This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Significance of Tests for Motor Fuels
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
IN THIS PAPER the author discusses the significance of the various tests for motor fuels, particularly in the light of extensive research work along these lines in the past few years by various industrial laboratories and the United States Bureau of Standards. A bibliography of the literature on the subject supplements the paper.
Although a large part of the public still seems to assume that the principal difference to the car user between different grades of gasoline is in mileage per gallon, actually, if today's best and poorest commercial gasolines are compared, the difference in mileage is very small compared with the differences in engine-starting ability, antiknock quality, vapor-locking tendency and liability to injure the engine or the fuel-induction system.
Volatility is generally believed to be the most important property of a motor fuel, but recent research has demonstrated that the 10-per cent point on the American Society for Testing Materials distillation curve is the best measure of the ease of starting in cold weather and of the danger of vapor lock, while the 90-per cent point is the best measure of the ease of uniform distribution and lack of crankcase-oil dilution in an engine after it has warmed up. Other intermediate points are of some importance in determining the ease of acceleration, especially while the engine is being warmed up; but, in general, suitable limits on the 10, 50 and 90-per cent points of a fuel will, the author asserts, assure good performance under all conditions so far as fuel volatility is concerned. The 10-per cent point especially must be closely controlled to assure easy starting without too much danger from vapor lock.
Antiknock quality is today a property of almost equal importance, from the standpoint of performance, with volatility of the fuel in its various aspects. Actual engine tests under carefully controlled conditions are as yet the only reliable measure of antiknock value. Difficulties in developing a standard engine-test are discussed in detail.
Sulphur content, gum content, and freedom from corrosive substances are each of importance in determining whether a gasoline can be used steadily without corroding or clogging the fuel system or the engine. Other properties of gasoline have little or no influence on the performance of a motor fuel, except that variations in viscosity or gravity may necessitate the readjustment of the carbureter.
High volatility and antiknock value and low sulphur and gum content cost money to obtain, but frequently the automotive engineer, by correct design, can decrease the need for too-rigid specifications on all those points. Of special importance in this connection are (a) more care in designing to prevent overheating of fuel lines, vacuum tank and other parts of the fuel system, thus permitting the use of valuable fuels without danger of vapor lock; (b) prevention of crankcase corrosion, thus raising the permissible limits for sulphur by eliminating the condensation of water in engines and crankcases; and (c) more uniform cooling of engines, especially aircraft engines, to reduce the tendency of hydrocarbon fuels to detonate.
Authors
Topic
Citation
WILSON, R., "Significance of Tests for Motor Fuels," SAE Technical Paper 300022, 1930, https://doi.org/10.4271/300022.Also In
References
- Wilson, R. E. Barnard, D. P. 4th Condensation Temperature of Gasoline and Kerosene-Air Mixtures Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Nov. 1921 13 313
- Wilson, R. E. Barnard, D. P. 4th Dew-Points of Gasoline-Air Mixtures Industrial and Engineering Chemistry April 1925 17 428 T RANSACTIONS 18 210
- Gruse W. A. Direct Determination of Dew-Points of Gasoline-Air Mixtures Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Aug. 1923 15 796 Oil and Gas Journal 1924 22 86 Petroleum Age 1924 12 20 Chemical and Metallurgical Engineering 1924 29 970 1924 30 364
- Stevenson, R. Stark, H. J. Equilibrium Vaporization of Gasoline Industrial and Engineering Chemistry July 1925 17 679
- Stevenson, R. Babor, J. A. Determination of Volatility of Gasoline Industrial and Engineering Chemistry December 1927 19 1361
- Whatmough, W. A. Relation between Fuel Deposition Temperature and Equilibrium Boiling Point Industrial and Engineering Chemistry June 1926 18 609
- Whatmough, W. A. Equilibrium Boiling Points Proceedings, Institute of Automobile Engineers 1922 17 346 Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 1926 18 43 Automotive Engineering 1926 17 15 452 484
- James, W. S. Gasoline Volatility T RANSACTIONS 21 35 American Petroleum Institute Bulletin April 1926 7 117 National Petroleum News 1926 18 85
- Sligh, T. S., Jr. Progress in the Measurement of Motor Fuel Volatility T RANSACTIONS 21 56 Volatility Tests for Automobile Fuels T RANSACTIONS 21 182
