This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Experimental Impact Protection with Advanced Automotive Restraint Systems: Preliminary Primate Tests with Air Bag and Inertia Reel/Inverted-Y Yoke Torso Harness
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1967 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Both the inverted-Y yoke torso harness with inertia reel and the air bag restraint system have had extensive independent development for some time by several engineering and research organizations for both aviation and ground vehicle occupant protection. The research reported in this paper consists of the first biomechanical primate evaluation of these concepts as experimentally adapted for possible automotive use. These tests are a continuation of a study involving the relative impact protection and effectiveness of major restraint systems utilized in general aviation aircraft and in limited automotive use. The objective of this test series was to determine how much protection those advanced restraint concepts provided; to obtain preliminary biomechanical and physiological data; to identify problems of technique and applications in occupant protection; and to provide an initial basis for direction of future test requirements.
Of 13 tests run in this series, nine tests of Savannah baboons (Papio cynocephalus) were made using a scaled-down air bag restraint system. All were oriented in the forward-facing position (-GX or 0-0-0) and at a 13° seat-back angle. Entrance velocities ranged from 71 ft/sec (33 peak G) at 3000 g/sec onset rate, to 94.2 ft/sec (57 peak G) at 6000 g/sec onset rate. In addition, four tests were conducted with the yoke harness, utilizing inertia reels activated at. 3G. Three of these were in the for ward-facing (-GX body orientation in impacts of 73 to 94.4 ft/sec (30-49 peak G) and 2700 to 6100 g/sec onset rate. In a fourth test, the subject was oriented for a 90° sideward impact at 75.2 ft/sec (32G). Since over 60 tests of baboon subjects now have been conducted with various restraint systems under identical controlled impact conditions, valid relative assessments of the impact injury protection offered by these systems may be made. Documentation included physiological data, restraint loadings, high-speed photography for body kinematics, biological assessments including gross and microscopic autopsy procedures, whole-body X-rays, and pre- and post-run blood analyses for stress and tissue damage determinations. Two air bag tests were run on each profile, and three animals were allowed to survive to monitor any neurological or other post-impact trauma. Conclusions of the relative value of these restraint systems for automotive use to protect occupants during impact are discussed from a biomechanical viewpoint.
CitationSnyder, R., Young, J., and Snow, C., "Experimental Impact Protection with Advanced Automotive Restraint Systems: Preliminary Primate Tests with Air Bag and Inertia Reel/Inverted-Y Yoke Torso Harness," SAE Technical Paper 670922, 1967, https://doi.org/10.4271/670922.
- 1854 “The First Aeronaut” Harpers New Monthly Magazine 8(46):521.
- LOVELACE, W. R., et al: 1945 The Ejection Seat for Emergency Escape from High-Speed Aircraft (USAAF, ATSC, Wright Field) MR-TSEAL-3-696-74C, page 3.
- WILSON, C. L. (Ed.):1959 Project Mercury Candidate Evaluation Program, WADC Tech. Rept. 59-505, p. 24, December 1959.
- STOUDT, H. W., Damon A., McFarland R. and Roberts J.: 1965 Weight, Height and Selected Body Dimensions of Adults, United States, 1960-1962. National Center for Health Statistics, Series 11 No. 8., Washington, D. C.
- Ford Motor Company, 1967, Testing Operations Office, (TSO) Reports of Car Crash Tests. Un-published.
- HASS, G.: 1943 An Analysis of Relations Between Force, Aircraft Structure and Injuries to Personnel Involved in Aircraft Accidents with Recommendations for Safer Principles in Design of Certain Types of Aircraft. School of Aviation Medicine, Prof 187:Rept. No. 1, Randolph AFB, Texas.
- HASBROOK, A. H.: 1953 Crash Survival Study: National Airlines DC-6 Accident at Elizabeth, N. J., on February 11, 1952. Cornell University Medical College, Crash Injury Research, New York, N. Y.
- U.S. National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics, 1957. Accelerations in Fighter Airplane Crashes, Lewis Flight Propulsion Laboratory, Cleveland. NACA RM E57G11.
- PINKEL, I. I. and ROSENBERG E. G.: 1957 Seat Design for Crash Worthiness NACA, Rept. 1332.
- Federal Aviation Agency. 1966 Calculations of Loads in Crash Landing of Boeing 727 Airliner. Unpublished data. Aeronautical Center.
