This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Role of Vehicle Handling in Accident Causation
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
This paper reports the results of a study designed to investigate the relation between vehicle handling and accident frequency. Because evaluation of the driver control process can only be made on a subjective basis, emphasis is placed on evaluating the role of the vehicle rather than the man-car combination.
Deficiencies in handling are likely to be associated with accidents involving loss of control, and it is shown that over 80 percent of loss of control accidents involve single vehicles only. This means that the single vehicle accident rate can be used as a measure of proneness of loss of control. Single vehicle accident rates are determined by model of car and the effect on these rates of other factors, such as variations in driver age and ratio of male to female driver population between the different models, are assessed. This allows accident rates to be established which are, to a large extent, independent of driver effects, so that their relation with vehicle handling performance can be directly assessed.
In selecting parameters with which to evaluate the role of the vehicle, emphasis is placed on simplicity of measurement to allow as many different models of car as possible to be included in the study. Accordingly, simple design parameters as well as more complex vehicle response parameters are considered.
Multiple regression techniques are used to establish the relative importance of handling response parameters when compared to driver effects and also to decide which are the most appropriate parameters to consider. The results show that in explaining the variation in the accident rate between different models of car, driver effects account for as much as 70 percent; if driver effects are removed from the accident rate then handling parameters explain about 35-40 percent of the remaining variation between models of car. The important parameters appear to be weight, a measure of the change in understeer as a function of lateral acceleration and power to weight ratio.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Development of Motor Vehicle Handling Performance Requirements |
Technical Paper | Considerations in Determining Vehicle Handling Requirements |
Technical Paper | Vehicle Transient Response Based on Human Sensitivity |
Authors
Citation
Jones, I., "The Role of Vehicle Handling in Accident Causation," SAE Technical Paper 750115, 1975, https://doi.org/10.4271/750115.Also In
References
- Jones I. S. “Road accident studies with particular reference to the handling and stability characteristics of cars.” University of London 1973
- Quenault S. W. “Driver behavior - safe and unsafe drivers - II.” Ministry of Transport RRL Report LR 146 Crowthorne 1968
- Munden J. M. “The accident rates of car drivers by age.” Int. Rd. Saf. Traffic. Rev. 1966 14 1 28 9
- “Passenger Transport in Great Britain 1967.” National Travel Survey 1965 London H.M.S.O. 1969
- Bull J. P. Roberts B. J. “Road accident statistics - a comparison of police and hospital information.” Accident Analysis and Prevention 5 1 April 1973
- Nordeen D. L. “Vehicle handling: Its dependence on vehicle parameters.” S.A.E. Paper No. 5404 964 1969
- Hales F. D. “Vehicle handling qualities.” Proc. Inst. Mech. Engrs. 184 12 1969-70
- Consumers Association “Handling Procedure.” February 1972 The Control Towers Gosfield Airfield, Gosfield, Essex February 1972
- Barter N. F. “Measurement of vehicle handling by tethered testing.” Proc. Inst. Mech. Engrs. 1970
- Milliken W. F. Whitcomb D. W. “Research in automobile stability and control and in tire performance.” Proc. Auto. Div. Instn. Mech. Engrs. 7 1956-57 287
- Barter N. L. Little J. “The handling and stability of motor vehicles, Part 7. Frequency Response Measurements and Their Analysis.” MIRA Report No. 1970/10 1970
- Stratton D. “Measurement and Analysis of Vehicle Handling.” Towards a safer road vehicle, TRRL meeting 1972
- Koiter W. T. Pacejka H. B. “Skidding of vehicles due to locked wheels.” Proc. Inst. Mech. Engrs. 183 1968-69 3 18
- Davies O. L. Goldsmith P. L. “Statistical methods in Research and Production.” Tweedale Court, Edinburgh Oliver and Boyd 1972
- Fryer H. C. “Concepts and Methods of Experimental Statistics.” Boston Allyn and Bacon, Inc. 1966