This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Deposits, Wear, and Catalyst Performance with Low Ash and Ashless Engine Oils
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
To meet exhaust emission standards, nearly all 1975 model U. S. passenger cars use catalytic converters in conjunction with unleaded gasoline. While it has been established that lead and phosphorus from gasoline are deleterious to catalyst performance, much less is known about any similar effect of elements normally present in conventional engine oils. In addition, the ability to protect engines from excessive deposits and wear is essentially unproved for engine oils in which the phosphorus and metals contents have been either reduced (low ash oils) or eliminated (ashless oils).
To obtain catalyst and engine performance information on such oils, tests were run using 95, 1972-1973 model passenger cars, operated with unleaded gasoline in several types of service. Forty cars were equipped with 1975 production-prototype underfloor catalytic converters containing pelleted oxidation catalysts.
Neither exhaust emissions nor catalyst conversion efficiency were affected by using either a low ash or an ashless oil instead of a conventional oil. However, oil consumption was less than typical for such service, so the effect of oil additives on catalyst durability may have been proportionately less.
Five experimental ashless oils were all deficient in engine performance in varying degrees, compared to conventional commercial SE-quality oils, with respect to cam and lifter wear, oil ring sticking, and piston varnish deposits.
It is concluded that reduction in phosphorus or metals content of current, conventional, commercial oils does not appear to be necessary to meet current exhaust emission standards with current General Motors (GM) catalyst systems. However, development of ashless oil technology should continue in the event such oils are necessary to meet future, more stringent engine or emission requirements.
Authors
Topic
Citation
Pless, L., "Deposits, Wear, and Catalyst Performance with Low Ash and Ashless Engine Oils," SAE Technical Paper 750900, 1975, https://doi.org/10.4271/750900.Also In
References
- Gagliardi J. C. Smith C. S. Weaver E. E. “Effect of Fuel and Oil Additives on Catalytic Converters.” Paper 63-72 API Division of Refining Midyear Meeting New York May 1972
- Gallopoulos N. E. Summers J. C. Klimisch R. L. “Effects of Engine Oil Composition on the Activity of Exhaust Emissions Oxidation Catalysts.” SAE Transactions 82 1973 paper 730598
- McConnell R. J. McDonnell T. F. “Fuel and Lubricant Effects on Oxidizing Catalysts.” Paper 730597 SAE Automobile Engineering Meeting Detroit May 1973
- Bouffard R. A. Waddey W. E. “Lube Effects on Exhaust Gas Oxidation Catalyst Activity.” Paper 740135 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit February 1974
- Giacomazzi R. A. Homfeld M. F. “The Effect of Lead, Sulfur, and Phosphorus on the Deterioration of Two Oxidizing Bead-Type Catalysts.” SAE Transactions 82 1973 paper 730595
- SAE Recommended Practice, Engine Oil Performance and Engine Service Classification - SAE J183a
- Miles D. L. Faix L. J. Lyon H. H. Niepoth G. W. “Catalytic Emission Control System Field Test Program.” Paper 750179 presented at SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit February 1975
- Pless L. G. “A Study of Lengthened Engine Oil-Change Intervals.” SAE Transactions 83 1974 paper 740139
- Pless L. G. “The Effects of Some Engine, Fuel, and Oil Additive Factors on Engine Rusting in Short-Trip Service.” SAE Transactions 79 1970 paper 700457
- Pless L. G. “Effects of Some Engine, Fuel, and Oil Parameters on Engine Rusting in Short-Trip Service.” Institute of Petroleum Symposium on Performance Testing of Lubricants for Automotive Engines and Transmissions Montreux, Switzerland April 1973
- Federal Register 37 221 November 15 1972 24250
- Meyers A. T. “Field Service Compatibility of Ashless and Fully Compounded Engine Oils with Two Bead Type Oxidation Catalysts.” Paper 750448 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit February 1975
- “Rust Rating Manual,” CRC Manual No. 7 Coordinating Research Council, Inc. New York July 1967
- “CRC Deposit Rating Scales,” CRC Manual No. 1 Coordinating Research Council, Inc. New York January 1955
- “Sludge Rating Manual,” CRC Manual No. 10 Coordinating Research Council, Inc. New York January 1969
- Lipson C. Sheth N. J. “Statistical Design and Analysis of Engineering Experiments.” New York: McGraw-Hill 1973
- Robins A. R. D. Gergel W. C. “Low-Ash Motor Oils - Performance in the Laboratory and Field.” Paper 740141 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit February 1974
- Benson B. J. D. “Some Factors Which Affect Octane Requirement Increase.” Paper 750933 SAE Automobile Engineering Meeting Detroit October 1975
- Orrin C. D. S. Miner W. R. Kipp K. L. “Unleaded Gasoline - Lubricant Requirements and Fuel Additive Performance.” SAE Transactions 81 1972 paper 720689