This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Power to Liquid (PtL) Synthetic Aviation Fuel - A Sustainable Pathway for Jet Fuel Production
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 04, 2022 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Event: SAE BRASIL 2021 Web Forum
Aviation industry currently accounts for almost 3% of worldwide greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Despite the continuous efforts to reduce this environmental footprint, with the use of technological efficiency driven solutions and operational changes to reduce climatic effects, such as engine improvements, fleet renewals and navigation operational improvements, the industry, which is permanently challenged by the continuously stringent standards, is aware of the need of additional measures to tackle, and even reduce, the GHG emissions, by decoupling the world's industry average growth (almost 4.1% annually) to the aviation's carbon emissions. Given its inherent operational features, the aviation sector requires fuels with high specific energy and energy density. This technical requirement makes the well known clean and efficient electrical propulsion technology to be limited to niche aviation segments (short range and low capacity airplanes) in the short and medium terms. In this scenario, the so called Sustainable Aviation Fuels(SAF) - non fossil hydrocarbons, manufactured with renewable & sustainable feedstocks - appear as the big bet for the carbon footprint reduction for the medium and long range aviation. The biofuel SAF pathway, i.e. that which relies on biological feedstocks (crops and waste), already certified and produced to be used in blends with fossil jet fuel, into a drop-in fuel concept, has some environmental limitations associated with GHG net emissions, cost, and natural resources (land use and water) requirements. These limitations might set sustainable challenges to a massive future biofuel based SAF approach. In this context, the so called Power to Liquids (PtL) fuels, which comprises the production of synthetic liquid hydrocarbon fuels, using renewable electricity (for hydrogen generation with water electrolysis) and non fossil carbon dioxide (CO2) as the main feedstocks, is seen as a promising SAF pathway. Compared to biofuels, PtL SAF reaches higher area-related yields, with the intensive use of renewable electricity, such as photovoltaic and wind energy. The PtL's SAF water requirement is also significantly lower, compared to the biofuel production. Hence, the PtL SAF technology is seen as an important SAF pathway to enable a non fossil and fully sustainable fuel supply for aviation in the long run, avoiding the risks and adverse effects potentially associated with biomass based pathways. This work presents, based on an assessment of the researched technical literature, an overview of the PtL SAF technology, with a focus on the production methods and the required inputs, followed by an assessment of operational effects and costs for the aviation sector. The analysis shows that the PtL SAF appears as a promising sustainable SAF pathway, with a lower GHG footprint (into a Lyfecycle basis) and reduced water requirement, as well as a higher yield, compared to the plant-based SAF pathways (biofuels). Moreover, PtL SAF does not raise the demand for arable land, avoiding the so called food & fuel conflict. From a technical perspective, the PtL SAF might produce fuels suitable for even a net fossil fuel substitution (no blends). Nevertheless, the PtL SAF costs, which relies strongly on the renewable electricity price, are still a challenge to enable the competition with fossil jet fuel. This might initially require regulatory actions as well as further technological improvements, mainly associated with renewable electricity - fuel conversion and CO2 supply alternatives.
CitationBarbosa, F., "Power to Liquid (PtL) Synthetic Aviation Fuel - A Sustainable Pathway for Jet Fuel Production," SAE Technical Paper 2021-36-0034, 2022, https://doi.org/10.4271/2021-36-0034.
- Yugo M. and Soler A. A look into the role of e-fuels in the transport system in Europe (2030-2050) (literature review) Concawe Review 28 1 2019
- McKinsey 2020
- DoE 2020
- Barbosa F.C. Aircraft Emissions and Noise Review - Technological Paths for Pursuing Sustainability in the Aviation Industry SAE Paper 2020-36-0106 2020
- Schmidt , P. and Weindorf , W. Power-to-Liquids Potentials and Perspectives for the Future Supply of Renewable Aviation Fuel Germany 2016
- ICAO POWER-TO-LIQUIDS (PTL): SUSTAINABLE FUELS FOR AVIATION Working Paper. International Civil Aviation Organization. 2019
- Barbosa F.C. Biojet Fuel - A Tool for a Sustainable Aviation Industry. A Technical Assessment SAE Paper 2017-36-0142 2017
- Toni De , et al. Conventional and alternative aviation fuels: an overview on composition, properties and aircraft engine test Proceedings of 15th Brazilian Congress of Thermal Sciences and Engineering Belém, Brazil November 10-13, 2014 at https://www.researchgate.net/publication/268810589_Conventio nal_and_alternative_aviation_fuels_an_overview_on_compostio n_properties_and_aircraft_engine_test?enrichId=rgreq 7177e430dcf48cf47d811b5cb5f8a84d XXX&enrichSource=Y292ZXJQYWdlOzI2ODgxMDU4OTtB UzoxNjgxODgwMTY4NjUyODBAMTQxNzExMDU1NjU5M A%3D%3D&el=1_x_2&_esc=publicationCoverPdf.
- Carvalho F.M. 2017
- Bauen , A. Sustainable Aviation Fuels Status, challenges and prospects of drop-in liquid fuels, hydrogen and electrification in aviation Johnson Matthey Technol. Rev. 2020
- Terwel R. and Kerkhoven J. 2018
- Pavlenko , N. and Searle , S. Assessing the sustainability implications of alternative aviation fuels International Council of Clean Transportation (ICCT) 2021
- Kolosz B.W. et al. Life cycle environmental analysis of ‘drop in’ alternative aviation fuels: a review Sustainable Energy & Fuels Journal 2020
- Schmidt P. et al. Power-to-Liquids as Renewable Fuel Option for Aviation: A Review Chem. Ing. Tech. 2018 90 1-2 127 140 2018
- Mulligan J. et al. https://www.wri.org/insights/6-ways-remove-carbon-pollution sky#:~:text=Direct%20air%20capture%20is%20the,or%20in%2 0long%2Dlived%20products.
- Bhatia S.C. https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/indirect-land use-change.
- https://www.government.nl/topics/renewable energy/offshore-wind-energy.
- https://www.offshore mag.com/renewable-energy/article/14188126/largest-.utch offshore-wind-farm-fully commissioned#:~:text=%C3%98rsted%20has%20fully%20com missioned%20the,in%20the%20Dutch%20North%20Sea.&text =Borssele%201%20%26%202%20is%20the,wind%20farm%20i n%20the%20Netherlands.&text=FREDERICIA%2C%20Denma rk%20%E2%80%93%20%C3%98rsted%20has%20fully,in%20t he%20Dutch%20North%20Sea.
- https://news.klm.com/world-first-in-the-netherlands-by-klm shell-and-dutch-ministry-for-infrastructure-and-water management-first-passenger-flight-performed-with-sustainable synthetic-kerosene/