This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Comparative Study between Physics, Electrical and Data Driven Lithium-Ion Battery Voltage Modeling Approaches
Technical Paper
2022-01-0700
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
This paper benchmarks three different lithium-ion (Li-ion) battery voltage modelling approaches, a physics-based approach using an Extended Single Particle Model (ESPM), an equivalent circuit model, and a recurrent neural network. The ESPM is the selected physics-based approach because it offers similar complexity and computational load to the other two benchmarked models. In the ESPM, the anode and cathode are simplified to single particles, and the partial differential equations are simplified to ordinary differential equations via model order reduction. Hence, the required state variables are reduced, and the simulation speed is improved. The second approach is a third-order equivalent circuit model (ECM), and the third approach uses a model based on a Long Short-Term Memory Recurrent Neural Network (LSTM-RNN)). A Li-ion pouch cell with 47 Ah nominal capacity is used to parameterize all the models. The models are tested and compared using four standard drive cycles at six ambient temperatures ranging from -200C to 40 0C. The proposed models are benchmarked using various qualitative and quantitative means including, accuracy, engineering effort to parametrize and create the model, and the ability of each model to represent the nonlinear behavior of the battery. The comparison between the three models shows that the ECM and the LSTM models have better accuracy than the ESPM. However, the ESPM requires a reduced set of calibration data, is highly capable of incorporating the complex nonlinear behavior of the battery, and the parameters have physical meaning.
Authors
- Yang Liang - FCA USA LLC
- Ali Emadi - McMaster University
- Oliver Gross - Stellantis NV
- Carlos Vidal - McMaster University
- Marcello Canova - Ohio State University
- Satyam Panchal - Stellantis NV
- Phillip Kollmeyer - McMaster University
- Mina Naguib - McMaster University
- Fauzia Khanum - McMaster University
Topic
Citation
Liang, Y., Emadi, A., Gross, O., Vidal, C. et al., "A Comparative Study between Physics, Electrical and Data Driven Lithium-Ion Battery Voltage Modeling Approaches," SAE Technical Paper 2022-01-0700, 2022, https://doi.org/10.4271/2022-01-0700.Also In
References
- Emadi , A. Advanced Electric Drive Vehicles Boca Raton CRC Press, Taylor & Francis 2017 10.1201/9781315215570
- Golubkov , A. Thermal-Runaway Experiments on Consumer Li-Ion Batteries with Metal-Oxide and Olivine-Type Cathodes Royal Society of Chemistry 4 2014 3363 3342
- Emadi , A. Transportation 2.0 IEEE Power and Energy Magazine 9 2011 18 29
- Dubarry , M. , Nicolas , V. , and Bor , L. From Li-Ion Single Cell Model to Battery Pack Simulation 2008 IEEE International Conference on Control Applications , 2008 10.1109/CCA.2008.4629598
- Hu , Y. , Yurkovich , S. , Guezennec , Y. , and Yurkovich , B. A Technique for Dynamic Battery Model Identification in Automotive Applications Using Linear Parameter Varying Structures Control Engineering Practice 17 10 2009 1190 1201 10.1016/j.conengprac.2009.05.002
- Andre , D. , Meiler , M. , Steiner , K. , Walz , H. et al. Characterization of High-Power Lithium-Ion Batteries by Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy. II: Modelling Journal of Power Sources 196 12 2011 5349 5356 10.1016/j.jpowsour.2010.07.071
- Kollmeyer , P. , Andreas , H. , and Emadi , A. Li-Ion Battery Model Performance for Automotive Drive Cycles with Current Pulse and EIS Parameterization 2017 IEEE Transportation Electrification Conference and Expo (ITEC) 2017 10.1109/ITEC.2017.7993319
- Ryan , A. et al. Reduced-Order Electrochemical Model Parameters Identification and SOC Estimation for Healthy and Aged Li-Ion Batteries Part I: Parameterization Model Development for Healthy Batteries IEEE Journal of Emerging and Selected Topics in Power Electronics 2 3 2014 659 677 10.1109/jestpe.2014.2331059
- Ran , G. , Malysz , P. , Yang , H. , and Emadi , A. On the Suitability of Electrochemical-Based Modeling for Lithium-Ion Batteries IEEE Transactions on Transportation Electrification 2 4 2016 417 431 10.1109/tte.2016.2571778
- Hu , X. , Shengbo , L. , and Huei , P. A Comparative Study of Equivalent Circuit Models for Li-Ion Batteries Journal of Power Sources 198 2012 359 367 10.1016/j.jpowsour.2011.10.013
