This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Injury Frequency and Head Restraint Effectiveness in Rear-End Impact Accidents
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
All of the rear-end impact accidents occurring in the city of Rochester, New York, in a three-month period were surveyed by tabulation of the police accident reports. Special police information forms, telephone interviews, and mail questionnaires were used for further data acquisition. Vehicle photographs and medical examinations were conducted for approximately every 20th vehicle.
During the data collection period, 691 rear-end impacts occurred. Although a computer program revealed 1371 accidents, defects in the program accounted for the large difference. Whiplash injury frequency based on telephone interview and mail questionnaire data obtained one to seven days after the accident revealed a whiplash injury frequency of 38%, which was approximately twice that determined by on-scene police investigators. Head restraints reduced whiplash frequency by 14% and fixed head restraints appeared to be more effective. Seventy percent of adjustable head restraints were in the downmost position. Women sustained whiplash injury more frequently (51%) but benefited from head restraints more (whiplash injury frequency 38%).
An extensive review of the literature related to whiplash injury and head restraint design and effectiveness is presented.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Statistical Approach to a Model-based Anthropometry Description |
Technical Paper | Development of a Biofidelic ‘Legform’ Impact Test Device |
Technical Paper | Safety Considerations in Design of New Transit Bus Seats |
Authors
- John D. States - Research Accident Investigation, University of Rochester
- John C. Balcerak - Research Accident Investigation, University of Rochester
- James S. Williams - Research Accident Investigation, University of Rochester
- Alexander T. Morris - Research Accident Investigation, University of Rochester
- William Babcock - Research Accident Investigation, University of Rochester
- Robert Polvino - Research Accident Investigation, University of Rochester
- Paul Riger - Research Accident Investigation, University of Rochester
- Raymond E. Dawley - Research Accident Investigation, University of Rochester
Citation
States, J., Balcerak, J., Williams, J., Morris, A. et al., "Injury Frequency and Head Restraint Effectiveness in Rear-End Impact Accidents," SAE Technical Paper 720967, 1972, https://doi.org/10.4271/720967.Also In
References
- “Accident Facts 1970.” National Safety Council 47
- Monroe County Sheriff's Office 1968
- Carlson W. L. “AID Analysis of National Accident Summary.” HIT Lab Reports October 1971
- New York State Department of Motor Vehicles 1970
- Ford Motor Co., Automotive Research Office March 1970
- Mackay G. M. “Some Features of Traffic Accidents.” British Medical Jrl. 4 December 27 1969 799 801
- “Accident Facts 1971.” National Safety Council
- McNab I. 1963
- Crowe K. “Letter to Tribune.” Medical Tribune December 21 1962
- Ghiardi J. D. “Letter to Tribune.” Medical Tribune October 25 1965
- Braunstein R. W. Moore J. O. “The Fallacy of the Term Whiplash.” Amer. Jrl. Surgery 97 1959 522 529
- Ellerbroek W. L. “Whiplash Injuries and Cervical Pain.” Headache 6 1966 73 77
- Manning G. C. “Letter to Editor.” Jrl. AMA 206 1968 2320
- McNab I. “Acceleration Injuries of the Cervical Spine.” Jrl. Bone and Joint Surgery 46A 1964 1797 1799
- McNab I. “Whiplash Injuries of the Neck.” Proceedings Annual Meeting Amer. Assoc. for Automotive Medicine 1965 11 15
