This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Open Rotor Engine Technology Review – A Tool for Efficiency
Technical Paper
2020-36-0108
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The aviation industry has been strongly driven by stringent safety, efficiency and environmental requirements. In the efficiency field, engine efficiency, allied with aerodynamic design improvements, have played an important role to reduce the fuel burn, given that fuel expenses are currently one of the major cost drivers of the air carriers worldwide. Since the beginning of the jet engine era, engine efficiency has evolved significantly, through thermodynamic efficiency improvements, associated mainly with increased engine pressure ratio (EPR) and turbine inlet temperature (TIT). Another important optimization driver has been the propulsive efficiency, associated with increased bypass ratios (BPR). Material and aerodynamic properties have imposed limits for thermal efficiency improvements, which ultimately might hinder further progresses. Meanwhile, propulsive efficiency - highly dependent on the BPR - is currently limited, due to the inherent increase in the nacelle weight and drag, derived from the higher BPR and its intrinsic larger fan diameter. In this context, the so called Open Rotor (OR) engine concept has been proposed to address the engine’s propulsive efficiency improvement, without the hurdles seen on the Turbofans (ducted fans), i.e. nacelle weight and drag increase. Furthermore, this engine technology has also incorporated the so called Contra Rotating (CR) concept, to recover the energy from the fan’s exhaust flow swirl, and, hence, improve further the propulsive efficiency. This engine concept has been initially proposed in the late 70's, as a product of an energy efficiency research program, to face the late 70's oil crisis. The technological concept has been developed and tested in the laboratory/wind tunnel and prototype’s operational field test campaigns (the most well known as Unducted Fan (UDF) and Propfan) along the 80's, focused on the medium range airplanes market. Albeit successfully from a propulsion and efficiency perspective, the increased noise level required further research. Moreover, the changes in the oil price scenario that followed the 90s have reduced the technology’s attractiveness for the world air carriers, which ultimately have contributed to the discontinuance of the research efforts. However, the advent of the continuously stringent efficiency (and emissions) standards, associated with a new oil price upward trend scenario, have awakened the interest in the technology. In this context, technological research institutions and engine manufacturers have relaunched the research programs, focused on the technology improvement and reliability tests, aimed on the medium term scenario, i.e. the next generation engine technology, to be used in mid range aircrafts. This work is supposed to present an Open Rotor Engine technology review, associated with a historical overview of its evolution pathway and current research initiatives, as well as the technological challenges to be addressed prior to its commercial use.
Citation
Barbosa, F., "Open Rotor Engine Technology Review – A Tool for Efficiency," SAE Technical Paper 2020-36-0108, 2021, https://doi.org/10.4271/2020-36-0108.Also In
References
- Kinney J. R. The Power forFlight NASA’s Contributions to Aircraft Propulsion NASA AERONAUTICS BOOKS SERIES The National Aeronautics and Space Administration United States 2017
- Self R. Competing Priorities Technology’s Influence on the Levels of Environmental Emissions from Aircraft and the TradeOffs Involved Review and Future Prospects University of Southampton United Kingdom 2018
- Zanenga E. S. Design and Engineering Methods for Open-rotor Nacelle Shaping Ph. D. Thesis School of Engineering. Cranfield University United Kingdom 2010
- Suder K.L. and Heidman J.D. Improvement of Aeropropulsion Fuel Efficiency through Engine Design Green Aviation: Reduction of Environmental Impact Through Aircraft Technology and Alternative Fuels CRC Press United Kingdom 2017
- NAP Commercial Aircraft Propulsion and Energy Systems Research Reducing Global Carbon Emissions The National Academies Press United States 2016
- Sabnis J. Green Aviation Propulsion System Challenges & Solutions NASA Green Aviation Summit United States 2010
- Mattingly J. D. Elements of Gas Turbine Propulsion McGraw-Hill Edition 2005
- Barbosa F.C. Aircraft Engine Technology Review – The Pathways for an Efficient, Cleaner and Quieter Aviation Industry Sae Technical Paper 2019-01-0175 Brazil 2019
- Cory W.T.W. Fans & Ventilation A Practical Guide United Kingdom 2005
- RR The Jet Engine Rolls Royce plc Fifth edition England 1996
- Adamson et al. Auxiliary Power Source in na Unducted Fan Gas Turbine Engine United States Patent Number 4,936,748 United States 1990
- ENOVAL Providing the next step in Engine Technologies Germany 2018 http://www.enoval.eu/
- Dilba D. High-bypass engines of the future Aeroreport. The Aviation Magazine of MTU Aero Engine Germany 2018 https://aeroreport.de/en/innovation/high-bypass-engines-of-the-future.
