This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Occupant Safety and Damageability Considerations Related to the 1974 Automobile Bumpers
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1974 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This paper reports on research which examined the effectiveness of 1974 automobile bumpers in terms of occupant safety and automobile damageability. Static and dynamic tests were performed by attaching a height measuring device on the front and rear bumpers of 1974 domestic automobiles. The static test results showed effective bumper height match. The dynamic test results showed that 21% of bumpers could mismatch when the rear (colliding) vehicle is pitched due to braking and 77% of bumpers could mismatch when both vehicles are pitched due to braking.
Occupant safety is discussed in terms of both the positive and negative effects of the new bumpers for all collision speeds. The effect on override/underride collision frequency and passive restraint (air bag) system activation is examined. The tradeoffs of decreased frequency of damage to vehicles and increased costs to replace the new bumpers when they are damaged in high speed collisions are discussed.
Conclusions are that any resultant gain in occupant safety as a result of the new bumpers is debatable and that there are no significant overall economic gains at this time. In addition, existing regulations that will become operative in the near future do not appear to provide an effective solution because of the multiplicity of factors which are involved.
CitationAppleby, M., "Occupant Safety and Damageability Considerations Related to the 1974 Automobile Bumpers," SAE Technical Paper 740989, 1974, https://doi.org/10.4271/740989.
- Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard 215, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 1972.
- California Vehicle Code, 1972 Edition, Section 34715.
- Status Report, Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, February 1974.
- Economic Analysis of the Exterior Protection Standard, FMVSS 215, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 1971.
- Hughey, M. Stanley, Comments to National Highway Traffic Safety Administration regarding the proposed bumper standard, Kemper Insurance Co., 1973.
- Personal communication with Segal Leonard, Univ. of Michigan, Highway Safety Research Institute, January 1974.
- Appleby M. R. and Morris A. G. R., “Automobile Damageability and Insurance Costs.” Paper 740305 presented at SAE Southern California Section, Los Angeles, May 1973.
- Laboratory Test Procedures, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Contract Number DOT-HS-066-3-782.
- Appleby M. R., Bischoff D. C., Siegel A. W., and Nahum A. M., “Injuries in Underride-Override Collisions-A Clinical Study.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 79 (1970), paper 700483.
- Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard 301, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
- Notice of Proposed Rule Making, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Bumper Standard, Federal Register, Vol. 38, No. 149 (August 3, 1973).
- “Automobile Insurance Losses, Collision Coverages-Initial Results for 1973 Models Compared with 1972 Models.” Highway Loss Data Institute, Research Report R73-1, September 1973.