- Wickstrom J. D. Martinez J. L. Johnston D. Tappen N. C. “Acceleration-Deceleration Injuries of the Cervical Spine in Animals.” The Seventh Stapp Car Crash Conference-Proceedings Springfield, Ill. Charles C Thomas 1963 284 301
- Rodriguez R. “Cervical Spine Syndrome in Experimental Acceleration Injuries of the Head and Neck.” The Prevention of Highway Injury HSRI Ann Arbor University of Michigan 1967
- Rodriguez R. Haines D. M. “Hyperextension and Hyperflexion Injuries of the Head and Neck of Primates.” “Neckache and Backache.” Springfield, Ill. Charles C Thomas 1970 108 117
- Luongo M. A. “Pathologist's Sub-Lethal Determinations.” Proceedings of Collision Investigation Methodology Symposium Warrenton, Va. U.S. Department of Transportation, National Highway Safety Bureau, and Automobile Manufacturers Assoc. August 1969
- States J. D. Korn M. W. Massengil J. M. “The Enigma of Whiplash.” New York State Jrl. Medicine 70 24 December 15 1970 2971 2978
- Holbourn A. H. “Mechanics of Head Injuries.” Lancet October 9 1943 438 441
- Ommaya A. K. Hirsch A. E. “Tolerances for Cerebral Concussion from Head Impact and Whiplash in Primates.” Jrl. Biomechanics 4 1971 13 21
- Yarnell P. Ommaya A. K. “Experimental Cerebral Concussion in the Rhesus Monkey.” Bull. New York Academy of Medicine 45 1969 39 45
- Ommaya A. K. Hirsch A. E. Martinez J. L. “The Role of Whiplash in Cerebral Concussion.” Proceedings of Tenth Stapp Car Crash Conference 12 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1966
- Ommaya A. K. Faas F. Yarnell P. “Whiplash and Brain Damage.” Jrl. AMA 204 1968 285 287
- Ommaya A. K. Yarnell P. “Subdural Hematoma of the Whiplash Injury.” Lancet August 2 1969 237 239
- VanGijn J. Wintzen A. R. “Whiplash Injury and Subdural Hematoma.” Lancet September 13 1969 592
- Fan W. R. S. “Internal Head Injury Assessment.” Paper 710870 Proceedings of Fifteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference 39 Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1972
- O'Neill B. Haddon, W. Jr. Kelley A. B. Sorenson W. W. “Automobile Head Restraints: Frequency of Neck Injury Insurance Claims in Relation to the Presence of Head Restraints.” September 1971
- Hiyama K. “Alterations in the Electroencephalogram of Rabbits Following Experimental Whiplash Injuries.” Jrl. Japanese Orthopedic Assoc. 42 1968 1057 1065
- Toglia J. U. Rosenberg T. E. Ronis M. L. “Vestibular and Audiologic Aspects of Whiplash Injury and Head Trauma.” Jrl. Forensic Sciences 14 1969 219 226
- Gibson W. J. “Ocular Findings in Extension Flexion Injuries of the Cervical Spine.” Proceedings Eleventh Annual Meeting Amer. Assoc. for Automotive Medicine Springfield, Ill. Charles C Thomas 1970 228 231
- Roca P. E. “Ocular Manifestations of Whiplash Injuries.” Proceedings Fifteenth Annual Meeting Amer. Assoc. for Automotive Medicine Ann Arbor University of Michigan 1971 308 319
- Yamaji R. Ecta. Soc. Ophthal. JAP 75 2 1971 1052 1055
- DeGravelles, W. D. Jr. Kelley J. H. “Injuries Following Rear End Automobile Collisions.” Springfield, Ill. Charles C Thomas 1969 78 109
- Goff C. W. Alden J. L. Aldes J. A. “Traumatic Cervical Syndrome and Whiplash.” Philadelphia J. P. Lippincott Co. 1969 13 19
- Gurdjian E. S. “Neckache and Backache.” Springfield, Ill. Charles C Thomas 1970 3 7
- Harris W. H. Hamplen D. L. Ojemann R. G. “Traumatic Disruption of Cervical Intervertebral Disc from Hyperextension Injury.” Clinical Orthopedics 60 1967 163 167
- Jaues J. M. Hooshmand H. “Extension Flexion Injuries of the Cervical Spine.” Mayo Clinic Proceedings 40 1965 353 369