- Fan , G. A Reduced-Order Multi-Scale, Multi-Dimensional Model for Performance Prediction of Large-Format Li-Ion Cells Journal of The Electrochemical Society 164 2 2017 A252 A264
- Fan , G. A Comparison of Model Order Reduction Techniques for Electrochemical Characterization of Lithium-Ion Batteries 2015 54th IEEE Conference on Decision and Controls (CDC) , 10.1109/CDC.2015.7402829
- Fan , G. Moder Order Reduction of Electrochemical Batteries Using Galerkin Method Mathematics 2015 10.1115/DSCC2015-9788
- Ruxiu , Z. , Kollmeyer , P. , Lorenz , R. , and Jahns , T. A Compact Methodology Via a Recurrent Neural Network for Accurate Equivalent Circuit Type Modeling of Lithium-Ion Batteries IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications 55 2 2019 1922 1931 10.1109/tia.2018.2874588
- Naguib , M. et al. Comparative Study Between Equivalent Circuit and Recurrent Neural Network Battery Voltage Models SAE 2021-04-06 2021 10.4271/2021-04-06
- Ojo , O.J. , Lin , X. , Lang , H. and Hu , X. A Voltage Fault Detection Method Enabled by A Recurrent Neural Network and Residual Threshold Monitor for Lithium-ion Batteries 2021 IEEE Transportation Electrification Conference & Expo (ITEC) , 2021 813 820 10.1109/ITEC51675.2021.9490102
- Cho , G. , Zhu , D. , and Campbell , J. A Comparative Study of Recurrent Neural Network Architectures for Battery Voltage Prediction SAE Technical Paper . 2021-01-1252 . 2021 10.4271/2021-01-1252
- Chemali , E. , Kollmeyer , P. , Preindl , M. , Rya , A. et al. Long Short-Term Memory Networks for Accurate State-of-Charge Estimation of Li-Ion Batteries IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics 65 8 2018 6730 6739 10.1109/tie.2017.2787586
- Vidal , C. , Pawel , M. , Kollmeyer , P. , and Emadi , A. Machine Learning Applied to Electrified Vehicle Battery State of Charge and State of Health Estimation: State-Of-The-Art IEEE Access 8 2020 52796 52814 10.1109/access.2020.2980961
- Naguib , M. et.al. Comparative Study Between Equivalent Circuit and Recurrent Neural Network Battery Voltage Models 2021 IEEE Transportation Electrification Conference & Expo (ITEC) , 2021 813 820 10.1109/ITEC51675.2021.9490102
- Dai , H. et al. A Novel Estimation Method for the State of Health of Lithium-Ion Battery Using Prior Knowledge-Based Neural Network and Markov Chain IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics 66 10 2018 7706 7716 10.1109/tie.2018.2880703
- Khaled , A. , El-Sayed , M. , and Mohammed , S. Evaluation of Bidirectional LSTM for Short-And Long-Term Stock Market Prediction 2018 9th International Conference on Information and Communication Systems (ICICS) 2018 10.1109/iacs.2018.8355458
- Weizhong , W. , Malysz , P. , Khan , K. , Gauchia , L. et al. Modeling, Parameterization, and Benchmarking of a Lithium Ion Electric Bicycle Battery 2016 IEEE Energy Conversion Congress and Exposition (ECCE) 2016 10.1109/ecce.2016.7855266
- Wang , W. 2016
- Pascanu , R. , Mikolov , T. , and Bengio , Y. On the Difficulty of Training Recurrent Neural Networks Proceedings of the 30th International Conference on Machine Learning 2012 10.5555/3042817.3043083
- https://colah.github.io/posts/2015-08-Understanding-LSTMs/
- Gao , Y. A Novel Model for Lithium-Ion Battery Aging Quantitative Analysis Based on Pseudo Two-Dimension Expressions International Journal of Electrochemical Sciences 14 2019 3180 3203
- Yang , X. Modeling of Lithium Plating Induced Aging of Lithium-Ion Batteries: Transition from Linear to Nonlinear Aging Journal of Power Sources 360 2017 28 40
- Kollmeyer , P. , Vidal , C. , Naguib , M. , and Skells , M. LG 18650HG2 Li-Ion Battery Data and Example Deep Neural Network xEV SOC Estimator Script, V3 Mendeley Data 2020 10.17632/cp3473x7xv.3
- Vidal , C. et al. Robust XEV Battery State-Of-Charge Estimator Design Using a Feedforward Deep Neural Network SAE Technical Paper 2020-01-1181 2020 10.4271/2020-01-1181
- Park , S. Optimal Experimental Design for Parameterization of an Electrochemical Lithium-Ion Battery Model Journal of Electrochemical Society 165 7 2018
- Valøen , L.O. and Reimers , J.N. Transport Properties of LiPF6-Based Li-Ion Battery Electrolytes Journal of The Electrochemical Society 152 5 2005 A882
- Marcicki , J. , Canova , M. , Conlisk , A.T. , and Rizzoni , G. Design and Parametrization Analysis of a Reduced-Order Electrochemical Model of Graphite/LiFePO4 Cells for SOC/SOH Estimation Journal of Power Sources 237 2013 310 324
- Fan , G. , Pan , K. , Canova , M. , Marcicki , J. et al. Modeling of Li-Ion Cells for Fast Simulation of High C-Rate and Low Temperature Operations Journal of The Electrochemical Society 163 5 2016 A666