This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Application of Extreme Value Theory to Crash Data Analysis
Published November 13, 2017 by The Stapp Association in United States
Annotation ability available
A parametric model obtained by fitting a set of data to a function generally uses a procedure such as maximum likelihood or least squares. In general this will generate the best estimate for the distribution of the data overall but will not necessarily generate a reasonable estimation for the tail of the distribution unless the function fitted resembles the underlying distribution function. A distribution function can represent an estimate that is significantly different from the actual tail data, while the bulk of the data is reasonably represented by the central part of the fitted distribution. Extreme value theory can be used to improve the predictive capabilities of the fitted function in the tail region.
In this study the peak-over-threshold approach from the extreme value theory was utilized to show that it is possible to obtain a better fit of the tail of a distribution than the procedures that use the entire distribution only. Additional constraints, on the current use of the extreme value approach with respect to the selection of the threshold (an estimate of the beginning of the tail region) that minimize the sensitivity to individual data samples associated with the tail section as well as contamination from the central distribution are used. Once the threshold is determined, the maximum likelihood method was used to fit the exceedances with the Generalized Pareto Distribution to obtain the tail distribution. The approach was then used in the analysis of airbag inflator pressure data from tank tests, crash velocity distribution and mass distribution from the field crash data (NASS).
From the examples, the extreme (tail) distributions were better estimated with the Generalized Pareto Distribution, than a single overall distribution, along with the probability of the occurrence for a given extreme value, or a rare observation such as a high speed crash. It was concluded that the peak-over-threshold approach from extreme value theory can be a useful tool in the vehicle crash, biomechanics and injury tolerance data analysis and in estimation of the occurrence probability of an extreme phenomenon given a set of accurate observations.
|Journal Article||A Bayesian Approach to Cross-Validation in Pedestrian Accident Reconstruction|
|Technical Paper||Examination Protocol for Vehicles Equipped with an Inflatable Restraint System|
CitationXu, L. and Nusholtz, G., "Application of Extreme Value Theory to Crash Data Analysis," SAE Technical Paper 2017-22-0011, 2017, https://doi.org/10.4271/2017-22-0011.
- R. Smith 2003 Statistics of Extremes with Applications in Environment, Insurance and Finance
- R. Smith 1989 Extreme Value Analysis of Environmental Time Series: An Application to Trend Detection in Ground-Level Ozone Statistical Science 4 4 367 393
- R. M. Vogel , N.c. Matalas , J.F. England Jr. , and A. Castellarin 2007 An Assessment of Exceedance Probability of Envelope Curves Water Resources Research 43
- M.T. Brunetti , S. Peruccacci , M. Rossi , S. Luciani , D. Valigi , and F. Guzzetti 2010 Rainful Threshold for the Possible Occurance of Landslides in Italy Nat. Hazaeds Earth Syst. Sci 10 447 458
- M. Gilli and E. Kellezi 2006 An Application of Extreme Value Theory for Measuring Financial Risk Computational Economics 27 1 1 23
- Y. Bensalah 2000 Steps in Appling Extreme Value Theory to Finance: A Review, Working Paper 2000-20 Bank of Canada
- P. Embrechts , S.I. Resnick , and G. Samorodnitsky 1999 Extreme Value Theory as a Risk. Managgement Tool North American Actuarial Journal 3 2
- X. Conort 2010 Quantile Estimation of Heavy Tail Dist ributions and Model Risks of EVT Technoques, Bulletin Francais D’Acturaet 10 19 Janvier-Juin 2010 63 109
- Fisher , R.A. ; Tippett , L.H.C. 1928 Limiting forms of the frequency distribution of the largest and smallest member of a sample 24 180 190
- Gumbel , E. J. 1958 Statistics of Extremes Mineola, NY Dover 0-486-43604-7
- ickands , J 1975 Statistical inference using extreme order statistics Annals of Statistics 3 119 131
- Balkema , A. 1974 Residual life time at great age Annals of Probability 2 792 804
- Coles , S. 2001 An introduction to statistical modeling of extreme values London, U.K. Springer-Verlag
- P.J Moiarty , W.E. Holley , and S.P. Butterfield 2004 Extrapolation of Extreme and Fatigue Loads Using Probabilistic Methods
- T. S. T. Wong and W.K. Li 2010 A Threshold Approach For Peak-Over-Threshold Modeling Using Maximum Product of Spacings Statistica Sinica 20 1257 1272
- A. Zoglat , S.EL Adlouni , E. Ezzahid , A. Amar , C.G. Okou and F. Badaoui 2000 Statistical Method to Expect Extreme Values: Application of POT Approach to CAC40 Return Index, J. of Economic Literature
- J. Zhang and M.A. Stephens 2010 A new and Efficient Estimation Method for Generalized Pareto Distribution Technometrics 51 3 316 325
- D. Draghicescu 2009 Modeling Threshold Exceedance Probability of Spatially Correlated Time Series Electronic J. of Statistics 3 149 164
- P.C. Embrechts , and T. Mikosch 1997 modelling Extremal Events for Insurance and Finance Berlin Springer
- B.M. Hill 1975 A Simple General Approach to Inference about the Tail of a Distribution The Annals of Statistics 3 5 1163 1174
- H. Drees , L. De Hann , and S. Resnick 2000 How to Make a Hill Plot The Annals of Statistics 28 1 254 274
- Joseph C. Watkins 2011