This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Analysis of Rear Seat Sled Tests with the 5th Female Hybrid III: Incorrect Conclusions in Bidez et al. SAE 2005-01-1708
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 2, 2019 by SAE International in United States
This content contains downloadable datasetsAnnotation ability available
Objective: Sled test video and data were independently analyzed to assess the validity of statements and conclusions reported in Bidez et al. SAE paper 2005-01-1708 .
Method: An independent review and analysis of the test data and video was conducted for 9 sled tests at 35 km/h (21.5 mph). The 5th female Hybrid III was lap-shoulder belted in the 2nd or 3rd row seat of a SUV buck. For one series, the angle was varied from 0, 15, 30, 45 and 60 deg PDOF. The second series involved shoulder belt pretensioning and other belt modifications.
Results: Bidez et al.  claimed “The lap belts moved up and over the pelvis of the small female dummy for all impact angles tested.” We found that there was no submarining in any of the tests with the production lap-shoulder belts. Bidez et al.  claimed “H3-5F dummies began to roll out of their shoulder belt at… 30 degrees. Complete loss of torso support was seen at 45 degrees without significant kinetic energy dissipation.” We found that the shoulder belt remained in place and restrained the upper torso in the 0, 15 and 30 deg sled tests. At 45 and 60 deg, significant restraint was provided before the belt slipped off the shoulder. It remained in contact with the arm and chest providing restraint. Bidez et al.  claimed “The results indicated kinematic movement of the dummies, which were predictive of injury in all sled runs.” We found that the kinematic control was good and the biomechanical responses were well below IARVs for the 5th female Hybrid III. Bidez et al.  claimed “a retractor pretensioner (7 ms fire time) eliminated both submarining and torso rollout in the H3-5F in the conditions tested.” We found that the pretensioner firing pulled the lap belt up onto the abdomen inducing submarining and causing abdominal loading in two out of four tests.
Conclusion: The independent review of the videos and data shows that Bidez et al.  misstated the results, misrepresented the findings and reached incorrect conclusions on the testing.
CitationViano, D. and Parenteau, C., "Analysis of Rear Seat Sled Tests with the 5th Female Hybrid III: Incorrect Conclusions in Bidez et al. SAE 2005-01-1708," SAE Technical Paper 2019-01-0618, 2019, https://doi.org/10.4271/2019-01-0618.
Data Sets - Support Documents
|[Unnamed Dataset 1]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 2]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 3]|
- Kulowski, J. and Rost, W.B., “Intra-Abdominal Injuries from Safety Belt in Auto Accident,” Arch Surg 73:970-971, December, 1956.
- Patrick, L.M. and Anderson, A., “Three-Point Harness Accident and Laboratory Data Comparison,” SAE Technical Paper 741181, 1974, doi:10.4271/741181.
- Adomeit, D. and Heger, A., “Motion Sequence Criteria and Design Proposals for Restraint Devices in Order to Avoid Unfavorable Biomechanic Conditions and Submarining,” SAE Technical Paper 751146, 1975, doi:10.4271/751146.
- Adomeit, D., “Evaluation Methods for the Biomechanical Quality of Restraint Systems During Frontal Impact,” SAE Technical Paper 770936, 1977, doi:10.4271/770936.
- Rouhana, S.W., Viano, D.C., Jedrzejczak, E.A., and JD, M.C., “Assessing Submarining and Abdominal Injury Risk in the Hybrid III Family of Dummies,” SAE Technical Paper 892440, 1989, doi:10.4271/892440.
- Uriot, J., Pascal, B., Potier, P., Trosseille, X. et al., “Investigations on the Belt-to-Pelvis Interaction in Case of Submarining. 50th Stapp Car Conference,” Stapp Car Crash Journal 50:53-73, 2006.
- Bidez, M., Hauschild, H., Syson, S., and Mergl, K., “Lap-Shoulder Belt Performance as a Function of Occupant Size,” SAE Technical Paper 2005-01-1705, 2005, doi:10.4271/2005-01-1705.
- Beck, B., Bilston, L.E., and Brown, J., “Injury Patterns of Rear Seat Occupants in Frontal Impact: An In-Depth Crash Investigation Study,” Inj Prev. 22(3):165-170, 2016 Jun.
- Beck, B., Brown, J., and Bilston, L.E., “Assessment of Vehicle and Restraint Design Changes for Mitigating Rear Seat Occupant Injuries,” Traffic Inj Prev. 15(7):711-719, 2014.
- Beck, B., Brown, J., and Bilston, L.E., “Variations in Rear Seat Cushion Properties and the Effects on Submarining,” Traffic Inj Prev. 12(1):54-61, 2011 Feb.
- Bidez, M., Hauschild, H., Mergl, K., and Syson, S., “Small Occupant Dynamics in the Rear Seat: Influence of Impact Angle and Belt Restraint Design,” SAE Technical Paper 2005-01-1708, 2005, doi:10.4271/2005-01-1708.
- Burke, D.S., Bidez, M.W., and Mergl, K.M., “Influence of Vehicle Restraint System Design on the Kinematics and Neck Forces of a Rear Seat Small Occupant,” in ASME 2011 Summer Bioengineering Conference, Farmington, Pennsylvania, USA, June 22-25, 2011, Paper No. SBC2011-53779, 979-980.
- Burke, D.S., “Influence of Socioecomonic Status and System Design on Child Passenger Safety,” Doctor of Philosophy Dissertation, The University of Alabama at Birmingham, 2013.
- Furas, A., Bidez, M.W., Burke, D.S., Mergl, K.M., Rosenberg, M., Rodriguez, N., and Hayes, L.A., “Demonstration Project to Protect Child Road Users in a Latin American Country: Year 1 Engineering Assessment Status Report,” in 6th International Conference on Protection of Children in Cars, Munich, December 4-5, 2008.
- Gunterberg, E. and Johansson, A., “Simulation and Analysis of Child Kinematics during Pre-Crash Maneuvers: FE Simulation and Physical Testing,” masters thesis, Chalmers University 2012.
- Jakobsson, L., Bohman, K., Andersson, M., Stockman, I., Bostrom, O., Svensson, M., Svanberg, H., Wimmerstedt, M., and Arbogast, K., “Rear Seat Safety in Frontal to Side Impacts-Focusing on Occupant from 3yrs to Small Adult,” in The 22nd ESV Conference Proceedings, 2011.
- Klinich, K.D., Reed, M.P., Ebert, S.M., and Rupp, J.D., “Kinematics of Pediatric Crash Dummies Seated on Vehicle Seats with Realistic Belt Geometry,” Traffic Inj Prev. 15(8):866-874, 2014.
- Van Toen, C.Y., “Biomechanics of Cervical Spine and Spinal Cord Injury Under Combined Axial Compression and Lateral Bending Loading,” Doctoral Dissertation, University of British Columbia, 2013.
- Mertz, H.J., Irwin, A.L., and Prasad, P., “Biomechanical and Scaling Bases for Frontal and Side Impact Injury Assessment Reference Values,” , 2016, doi:10.4271/2016-22-0018.
- Horsch, J.D., “Occupant Dynamics as a Function of Impact Angle and Belt Restraint,” SAE Technical Paper 801310, 1980, doi:10.4271/801310.