- Kulowski J. “Crash Injuries.” Springfield, Ill. Charles C Thomas 1960 181 191
- Rann R. W. Crandall R. H. “Central Spinal Cord Syndrome and Hyperextension Injuries of the Cervical Spine.” Jrl. Bone and Joint Surgery 44A 1962 1415 1422
- Morrison A. “Hyperextension Injury of the Cervical Spine with Rupture of the Esophagus.” Jrl. Bone and Joint Surgery 42B 1960 356 357
- Gissane W. “The Nature, Causes and Prevention of Neck Injuries in Car Occupants.” “Accident Pathology,” National Highway Safety Bureau 1968
- Miller J. W. Schultz L. R. “Paraplegia Associated with Hyperextension Injury to the Cervical Spine.” Amer. Jrl. Surgery 96 1958 618 623
- Kihlberg J. K. “Flexion Torsion Neck Injury in Rear Impacts.” Proceedings Thirteenth Annual Meeting Amer. Assoc. for Automotive Medicine, HSRI Ann Arbor University of Michigan 1969 1 16
- Buck C. A. Dameron F. B. Dow M. J. Skowlund H. B. “Study of Normal Range of Motion in the Neck Utilizing a Bubble Goniometer.” Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 40 1959 390 392
- Glanville A. D. Kreezer G. “The Maximum Amplitude and Velocity of Human Movements in Normal Male Human Adults.” Human Biology 9 1937 197 211
- Bennett J. G. Bergmanis L. E. Carpenter J. K. Skowlund H. B. “Range of Motion of the Neck.” Jrl. Amer. Physiotherapy Assoc. January 1963 45 47
- Jackson R. “The Positive Findings in Alleged Neck Injuries.” Amer. Jrl. Orthopedics 6 1964 184 187
- Ferlic D. “The Range of Motion of the Normal Cervical Spine.” Hopkins Hospital Bulletin 110 1962
- Gadd C. W. Culver C. C. Nahum A. M. “The Study of Responses and Tolerances of the Neck.” Paper 710856 Proceedings of Fifteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference 39 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1971
- Tuell J. I. Seattle, Washington
- Portnoy H. D. McElhaney J. H. Melvin J. W. Croissant P. D. “Mechanisms of Cervical Spine Injury in Auto Accidents.” Proceedings Fifteenth Conference Amer. Assoc. for Automotive Medicine, HSRI Ann Arbor University of Michigan 1972 58 83
- Ruedemann A. D. “Automobile Safety Device-Head Rest to Prevent Whiplash Injury.” Jrl. AMA 164 1957 1189
- Severy D. M. Brink H. M. Baird J. D. “Backrest and Head Restraint Design for Rear End Collision Protection.” Paper 680079 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit January 1968
- Berton R. J. “Whiplash: Tests of the Influential Variables.” Paper 680080 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit January 1968
- Morris D. F. Garrett J. “Performance Evaluation of Automobile Head Restraints.” Paper 720034 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit January 1972
- Melvin J. W. McElhaney J. H. Roberts V. L. Portnoy H. D. “Deployable Head Restraints-A Feasibility Study.” SAE Transactions 80 1971 paper 710853
- Beatty R. A. “Fracture of Odontoid Process Related to Automobile Head Rests.” Jrl. AMA 11 1970 29
- MDAI Case Number RAI 69 University of Rochester U.S. Department of Commerce Clearinghouse Springfield, Va. 22151 1969
- Fetterman L. E. DeVan F. H. “Automobile Head Restraint Injury.” Jrl. AMA 214 1970 1328
- Simmons C. F. Herting D. N. “Human Neck Strength-Method of Determination.” North American Aviation, Inc., Space and Information Systems Division 1965
- Evans F. G. “Stress and Strain in Bones.” Springfield, Ill. Charles C Thomas 1957
- Yamada H. “Stress Analysis of Individual Tissues.” “Accident Pathology.” Brinkhouse K. M. U.S. Government Printing Office 1968 114 116
- Davis A. G. “Tensile Strength of the Anterior Longitudinal Ligament in Relation to the Treatment of 132 Crash Fractures of the Spine.” Jrl. Bone and Joint Surgery 20 1938 429 438