- Cragoe, C. S. Eisinger, J. O. Fuel Requirements for Engine Starting T RANSACTIONS 22 1
- Brown, G. G. The Relation of Motor Fuel Characteristics to Engine Performance Engineering Research Bulletin 7 May 1927 University of Michigan 129
- Bridgeman, O. C. Volatility Data from Gasoline Distillation Curves S. A. E. J OURNAL April 1928 22 437
- Bridgeman, O. C. Dew Point Data on Gasoline S.A.E. T RANSACTIONS 23 371
- Bridgeman, O. C. Equilibrium Volatility of Motor Fuels American Petroleum Institute Bulletin 1929 10 2 124
- Brown, G. G. Skinner, E. M. Motor Fuel Volatility Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 1930 22 278
- Bridgeman, O. C. Present Status of Equilibrium Volatility Work at the Bureau of Standards S.A.E. T RANSACTIONS 24 240
- Lane, E. C. Taylor, S. S. Wilhelm, C. J. Twentieth Semi-Annual Motor Gasoline Survey U. S. Bureau of Mines 1929
- Dickinson, H. C. Proceedings Tenth Annual Meeting of the American Petroleum Institute 1930 4
- Bridgeman, O. C. Aldrich, E. W. White, H. S. Vapor Pressure of Gas-Free Gasolines Proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute Jan. 1930 4
- Brown, A. C. Caine, G. C. Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium in Complex Hydrocarbon Mixtures Transactions of the American Institute of Chemical Engineers 1928 21 91
- Brooks, D. B. Economic Fuel-Volatility and Engine Acceleration S.A.E. T RANSACTIONS 24 229
- Brown, G. G. Miller, J. E. Motor Fuel Volatility, Part II. Effective Volatility as Related to Equilibrium Volatility and the A. S. T. M. Distillation American Chemical Society Minneapolis Sept. 1929
- Dickinson, H. C. When Is Gasoline Satisfactory as Motor Fuel? Chemical and Metallurgical Engineering May 1926 33 293
- Proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute Tenth Annual Meeting December 1929 112 132
- Voorhees, V. Eisinger, J. O. The Importance and Significance of Gum in Gasoline Proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute Ninth Annual Meeting December 1928 169 S. A. E. T RANSACTIONS 24 285
- Cooke, M. B. Reports of Investigations, No. 2686. A Convenient Method of Determining Gum Forming Material in Gasoline U. S. Bureau of Mines Report 1925
- Hunn, E. B. Fischer, H. G. M. Blackwood, A. J. Gum in Gasoline S.A.E. J OURNAL January 1930 26 31
- Herthel, E. C. Apgar, F. Some Phenomena of Gum Determination of Motor Fuels Proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute December 1929 124
- Wagner, C. R. Hyman, J. Factors Affecting Determination of Gum in Gasoline Proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute December 1929 112
- Egloff, G. Faragher, W. F. Morrell, J. C. Stabilization of Knock Rating, Gums, and Color of Gasoline by Chemical Inhibitors Proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute December 1929 112
- Voorhees, V. Remarks during Discussion Proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute December 1929 129
- Edgar, G. Detonation Specifications for Automotive Fuels S.A.E. T RANSACTIONS 22 55
- Stansfield, R. Thole, F. B. Standardization of Conditions for Measuring the Detonation Characteristics of Motor Fuels Industrial and Engineering Chemistry April 15 1927 1 98 1929
- Campbell, J. M. Lovell, W. G. Boyd, R. A. Detonation Characteristics of Some of the Fuels Suggested as Standards of Anti-Knock Quality S. A. E. J OURNAL February 1930 26 163 Oil and Gas Journal January 23 1930 42
- Bartholomew, E. Progress in Knock Testing National Petroleum News Oct. 16 1929 37 Oct. 23 1929 57
- Cummings, H. K. Results of Two Detonation Surveys S.A.E. T RANSACTIONS 23 53
- MacCoull, N. Methods of Measuring Detonation S.A.E. T RANSACTIONS 23 63
- Summary of Knock-Test Methods, Report of Subcommittee on Methods for Rating Fuels for Knock Tendency S.A.E. J OURNAL July 1929 25 80
- Horning, H. L. Standardization of Antiknock Testing Proceedings of the American Petroleum Institute December 1929 32
- Mougey, H. C. Sulphur in Gasoline from the Automobile Standpoint Industrial and Engineering Chemistry January 1928 20 18
- Diggs, S. H. Effect of Sulphur in Gasoline on Wrist-Pin Corrosion in Automobiles Industrial and Engineering Chemistry January 1928 20 16
- Halloran, R. A. Method of Refining Cracked Naphtha Oil and Gas Journal Dec 8 1927 36
- Griffin, R. C. Determination of Sulphur in Petroleum Oil Industrial and Engineering Chemistry July 15 1929 167
- Edgar, G. Calingaert, G. Determination of Sulphur in Gasoline Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 1930 21 104
- Boyd, T. A. Report of Sub-Committee VII of A. S. T. M. Committee D-2 National Petroleum News August 7 1929 80 82
- Birdsell, Roger Economic Motor Fuel Volatility T RANSACTIONS 19 130 T HE J OURNAL July 1924 15 24
- Brown, G. G. Zuck, H. E. Perfect Certified Knock Rating Test Oil and Gas Journal Jan. 9 1930 44