- Aviation Safety Engineering and Research of Flight Safety Foundation, 1964. “Crash Injury Evaluation. Personal Restraint System Study CV-2 De-Havilland Caribou” Rept. AVCIR 62-16.
- Federal Aviation Agency, 1964 Commercial Airliner Crash Tests. Phoenix, Arizona.
- Federal Aviation Agency. Technical Standard Order C22E. 3. 1. “Material”.
- United States Air Force. Handbook of Instructions for Aircraft Design. AF SCM80-1 2.6 Acceleration Loads. 2.6.1 Safety Belts and Harnesses. C.6-28A.
- USAF MEL W4088. E Revision. Type 24 for Safety Seat Belts. (Replaces USAF Tech Order 13A 1-1-2, and Navy MIL W 8630).
- Federal Register 15CFR Part 9, 31 August 1966. (Also see Society of Engineers 1965 Handbook, J4c) SAE J4C Report of Motor Vehicle Seat Belt Committee, revised July 1965. (Technical Report Preprint in 1966 Handbook.).
- GARRETT, J. W.: 1963 “A Study of Seat Belts in Wisconsin Automobile Accidents” Cornell Aeronautical Laboratory, Inc. Rept. No. VJ-1823-R3.
- LISTER, R. D. and MILSOM, B. M.: 1963 “Car Seat Belts: An Analysis of the Injuries Sustained by Car Occupants” Practitioner 191:332-340.
- BACKSTROM, C.: 1963 “Traffic Injuries in South Sweden with Special Reference to Medico-Legal Autopsies of Car Occupants and Value of Seat Belts” Acta Chirurgica Scandinavica, Suppl. 308.
- MacVEAN, S. S.: 1966 “Seat Belt Usage and Vehicle Occupancy Data” Ford Motor Company Technical Memo. PRM 66-26, 9 August.
- CALLAHAN, J.: 1967 “U. S. Makers Select 2-Buckle Setup for Lap-Shoulder Belts” Automotive News 29 May, pp. 10, 17-18.
- NAHUM, A. M., SIEGEL A. W., and TRACHTENBERG S. B.: 1966 “Causes of Significant Injuries in Non-Fatal Traffic Accidents” Proceedings 10th Stapp Car Crash Conference (Reprint SAE 660803).
- SNYDER, R. G., CROSBY, W., HANSON, P., SNOW, C., FINEG, J., and CHANDLER, R.: 1966 “Impact Injury to the Pregnant Female and Fetus in Lap Belt Restraint: (Presented 10th Stapp Car Crash Conference, 8 November Holloman AFB, New Mexico and, in press, University of Minnesota Press) SAE Paper No. 660801.
- SNYDER, R. G., CROSBY W. M., SNOW C. C.,, YOUNG J. W., and HANSON P.: 1967 Seat Belt Injuries in Impact Presented, University of Michigan Medical School, Sesquicentennial Symposium on THE PREVENTION OF HIGHWAY INJURY, High-way Safety Institute, Ann Arbor, Michigan, 21 April.
- CROSBY, W. M., SNYDER R. G., HANSON P., SNOW C. C.: 1967 “Impact Injuries to the Pregnant Female. I: Experimental Studies” To be presented, Regional Meeting National Academy of Gynecologists and Obstetricians, Detroit.
- BARECKI, C. J.: 1957 Auto Crash Safety Research Leading to Optimum Protection for Auto mobile Occupants. American Seating Company, Grand Rapids.
- BARECKI, C. J.: 1958 film of car crash tests at Holloman AFB. American Seating Company.
- MANSON, F. G.: 1935 U. S. Patent 2,057,687.
- JORDANOFF, A.: 1952 Air bag Restraint Design cited by Clark, Stapp Car Crash Conference.
- HETRICK, J. W.: 1952 U. S. Patent 2,649,311 filed on 5 August 1952, and granted 18 August 1953.
- BERTRAND, H. A.: 1955 U. S. Patent 2,834,606 granted 13 May 1958 and U. S. Patent 2,834,609.
- KOHN, W. A.: 1957 Proposed Air Cushion Applications, Disclosure, January 29. Ford Motor Company, Dearborn.
- FLAJOLE, W. J.: 1957 U. S. Patent 2,938,570 filed 5 July 1957 and granted 31 May, 1960.
