This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Should We Walk or Take a Car for Minimum Greenhouse Gas Emissions?
Technical Paper
2019-01-0996
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
This content contains downloadable datasets
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
This paper compares the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions attributed to driving a popular production vehicle powered by an internal combustion engine (ICE), as well as a hybrid electric vehicle (HEV), with GHG emissions associated with walking, running and bicycling. The purpose of this study is to offer a different perspective on the problem of global warming due to anthropogenic causes, specifically on transportation and eating patterns. In order to accurately estimate emissions, a full life cycle of food has been considered coupled with energy expenditures of the aforementioned activities obtained from several different sources and averaged for more reliable results. The GHG emissions were calculated for Sweden, the UK, and the US. Depending on the availability of certain data, the methodology for different countries was altered slightly. The question whether walking, running or taking a bicycle is better for the environment than driving a car cannot be answered uniquely. This study demonstrates that the answer depends on several factors, such as diet composition, the number of people commuting, vehicle powertrain, as well as the country analyzed. The conclusion is that if one has an eco-friendly diet and travels alone the preferred modes of transport would be bicycling, walking and running, the cleanest of which by far is bicycling. However, if the diet has a higher CO2 footprint, as in the case of diets containing a large amount of meat and/or imported products, then the preference shifts towards cars, among which the most environmentally friendly are hybrid electric vehicles. The same conclusion applies to the cases where the number of people commuting together exceeds two-three persons.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Babayev, R. and Johansson, B., "Should We Walk or Take a Car for Minimum Greenhouse Gas Emissions?," SAE Technical Paper 2019-01-0996, 2019, https://doi.org/10.4271/2019-01-0996.Data Sets - Support Documents
| Title | Description | Download |
|---|---|---|
| Unnamed Dataset 1 | ||
| Unnamed Dataset 2 |
Also In
References
- Maibach , E. , Steg , L. , and Anable , J. Promoting Physical Activity and Reducing Climate Change: Opportunities to Replace Short Car Trips with Active Transportation Preventive Medicine 49 4 326 327 2009
- Haines , A. , McMichael , A.J. , Smith , K.R. , Roberts , I. et al. Public Health Benefits of Strategies to Reduce Greenhouse-Gas Emissions: Overview and Implications for Policy Makers The Lancet 374 9707 2104 2114 2009
- Woodcock , J. and Aldred , R. Cars, Corporations, and Commodities: Consequences for the Social Determinants of Health Emerging Themes in Epidemiology 5 1 4 2008
- Rabl , A. and De Nazelle , A. Benefits of Shift from Car to Active Transport Transport Policy 19 1 121 131 2012
- Komanoff , C. , Roelofs , C. , Orcutt , J. , and Ketcham , B. 1993
- Stanley , J.K. , Hensher , D.A. , and Loader , C. Road Transport and Climate Change: Stepping off the Greenhouse Gas Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 45 10 1020 1030 2011
- 2015
- Barlow , T.J. , Latham S. , McCrae I.S. , and Boulter P.G. 2009
- https://www.opel.ie/tools/wltp-drivingcycle-fuelconsumption.html/
- https://www.toyota-europe.com/new-cars/prius/index/specs
- Edwards , R. , Mahieu , V. , Griesemann , J.-C. , Larivé , J.-F. et al. Well-to-Wheels Analysis of Future Automotive Fuels and Powertrains in the European Context SAE Technical Paper 2004-01-1924 2004 10.4271/2004-01-1924
- Edwards , R. , Larivé , J.-F. , Rickeard , D. , and Weindorf , W. 2014
- Pagerit , S. , Sharer , P. , and Rousseau , A. Fuel Economy Sensitivity to Vehicle Mass for Advanced Vehicle Powertrains SAE Technical Paper 2006-01-0665 2006 10.4271/2006-01-0665
- Passmore , R. and Durnin , J.V.G.A. Human Energy Expenditure Physiological Reviews 35 4 801 840 1955
- Hall , C. , Arturo , F. , Fernhall , B.O. , and Kanaley , J.A. Energy Expenditure of Walking and Running: Comparison with Prediction Equations Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 36 2128 2134 2004
- 2004
- Léger , L. and Mercier , D. Gross Energy Cost of Horizontal Treadmill and Track Running Sports Medicine 1 4 270 277 1984
- Jette , M. , Sidney , K. , and Blümchen , G. Metabolic Equivalents (METS) in Exercise Testing, Exercise Prescription, and Evaluation of Functional Capacity Clinical Cardiology 13 8 555 565 1990
