This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Comparison of Simple and Detailed Soot Models in the Study of Soot Formation in a Compression Ignition Diesel Engine
Technical Paper
2017-01-1006
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
This content contains downloadable datasets
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Application of computational method in studying soot formation and its characteristics has become more preferable in today’s automotive field. Current developments of computer programs with higher precision mathematical models enable simulation results to become closer to the real engine combustion phenomena. In the present study, investigation on soot has been performed using various soot models with different levels of complexity, from simple two-step Hiroyasu-NSC soot model to the detailed-kinetic soot model. Detailed soot models, Particulate Mimic (PM) which is based on methods of moment and Particulate Size Mimic (PSM) which is based on sectional method, are applied in this study. Result of soot mass from Hiroyasu-NSC model provides 120% error compare to experimental result, while both detailed models provide an acceptable error of 7%. In addition, the post-processing effort provide a qualitative information on soot mass distribution inside combustion chamber along simulation time, which almost impossible to be provided by experimental method. Additional analysis on the computational cost also gives some beneficial information to the use of different soot models which can be selected and applied for specific objectives.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Ibrahim, F., Wan Mahmood, W., Abdullah, S., and Mansor, M., "Comparison of Simple and Detailed Soot Models in the Study of Soot Formation in a Compression Ignition Diesel Engine," SAE Technical Paper 2017-01-1006, 2017, https://doi.org/10.4271/2017-01-1006.Data Sets - Support Documents
| Title | Description | Download |
|---|---|---|
| Unnamed Dataset 1 | ||
| Unnamed Dataset 2 | ||
| Unnamed Dataset 3 | ||
| Unnamed Dataset 4 | ||
| Unnamed Dataset 5 | ||
| Unnamed Dataset 6 | ||
| Unnamed Dataset 7 |
Also In
References
- Ibrahim F. , Wan Mahmood W. M. F. , Abdullah S. , and Mansor M. R. Abu A review of soot particle measurement in lubricating oil Def. S&T Tech. Bull. 8 2 141 152 2015
- Ibrahim F. , Wan Mahmood W. M. F. , Abdullah S. , and Mansor M. R. Abu Investigation of soot emission in compression ignition diesel engine by CFD simulation ReCAR 2015 2015
- Ibrahim F. , Wan Mahmood W. M. F. , Abdullah S. , and Mansor M. R. Abu Soot particle measurement in engine cylinder: A review J. Teknol. 78 8 187 195 2016
- Wan Mahmood W. M. F. Computational studies of soot paths to cylinder wall layers of a direct injection diesel engine The University of Nottingham United Kingdom 2011
- Wan Mahmood , W. , LaRocca , A. , Shayler , P. , Bonatesta , F. et al. Predicted Paths of Soot Particles in the Cylinders of a Direct Injection Diesel Engine SAE Technical Paper 2012-01-0148 2012 10.4271/2012-01-0148
- Bonatesta F. , La Rocca A. , Shayler P. J. , and Wahab E. The influence of swirl ratio on soot quantity and distribution in the cylinder of a diesel engine Third European Combustion Meeting ECM 2007 1 6
- Shayler , P. and Ng , H. Simulation Studies of the Effect of Fuel Injection Pattern on NO and Soot Formation in Diesel Engines SAE Technical Paper 2004-01-0116 2004 10.4271/2004-01-0116
- Weber , J. , Peters , N. , Bockhorn , H. , and Pittermann , R. Numerical Simulation of the Evolution of the Soot Particle Size Distribution in a DI Diesel Engine Using an Emulsified Fuel of Diesel-Water SAE Technical Paper 2004-01-1840 2004 10.4271/2004-01-1840
- Cui , X. , Zhou , B. , Matsunaga , M. , Fujii , Y. et al. A Numerical Study of the Effects of FAME Blends on Diesel Combustion and Emissions Characteristics Using a 3-D CFD Code Combined with Detailed Kinetics and Phenomenological Soot Formation Models SAE Int. J. Fuels Lubr. 6 3 839 851 2013 10.4271/2013-01-2689