- ANGEL, C., KERVAN F., BLOETSCHER H., and GOLD A.: 1959 Proposed Program to Develop Techniques for Simulation of Physiological Sensations of Re-entry and Landing of Boost-Guide Vehicles. Re-port TAP-8935, Goodyear Aircraft Corporation, Akron Ohio, December.
- SNYDER, R. G.: 1960 Design and Fabrication of a Restraint System for Advanced Manned Flight. Proposal submitted to AMC Aeronautical Systems Center, Wright Air Development Center (PR 96126). Rept. 60-9-8, Applied Research Laboratory, College of Engineering, University of Arizona, Tucson. 1 February.
- FREEMAN, H. E., BOYCE W. C., McKINNEY R., and ADAMS C. R.: 1960 Personal Restraint System, Progress Report No. 2, Contract AF33 (600) 41418, Chance-Vought Corporation, Dallas, Texas, September.
- CLARK, Carl, et al: 1962 Technical Proposal for a Universal Couch Restraint System Concept Development. Engineering Report 12434P, Martin Company, Baltimore, Md., May.
- CLARK, C., BLECHSCHMIDT C., and JORDON F.: 1964 Impact Protection with the “Airstop” Restraint System. Eighth Annual Stapp Auto Crash Conference, Detroit, October. Wayne State University Press, Detroit, 1966. (Engineering Report 13670, Martin Company, Baltimore, Md., October 1964).
- CLARK, C., and BLECHSCHMIDT C.: 1965 The Analytical Performance of an Airstop Restraint System in an Automobile Crash. Engineering Report 14005, Martin Company, Baltimore, Md. October.
- CLARK, C.: 1965 Human Transportation Fatalities and Protection Against Rear and Side Crash Loads by the Airstop Restraint. Proceedings Ninth Stapp Car Crash Conference, University of Minnesota Press, 1966.
- CARLYLE, L.: 1959 Literature Survey on Aircrew Restraint. Report ES 29260, Douglas Air craft Company, Inc. El Segundo, Calif. February.
- DANIEL, R. P.: 1960 Explosive Charge Activation of Air Bag. Patent Disclosure, January 25. Ford Motor Company, Dearborn.
- BENRUD, D. W.: 1960-61 as cited by Clark, Ninth Stapp Car Crash Conference, Proceedings.
- VYKUKAL, H. D., RICHARD G. P., and STINNETT G. W.: 1962 An Inter-Changeable Mobile Pilot Restraint System Designed for Use in High Sustained Acceleration Force Fields. Aerospace Medicine 33:279-285.
- KEMMERER, R. M.: 1967 Air Bag - Passenger Restraint System. Automotive Research Office, Impact Dynamics Department, Ford Motor Company, Rept. No. S-67-3.
- CHANDLER, Richard F.: 1967 The Daisy Decelerator. Holloman AFB, New Mexico. 6571st Aeromedical Research Laboratory. Tech. Report ARL-TR-67-3.
- SNYDER, R. G., SNOW C. C., YOUNG J. W., PRICE G. T., and HANSON P.: 1967 Experimental Comparison of Trauma in Lateral (-GY), Rearward Facing (+GX) and Forward Facing (-GX) Body Orientations When Restrained by Lap Belt Only. (In press, Aerospace Medicine). Presented at 38th Annual Scientific Meeting, Aerospace Medical Association, Washington, D. C., 10 April, as “Injury in Lateral Impact (-GY) When Restrained by Aircraft Seat Belt Only”.
- SNOW, C. C., SNYDER R. G., PRICE G. T., SHIRES T. K., and PARRY W. L.: 1967 “Trauma to the Urinary System Caused by Abrupt Deceleration.” Presented at American Medical Association, Scientific Assembly on Urology, Atlantic City, N. J., May. (In press, J.A.M.A.)
- LIFE, J. S., McCOY L. E., BRIAN M., and PINCE B. W.: 1967 Comparative Response of Live-Anesthetized and Dead Embalmed Organisms Exposed to Impact Stressing. Phase II: The Rhesus Monkey. Final Report to Ford Motor Company. TR 67-107. Space/Defense Corporation, Birmingham, Michigan.
- DE LA RENA, A., and GOLDZIEHER J. W.: 1967 “Clinical Parameters of the Normal Baboon.” The Baboon in Medical Research, Proceedings, Vol. Π, pp 379-389. First International Symposium on the Baboon and Its Use as an Experimental Animal. Harold Vagtborg, Ed., University of Texas Press.