- Cohen , M. and Heberger , M. 2008
- Edholm , O.G. , Fletcher , J.G. , Widdowson , E.M. , and McCance , R.A. The Energy Expenditure and Food Intake of Individual Men British Journal of Nutrition 9 3 286 300 1955
- Levine , J.A. , Schleusner , S.J. , and Jensen , M.D. Energy Expenditure of Nonexercise Activity The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 72 6 1451 1454 2000
- Dong , L. , Block , G. , and Mandel , S. Activities Contributing to Total Energy Expenditure in the United States: Results from the NHAPS Study International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity 1 1 4 2004
- Chang , Y.-H. and Kram , R. Metabolic Cost of Generating Horizontal Forces during Human Running Journal of Applied Physiology 86 5 1657 1662 1999
- Farley , C.T. and McMahon , T.A. Energetics of Walking and Running: Insights from Simulated Reduced-Gravity Experiments Journal of Applied Physiology 73 6 2709 2712 1992
- Kram , R. and Taylor , C.R. Energetics of Running: A New Perspective Nature 346 6281 265 1990
- Roberts , T.J. , Rodger , K. , Weyand , P.G. , and Taylor , C.R. Energetics of Bipedal Running. I. Metabolic Cost of Generating Force Journal of Experimental Biology 201 19 2745 2751 1998
- Carlsson-Kanyama , A. and González , A.D. Potential Contributions of Food Consumption Patterns to Climate Change The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 89 5 1704S 1709S 2009
- Johansson , B. 2014
- Merrill , A.L. and Watt , B.K. Energy Value of Foods: Basis and Derivation Agriculture Handbook 74 Washington, DC United States Department of Agriculture 1973
- Maclean , W. , Harnly , J. , Chen , J. , Chevassus-Agnes , S. et al. 2003
- Novotny , J.A. , Gebauer , S.K. , and Baer , D.J. Discrepancy between the Atwater Factor Predicted and Empirically Measured Energy Values of Almonds in Human Diets The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 96 2 296 301 2012
- https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/food-availability-per-capita-data-system/
- Pandey , D. , Agrawal , M. , and Pandey , J.S. Carbon Footprint: Current Methods of Estimation Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 178 1-4 135 160 2011
- Guinée , J.B. Handbook on Life Cycle Assessment Operational Guide to the ISO Standards The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment 7 5 311 2002
- 2008
- Eggleston , S. , Buendia , L. , and Miwa , K. 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories [Recurso electrónico]: Waste Kanagawa, JP Institute for Global Environmental Strategies 2006
- Williams , A. , Audsley , E. , and Sandars , D. Determining the Environmental Burdens and Resource use in the Production of Agricultural and Horticultural Commodities: Defra Project Report IS0205 http://randd.defra.gov.uk/Default.aspx 2006
- Cederberg , C. and Stadig , M. System Expansion and Allocation in Life Cycle Assessment of Milk and Beef Production The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment 8 6 350 356 2003
- Casey , J.W. and Holden , N.M. Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Conventional, Agri-Environmental Scheme, and Organic Irish Suckler-Beef Units Journal of Environmental Quality 35 1 231 239 2006
- Stackhouse-Lawson , K.R. , Rotz , C.A. , Oltjen , J.W. , and Mitloehner , F.M. Carbon Footprint and Ammonia Emissions of California Beef Production Systems Journal of Animal Science 90 12 4641 4655 2012
- Ogino , A. , Orito , H. , Shimada , K. , and Hirooka , H. Evaluating Environmental Impacts of the Japanese Beef Cow-Calf System by the Life Cycle Assessment Method Animal Science Journal 78 4 424 432 2007
- Heller , M.C. and Keoleian , G.A. Greenhouse Gas Emission Estimates of US Dietary Choices and Food Loss Journal of Industrial Ecology 19 3 391 401 2015
- Scarborough , P. , Appleby , P.N. , Mizdrak , A. , Briggs , A.D.M. et al. Dietary Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Meat-Eaters, Fish-Eaters, Vegetarians and Vegans in the UK Climatic Change 125 2 179 192 2014
- Casaburi , R. , Barstow , T.J. , Terry , R. , and Karlman , W. Influence of Work Rate on Ventilatory and Gas Exchange Kinetics Journal of Applied Physiology 67 2 547 555 1989
- Van Der Walt , W.H. and Wyndham , C.H. An Equation for Prediction of Energy Expenditure of Walking and Running Journal of Applied Physiology 34 5 559 563 1973
- A. C. of Sports Medicine Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription Williams & Wilkins 1991
- Ejaimi , G. and Saeed , S.
- Glenny , R.W. and Robertson , H.T. Introduction to Cardiopulmonary Exercise Testing New York Springer 2013