- Mertz H. J. Patrick L. M. “Strength and Response of the Human Neck.” SAE Transactions 80 1971 paper 710855
- Mertz H. J. Patrick L. M. “Investigation of the Kinematics and Kinetics of Whiplash.” SAE Transactions 76 paper 670919
- Clarke P. D. Gragg C. D. Sprouffske J. F. Trout E. M. “Human Head Linear and Angular Accelerations During Impact.” Paper 710857 Proceedings of Fifteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference 39 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1971
- Furusho H. Yokoya K. Nishino S. Fujiki S. “Analysis of Occupants Movements in Rear End Collisions.” Bull. Japanese Society of Automotive Engineers 1971 150 166
- Higuchi K. Morisawa M. Sato T. “Movement of Automobile Occupants in Collisions.” Bull. Japanese Society of Automotive Engineers 1971 124 133
- Pontius U. “Computer Analysis of the Mechanics of the Cervical Spine.” Computers in Orthopedic Research and Education Atlanta March 23 1972
- Hertzberger H. T. E. “Anthropology of Anthropomorphic Dummies.” Paper 690805 Proceedings of Thirteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference 28 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1969
- Severy D. M. “Human Simulations for Automotive Research.” New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1965
- Ritterrath S. A. “Design and Construction of an Anthropomorphic Dummy.” U.S.A.F. Technical Report 6365 Air Material Command, Wright Patterson Air Force Base Dayton, Ohio February 1951
- Alderson S. Alderson Research Laboratory Stamford, Connecticut 06902
- Aldman B. “Biomechanic Studies in Impact Protection.” A Acta Physiologica Scan. 56 1962
- Mira O. Anthropomorphic Crash Test Dummy Oggle Design Limited Birdshill, Letchworth, Hertfordshire, United Kingdom
- Bloom A. Cichowski W. G. Roberts V. L. “Sophisticated Sam-A New Concept in Dummies.” Paper 680031 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit January 1968
- Terry S. L. “Identical Crashes Yield Wide Ranges in Dummy Data.” Automotive Engineering 79 July 1971 30 32
- Schutt C. H. Dohan C. F. “Neck Injury to Women in Auto Accidents Jrl. AMA 206 1968 2689 2692
- Anthropometry of WAF Basic Trainees and Male Basic Trainees Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Wright Air Development Center July 1963
- Wiggins H. E. Jrl. AMA 207 1969 2284
- Severy D. M. Mathewson J. H. Bechtol C. O. “Controlled Automobile Rear End Collisions, An Investigation of Related Engineering and Medical Phenomena.” Medical Aspects of Traffic Accidents-Proceedings of the Montreal Conference Montreal Traffic Accident Foundation for Medical Research 1955 152 184
- Braunstein V. W. Moore J. O. “Misuse of the Term Whiplash Injury.” Amer. Jrl. Surgery 97 1959 522 529
- Gotten N. “Survey of 100 Cases of Whiplash Injury After Settlement of Litigation.” Jrl. AMA 162 1959 865 867
- Martinez J. L. “Head Rest and Seat Back Design Proposals.” Paper 680775 Proceedings of Twelfth Stapp Car Crash Conference 26 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1968
- Gurdjian E. S. Lange W. A. Patrick L. M. Thomas L. M. “Impact Injury and Crash Protection Springfield, Ill. Charles C Thomas 1970
- Gilbert M. M. Amer. Assoc. for the Study of Headache, Medical Tribune October 16 1969
- Fell J. Accident Investigation Division, National Highway Traffic Safety Admin.
- Lange W. “Mechanical and Physiological Response of the Human Cervical Vertebral Column to Severe Impacts Applied to the Torso.” Max Planck Institute 46 Dortmund, Germany 1970
- Fell J. August 7 1972