- GE Aviation Open Rotor Engine Aeroacoustic Technology -Final Report Continuous Lower Energy, Emissions and Noise (CLEEN) Program U.S. DoT & FAA United States 2013
- McCarthy M. Contra-Rotating Open Rotor Reverse Thrust Aerodynamics MSc Thesis in Engineering Cranfield University United Kingdom 2011
- Langston L. S. Open Rotor Engines — Still na Open Question? ASME Mechanical Engineering Magazine 36 December 2018 United Sates 2018
- Ziemianski J. A. and Whitlow J. B. Jr. Nasa/Industry Advanced Turboprop Technology Program NASA United States 1988
- Álvarez R. A. Estudo dos Motores Propfan em Aeronaves de Pequena Dimensão Propfan como Alternativa ao Turbofan MSc Thesis Universidade da Beira Interior Portugal 2012
- Zante D. E. V. Progress in Open Rotor Research: A U. S. Perspective. Paper GT2015-42203 Proceedings of ASME Turbo Expo 2015: Turbine Technical Conference and Exposition GT2015 Canada 2015
- M'Bengue L. Toward ACARE2020; Innovative Engine Architectures to Achieve the Environmental Goals Snecma SAFRAN Group 27th International Congress of Aeronautical Sciences 2010
- Vanderover J.S. et al. Analysis of a Contra-Rotating Propeller Driven Transport Aircraft American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics United States
- Hendricks E. S. and Tong M. T. Performance and Weight Estimates for na Advanced Open Rotor Engine AIAA–2012– 3911. 48th Joint Propulsion Conference and Exhibit United States 2012
- Peters A. Assessment of Propfan Propulsion Systems for Reduced Environmental Impact MSc Thesis in Aeronautics and Astronautics Massachusetts Institute of Technology United States 2010
- Chao MA and Zhaoguang TAN A conceptual Analysis of na Aircraft with Rear-Mounted Open rotor Engines 30th Congress of International Council of the Aeronautical Sciences (ICAS, 2016) South Korea 2016 http://www.icas.org/ICAS_ARCHIVE/ICAS2016/data/papers/2 016_0253_paper.pdf.
- Excell J. Interview with Ric Parker: Director of research and technology, Rolls Royce The Engineer 2014 https://www.theengineer.co.uk/ric-parker-director-of-research-and-technology-rolls-royce/.
- Smith D. J. Case Study The Sustainable and Green Engine (SAGE) – Aircraft Engine of the Future? Nottingham Trent University United Kingdom
- Moreau S. and Michel R. Advanced Noise Modeling for Future Propulsion Systems International Journal of Aeroacoustics 17 6–8 576 599 2018 https://acoustique.ec-lyon.fr/publi/moreau_ija18.pdf.
- Robison R. A. V. Turbulence Ingestion Noise of Open Rotors PhD Thesis Jesus College Cambridge. United Kingdom 2011
- The Engine Yearbook Fulfilling the Promise of Open-Rotor Technology https://issuu.com/ubmaviationpublications/docs/eyb_2011_ipad/ 107.
- FI - Yakovlev takes propfan lead While development of fuel-saving propfan engines languishes in the West, work continues in the Soviet Union where recent fuel shortages have underscored the need for new engine technology Flight International Magazine 139 4267 27 28 1991
- Wikipedia Propfan https://thereaderwiki.com/en/Propfan.
- AFT - Antonov An-70 Transport / Cargo Aircraft Air Force Technology https://www.airforce-technology.com/projects/antonovan70freighter/.
- Ekoule C. M. Advanced Open Rotor Far-Field Tone Noise PhD Thesis Institute of Sound and Vibration Research. University of Southampton United Kingdom 2017
- IATA - Aircraft Technology Roadmap to 2050 Switzerland
- Larsson L. et al. Conceptual Design and Mission Analysis for a Geared Turbofan and Open Rotor Configuration Proceedings of ASME Turbo Expo 2011 Canada 2011
- Angrand A. Safran Ponders Open Rotor Options AIR & COSMOS INTERNATIONAL Magazine 7-10th May 2019
- Safran Media 2 Open Rotor wins Aviation Week’s Laureate Award for propulsion https://www.safran-aircraft-engines.com/media/open-rotor-wins-aviation-weeks-laureate-award-propulsion-20190315.
- Safran Media 1 What does the future hold in store for the Open Rotor? https://www.safran-group.com/media/what-does-future-hold-store-open-rotor-20190328.
- Safran - OR Picture Library https://www.safran-group.com/node/16322?button=1&index=0.
- König J. and Thomas H. The Clean Sky “Smart Fixed Wing Aircraft Integrated Technology Demonstrator Technology targets and project status. 27th International Congress of the Aeronautical Sciences 2010
- Paxton C. et al. High Efficiency Forward Swept Propellers at Low Speed 41st Aerospace Sciences Meeting & Exhibit United States 2003