This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Gasoline Lead Additive and Cost Effects of Potential 1975-1976 Emission Control Systems
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1973 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
A study was conducted in 1971 to assess the overall effects of lead additives in gasoline on the performance, durability, and costs of emission control devices/systems which might be used to meet the 1975-1976 federal emission standards for light-duty motor vehicles. Although no system has yet demonstrated meeting the 50,000-mile emission level lifetime, all currently planned 1975-1976 emission control systems include a catalytic converter. However, lead additives are toxic to catalytic materials; they reduce catalytic activity, which results in increasing emission levels with mileage accumulation. Unleaded gasoline would be required in quantities sufficient to satisfy the demands of vehicles equipped with a catalytic converter in order to prevent catalyst activity degradation from lead additives. Implementation of such advanced emission control systems implies very high cost to the consumer, with the cost being a strong function of the required NOx emission level. At this time, estimated overall costs to the consumer (initial, maintenance, and operating) for emission control systems being considered for the 1976 federal emission standards are $860 above average 1970 vehicle costs, over an 85,000-mile vehicle lifetime. This estimate is based on a system incorporating a dual (HC/CO, NOx) catalytic converter, a low-grade rich thermal reactor, and exhaust gas recirculation. This system is currently considered to have the most promise to meet the 1976 NOx standard of 0.4 g/mile.
CitationHinton, M., Iura, T., Meltzer, J., and Somers, J., "Gasoline Lead Additive and Cost Effects of Potential 1975-1976 Emission Control Systems," SAE Technical Paper 730014, 1973, https://doi.org/10.4271/730014.
- Public Law 90-148, The Clean Air Act, as amended.
- “Control of Air Pollution from New Motor Vehicles and New Motor Vehicle Engines.” Federal Register, Vol. 36, No. 128, July 2, 1971.
- Progress and Programs in Automotive Emissions Control, Progress Report to the Environmental Protection Agency, General Motors Corp., March 12, 1971.
- American Motors Corp., letter in response to request from Administrator, Environmental Protection Agency, Subject: Regarding Requirements of the Clean Air Act, April 2, 1971.
- Misch H. L., Vice President - Engineering, Ford Motor Co., statement to the Environmental Protection Agency, May 6, 1971.
- Chrysler Corp., letter in response to request from administrator, Environmental Protection Agency, Subject: Regarding Emission Control, April 1, 1971.
- “An Assessment of the Effects of Lead Additives in Gasoline on Emission Control Systems Which Might Be Used to Meet the 1975-76 Motor Vehicle Emission Standards.” Final Report. Report No. TOR-0172 (2787) - 2, The Aerospace Corp., El Segundo, Calif., Nov. 15, 1971.
- Yaneko Y., et al., “Small Engine-Concept Emission Vehicles.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 80 (1971), paper 710296.
- “Exhaust Manifold Thermal Reactor Development at Du Pont.” Petroleum Chem. Div.: Wilmington, Del., Jan. 20, 1971.
- Lang R. J., “A Well-Mixed Thermal Reactor System for Automotive Emission Control.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 80 (1971), paper 710608.
- Meguerian G. H. and Lang C. R., “NOx Reduction Catalysts for Vehicle Emission Control.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 80(1971), paper 710291.
- Nebel G. J. and Bishop R. W., “Catalytic Oxidation of Automobile Exhaust Gases.” Paper 29-R presented at SAE Annual Meeting, Detroit, January 1959.
- Campau R. M., “Low Emission Concept Vehicles.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 80 (1971), paper 710294.
- Jagel K. I. and Dwyer F. G., “HC/CO Oxidation Catalysts for Vehicle Exhaust Emission Control.” Published in SP-361, “Inter-Industry Emission Control.” New York: Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., 1971, paper 710290.
- Allen R. R. and Gerhold C. G., “Catalytic Converters for New and Current (Used) Vehicles.” Paper presented at the Fifth Technical Meeting, West Coast Section of Air Pollution Control Assn., San Francisco, Oct. 8-9, 1970.
- Barth W. J. and Cantwell E. N., “Automotive Exhaust Manifold Thermal Reactors-Materials Considerations.” Presented before Div. of Petroleum Chemistry, Inc., 161st Meeting of the American Chem. Soc., Los Angeles, March 28 - April 2, 1971.
- Jaimee A., et al., “Thermal Reactor - Design, Development and Performance.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 80 (1971), paper 710923.
- Oldrieve R. E. and Stone P. L., Letter Report on the Current Status of the NASA/Lewis Program for Evaluation and Development of Materials for Automobile Thermal Reactors. Materials and Structures Div., NASA/Lewis Research Center, Cleveland, April 30, 1971.
- The Ethyl Lean Reactor System, Ethyl Corp. Research Lab., Detroit, July 1, 1971.
- Personal discussion with representatives of General Motors Corp., June 30, 1971.
- Personal discussion with representatives of Ford Motor Co., July 1, 1971.
- Personal discussion with representatives of Chrysler Corp., June 29, 1971.
- Personal discussion with representatives of American Motors Corp., Sept. 29, 1971.
- Misch H. L., Vice President - Engineering, Ford Motor Co., Testimony before Calif. Air Resources Board, Sacramento, March 4, 1970.
- Musser G. S., et al., “Effectiveness of Exhaust Gas Recirculation with Extended Uses.” Paper 710013 presented at SAE Automotive Engineering Congress, Detroit, January 1971.
- 1968/Automobile Facts/Figures Report, Automobile Mfrs. Assn., Inc., Detroit, 1968.
