This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Critical Assessment of the Use of Non-Human Responding Surrogates for Safety System Evaluation
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1976 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The basic physical mechanisms underlying recent experimentally observed anomalous behavior in the impact performance of safety helmets evaluated with soft (human-like) and hard (magnesium alloy) headform surrogates are qualitatively and quantitatively explained in this paper. The principal and physical mechanisms brought to light in the headform surrogate investigation are directly applicable to the utilization of other forms of surrogates (head -neck, thorax, whole body). In particular the results raise a serious question as to the validity of using non-human responding surrogates, with human generated injury tolerance data, for the purpose of assessing safety system performance. The implications of the results are that good crash-impact protective devices (helmets, restraints, etc.) could be penalized and, equally important, less safe crash-impact protective system designs could result from improper assessment of safety system performance.
CitationSaczalski, K., States, J., Wagar, I., and Richardson, E., "A Critical Assessment of the Use of Non-Human Responding Surrogates for Safety System Evaluation," SAE Technical Paper 760805, 1976, https://doi.org/10.4271/760805.
- Dunham T. D., Astleford W. J., Sissung M. A., Nagy A., Yeahley L. M., “Safety Helmet Performance Investigation” Volume 1, Southwest Research Institute Report DOT HS-801 429, Nov. 1974.
- -- “Development of Criteria for Industrial and Firefighters' Head Protective Devices,” National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) research report, HEW publication No. (NIOSH) 75-125, 1975.
- Hodgson V. R., “National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment Football Helmet Certification Program,” Medicine and Science in Sports, Vol. 7, No. 3, pp. 225-232, 1975.
- -- “Motorcycle Accident Investigation and Effect of Helmet, ” Japanese Council of Traffic Science Report, Nov. 1975.
- Stalnaker R. L., McElhaney J. H., Roberts V. L., “MSC Tolerance Curve for Head Impacts,” ASME Preprint - WA/BHF-10, Nov. 1971.
- Hodgson V. R., Patrick L. M., “Dynamic Response of the Human Cadaver Head Compared to a Simple Mathematical Model,” The 12th STAPP Car Crash Conference, 1968.
- Saczalski K. J., “Modeling and Analysis Techniques for Prediction of Structural and Biodynamic Crash-Impact Response,” Proceedings of the ASME Applied Mechanics Division Symposium on Finite-Element Analysis of Transient Nonlinear Structural Behavior, AMD Vol. 14, Nov. 1975.
- Stricklin J., Haisler W., “Development of AGGIE, a General Purpose, 3-D, Non-linear Finite-Element Structures Program, ” Texas A&M University Progress Report to Office of Naval Research, Code 474, May 1976.
- King A. I., Chou C. C., “Mathematical Modelling, Simulation and Experimental Testing of Biomechanical System Crash Response,” AIAA Paper 75-272, presented at 11th Annual AIAA Meeting, Washington, D. C., Feb. 25, 1975.
- Hodgson V. R., Thomas L. M., “Head Impact Response,” SAE, Vehicle Research Institute Report VRI-7. 2, 1975.
- Hardy C. H., Marcel P. V., “Elastic Analysis of a Human Skull, ” Brown Univ., Division of Engineering Report No. 8, to the Office of Naval Research, Nov. 1971.
- Khalil T. B., Goldsmith W., Sackman J. L., “Impact On a Model Head-Helmet System,” Int. J. Mech. Sci., Vol. 16, pp. 609-625, 1974.
- Brooks J. D., Rey L. G., “Polystyrene-Urethane Composite Foam for Crash Padding Applications,” J. of Cellular Plastics, September/October 1973, pp. 232-234.
- Kimball C. E., DeHart R. C., “Energy-Absorbing Materials for Improving Helicopter Crashworthiness, ” Southwest Research Institute Report to Office Of Naval Research, March 1976.
- Nagy A., Ko W. L., Lindholm U. S., “Mechanical Behavior of Foamed Materials Under Dynamic Compression”, Southwest Research Institute Report, project no. 02-9062, June 1973.
- Evans F. G., Lissner H. R., “Tensile and Compressive Strength of Human Parietal Bone,” J. of Applied Physiology, Vol. 10, pp. 493-497, 1957.