This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Tempered versus HPR Laminated Windshields: A Comparative Study of United Kingdom and United States Collisions
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1970 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Data are presented from two field studies on the collision injuries which result from contact with tempered glass and 0.030 in. (0.76 mm) high penetration resistant (HPR) laminated glass windshields. Two sets of similar automobile collisions are analyzed. The first set consists of European and Japanese cars imported into the United States (in Southern California). The second set is drawn from a study of British cars involved in collisions in England, all of which had tempered windshields.
The frequency and severity of injury from the windshield are given for each set of collisions. Comparisons are made on the basis of vehicle damage and equivalent impact speeds. Examples of the mechanisms of injury for the two types of glass are outlined.
The data presented indicate that tempered windshields give rise to a higher incidence of injury and more severe injuries than the 0.030 in. HPR laminated windshields under similar impact conditions. These differences are statistically significant. The importance of severe injuries from the edges of shattered tempered windshields is discussed, together with injuries which result from the passing of occupants through the plane of the windshield to strike the car hood or cowl.
Eye injuries from the two types of windshields are discussed, together with the effect on the injury mechanisms when the windshield becomes detached during the collision.
CitationMackay, G., Siegel, A., and Hight, P., "Tempered versus HPR Laminated Windshields: A Comparative Study of United Kingdom and United States Collisions," SAE Technical Paper 700911, 1970, https://doi.org/10.4271/700911.
- Hobbs J. A. Allsop R. E. Starks H. J. H. “Injuries Produced by Motor Car Windscreens.” Ministry of Transport R.R.L. Report LR 152 1968
- Fargo R. B. “Windshield Glazing as an Injury Factor in Automobile Accidents.” CAL Report VJ-1823-R25 October 1968
- Huelke D. F. Grabb W. C. Dingman R. O. O'Neal R. M. “The New Automobile Windshield and its Effectiveness in Reducing Facial Lacerations.” J. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery 41 6 1968
- Siegel A. W. Nahum A. M. “Automobile Collisions and the Effects of the New U.S.A. Standards.” Proceedings of Conference on Road Safety Brussels II paper A15 October 1968
- Patrick L. M. Trosien K. R. Dupont F. T. “Comparison of Safety Performance of Solid Tempered and Laminated Windshields.” 1970 International Automobile Safety Conference Compendium 30 paper 700427 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1970
- Mackay G. M. “Some Features of Traffic Accidents.” British Medical Journal 4 Dec. 27 1969 799
- Gissane W. Bull J. P. Roberts Barbara “Sequelae of Road Injuries.” Injury 1 3 January 1970
- McLean A. J. “The Performance of Automobile Glazing in Urban Accidents.” Proceedings of Thirteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference 28 paper 690807 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1969
- Mackay G. M. “Some Collision Aspects of British Road Accidents.” Auto. Engineer 59 13 October 1969 500
- Siegel A. W. “The Vehicle Deformation Index.” Collision Investigation Methodology Symposium Warrenton, Va. CAL August 1969
- Stonex K. A. Nelson W. D. Siegel A. W. Garrett J. W. Michalski C. S. “The Collision Damage Severity Scale.” Paper 700136 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit January 1970
- Mackay G. M. “Injury and Collision Severity.” Proceedings of Twelfth Stapp Car Crash Conference 26 paper 680779 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1968
- States J. D. “The Abbreviated and the Comprehensive Research Injury Scales.” Proceedings of Thirteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference 28 paper 690810 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1969
- Bodinat de B. Krings H. “Le Pare-brise et la Sécurité Routiere.” Proceedings of Conference on Road Safety Brussels II paper A11 October 1968
- Grattan E. Clegg N. G. Hobbs J. A. “Toughened Glass Windscreen Injuries in Car Occupants.” Ministry of Transport R.R.L. Report LR 282 1969
- Holland G. “Eye and Eyelid Injuries from Windshields and Means to Prevent Them.” 1970 International Automobile Safety Conference Compendium 30 paper 700431 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1970
- Pouliquen Y. Defoug D. Paris 29 1 1969 11 16
- Müller-Jensen K. Allmaras W. 153 1968 153
- François J. de Vos E. Geerts L. de Lombaert C. University of Ghent FISITA Conference Brussels June 1970