- Car Maintenance Expense When Using Leaded and Nonleaded Gasoline, Ethyl Corp., Detroit, July 2, 1971.
- Giles W., “Valve Problems with Lead Free Gasoline.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 80 (1971), paper 710368.
- Godfrey D. and Courtney R. L., “Investigation of the Mechanism of Exhaust Valve Seat Wear in Engines Run on Unleaded Gasoline.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 80 (1971), paper 710356.
- Schwochert H. W., “Performance of a Catalytic Converter on Nonleaded Gasoline.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 78 (1969), paper 690503.
- Consequences of Removing Lead Antiknocks from Gasoline, A Status Report, No. AC-10, Ethyl Corp., New York, August 1970.
- Felt A. E. and Kerley R. V., “Engines and Effects of Lead-Free Gasoline.” Paper 710367 presented at SAE Mississippi Valley Section, October 1970.
- “Effect of Lead Antiknocks on the Performance and Costs of Advanced Emission Control Systems.” Wilmington, Del.: Du Pont de Nemours & Co., July 15, 1971.
- De Palma T. V., “The Application of Catalytic Converters to the Problems of Automotive Exhaust Emissions.” Paper presented to Interpetrol Congress, Rome, Italy, June 24, 1971.
- Engelhard Industries, Inc., letter to Aerospace Corp., Oct. 13, 1971.
- Thompson J. C., “Exhaust Emissions from a Passenger Car Equipped with a Universal Oil Products Catalytic Converter.” Air Pollution Control Office, Environmental Protection Agency, December 1970.
- “The Ethyl Lean Reactor System.” Ethyl Corp. Research Labs., Detroit, July 1, 1971.
- Jaimee A., Schneider D. E., Rozmanith A. I., and Sjoberg J. W., “Thermal Reactor-Design, Development and Performance.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 80 (1971), paper 710293.
- Personal discussion with representatives of General Motors Corp., September 1971.
- Burke C. E., American Motors Corp., letter to Aerospace Corp., Sept. 29, 1971.
- Conversation with Simpson B., Ford Motor Co., October 1971.
- Somers J. H., Office of Air Programs, Environmental Protection Agency, Letter to Aerospace Corp., Subject: Discussion with Dr. G. Meguerian, Oct. 7, 1971.
- Simpson B., Ford Motor Co., letter to Aerospace Corp., Sept. 15, 1971.
- Butler R. C., Du Pont de Nemours & Co., letter to Office of Air Programs, Environmental Protection Agency, Aug. 30, 1971.
- Musser G. S., et al., “Effectiveness of Exhaust Gas Recirculation with Extended Use.” Paper 710013 presented at SAE Automotive Engineering Congress, Detroit, January 1971.
- Bowditch F. W., Director, Automotive Emission Control, General Motors Corp., letter to Administrator, Environmental Protection Agency, Subject: Comments on Notice of Proposed Rule-Making for NOx on 1973 New Motor Vehicles, Federal Register of 27 February 1971, Vol. 36, No. 40, Apr. 28, 1971.
- Bernstein L. S., et al., “Application of Catalysts to Automotive NOx Emissions Control.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 80 (1971) paper 710014.
- Personal discussion with representatives of Chrysler Corp., June 29, 1971.
- Personal discussion with representative of Esso Research and Engrg. Co., July 6, 1971.
- Chapter 3: Mobile Sources, “The Economics of Clean Air.” Report of Administrator of Environmental Protection Agency to Congress of United States, Senate Document No. 92-6, March 1971.
- Personal discussion with representative of Research Triangle Inst., unpublished data, Aug. 6, 1971. The Economics of Clean Air, Annual Report of Administrator of Environmental Protection Agency to Congress of United States, February 1972.
- Personal discussion with representatives of Engelhard Industries, Inc., July 1971.
- Bernstein L. S., Raman A. K. S., and Wigg E. E., “The Control of Automotive Emissions with Dual Bed Catalyst Systems.” Presented to 1971 Central States Section of Combustion Institute, Mar. 23, 1971.
- Yolles R. S., Wise H., and Berriman L. P., “Study of Catalytic Control of Exhaust Emissions for Otto Cycle Engines.” Stanford Research Inst., Final Report, SRI Project PSU-8028, April 1970.
- Automotive News-1971 Almanac, 35th Review and Reference Ed., Detroit: Slocum Publishing Co., Apr. 26, 1971.
- “Relationships of Passenger Car Age and Other Factors to Miles Driven.” U. S. Department of Transportation, Bureau of Public Roads, Washington, D. C.
- “Consequences of Removing Lead Antiknocks from Gasoline. A Status Report.” Detroit: Ethyl Corp., No. AC-10, August 1970.
- “Passenger Cars: Oil, Automotive Trends.” 1971 National Petroleum News Factbook Issue.
- Personal discussion with representatives of Du Pont de Nemours & Co., regarding their winter and summer gasoline surveys, October 1971.
- “Economic Analysis of Proposed Schedules for Removal of Lead Additives from Gasoline.” Houston, Texas: Bonner & Moore Assoc., Inc., June 25, 1971.
- Corner E. S. and Cunningham A. R., “Value of High Octane Number Unleaded Gasolines in the United States.” Presented before Division of Water, Air, and Waste Chemistry, American Chem. Soc., Los Angeles, Mar. 28-Apr. 2, 1971.
- Regulations of Fuels and Fuel Additives, Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, Federal Register, 37, 36, 40 CFR part 80, Feb. 23, 1972.