June 1970
- Severy D. M. Brink H. M. Baird J. D. “School Bus Passenger Protection SAE No. 670040 , Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit, Mchigan January 1967
- Siegel A. W. Nahum A. M. Runge D. E. “Bus Collision Causation and Injury Patterns,” SAE No. 710860 , Proceedings of Fifteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, Pennsylvania 15096 1971
- Clark C. Blechschmidt C. “Human Transportation Fatalities and Protection Against Rear and Side Crash Loads by the Airstop Restraint,” Proceedings of Ninth Stapp Car Crash Conference Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, Pennsylvania 15096 1965
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration “49 CFR Part 571 (Docket No. 74-13; Notice 1), Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards,” Federal Register 39 54 Washington, D.C. March 1974
- Severy D. M. Mathewson J. H. Siegel A. W. “Automobile Head-on Collisions, Series II,” SAE Transactions Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, Pennsylvania 15096 1959
- Severy D. M. Brink H. M. Baird J. D. “Backrest and Head Restraint Design for Rear-end Collision Protection,” SAE No. 680079 , presented SAE Congress Detroit, Michigan January 1968
- Patrick L. M. et al “Impact Dynamics of Vehicle Occupants,” Tenth Stapp Conference Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, Pennsylvania 15096 1966
- Preston F. “A Comparison of Contacts for Unrestrained and Lap Belted Occupants in Automobile Accidents,” Seventeenth Conference American Association for Automotive Medicine 801 Green Bay Road, Lake Bluff, Illinois 60044
- Melvin J. W. McElhaney J. H. Roberts V. L. Portnoy H. D. “Deployable Head Restraints - A Feasibility Study,” SAE No. 710853 , Fifteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, Pennsylvania 15096 1971
- McElhaney J. H. Stalnaker R. L. Roberts V. L. Snyder R. G. “Door Crashworthiness Criteria,” SAE No. 710864 , Fifteenth Stapp Conference Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, Pennsylvania 15096 1971
- Severy D. M. Brink H. M. Baird J. D. “Passenger Protection from Front-end Impacts,” SAE No. 690068 , International Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit, Michigan January 1969
- Huelke D. F. Marsh J. C. et al “Injury Causation in Rollover Accidents,” Proceedings of Seventeenth Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 1973
- Hight P. V. Siegel A. W. Nahum A. M. “Injury Mechanisms in Rollover Collisions,” SAE No. 720966 , Sixteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, Pennsylvania 15096 1972