- Zuber M. A. , Wan Mahmood W. M. F. , Harun Z. , and Zainol Abidin Z. Soot Particle Evolution and Transport in a Direct Injection Diesel Engine J. Teknol. 74 3 85 88 2015
- Zuber , M. , Wan Mahmood , W. , Harun , Z. , Zainol Abidin , Z. et al. Modeling of In-Cylinder Soot Particle Size Evolution and Distribution in a Direct Injection Diesel Engine SAE Technical Paper 2015-01-1075 2015 10.4271/2015-01-1075
- Lim , J. and Min , K. The Effects of Spray Angle and Piston Bowl Shape on Diesel Engine Soot Emissions Using 3-D CFD Simulation SAE Technical Paper 2005-01-2117 2005 10.4271/2005-01-2117
- Raj R. T. K. and Manimaran R. Effect of swirl in a constant speed DI diesel engine using computational fluid dynamics CFD Lett. 4 4 214 224 2012
- Adomeit , P. , Lang , O. , Schulz , R. , and Weng , V. CFD Simulation of Diesel Injection and Combustion SAE Technical Paper 2002-01-0945 2002 10.4271/2002-01-0945
- Sencic T. , Medica V. , and Bukovac O. Soot model validation and development Adv. Eng. 4 1 75 86 2010
- Bissoli , M. , Cuoci , A. , Frassoldati , A. , Faravelli , T. et al. Detailed Kinetic Analysis of HCCI Combustion Using a New Multi-Zone Model and CFD Simulations SAE Int. J. Engines 6 3 1594 1609 2013 10.4271/2013-24-0021
- Kawanabe H. and Ishiyama T. Computational fluid dynamics analysis of the combustion process and emission characteristics for a direct-injection-premixed charge compression ignition engine Int. J. Engine Res. 15 5 539 548 2014
- Wei S. , Wang F. , Leng X. , Liu X. , and Ji K. Numerical analysis on the effect of swirl ratios on swirl chamber combustion system of DI diesel engines Energy Convers. Manag. 75 184 190 2013
- Wang Z. , Srinivasan K. K. , Krishnan S. R. , and Som S. A computational investigation of diesel and biodiesel combustion and NOx formation in a light-duty compression ignition engine Spring Technical Meeting of the Central States Section of the Combustion Institute 2012 1 11
- Ren Y. , Abu-Ramadan E. , and Li X. Numerical simulation of biodiesel fuel combustion and emission characteristics in a direct injection diesel engine Front. Energy Power Eng. China 4 2 252 261 2010
- Pang K. M. , Ng H. K. , and Gan S. In-cylinder diesel spray combustion simulations using parallel computation : A performance benchmarking study Appl. Energy 93 2012 466 478 May 2012
- Pang K. M. , Ng H. K. , and Gan S. Simulation of temporal and spatial soot evolution in an automotive diesel engine using the Moss-Brookes soot model Energy Convers. Manag. 58 x 171 184 2012
- Kennedy I. M. Models of soot formation and oxidation Prog. Energy Combust. Sci. 23 95 132 1997
- Tesner P. , Snegiriova T. , and Knorre V. Kinetics of dispersed carbon formation Combust. Flame 17 253 260 1971
- Khan I. , Greeves G. , and Probert D. Air pollution control in transport engines Inst. Mech. Eng. C142 71 205 217 1971
- Khan I. and Greeves G. A method for calculating the formation and combustion of soot in diesel engines Heat Transfer in Flames Afgan N. and Beer J. Washington DC Scripta 1974
- Hiroyasu H. and Kadota T. Development and use of a spray combustion modeling to predict diesel engine efficiency and pollutant emissions (Part 1 Combustion modeling) Bull. JSME 26 214 569 575 1983
- Nishida , K. and Hiroyasu , H. Simplified Three-Dimensional Modeling of Mixture Formation and Combustion in a D.I. Diesel Engine SAE Technical Paper 890269 1989 10.4271/890269
- Yoshizaki , T. , Nishida , K. , and Hiroyasu , H. Approach to Low NOx and Smoke Emission Engines by Using Phenomenological Simulation SAE Technical Paper 930612 1993 10.4271/930612
- Belardini , P. , Bertoli , C. , Ciajolo , A. , D'Anna , A. et al. Three Dimensional Calculations of DI Diesel Engine Combustion and Comparison whit In Cylinder Sampling Valve Data SAE Technical Paper 922225 1992 10.4271/922225
- Patterson , M. , Kong , S. , Hampson , G. , and Reitz , R. Modeling the Effects of Fuel Injection Characteristics on Diesel Engine Soot and NOx Emissions SAE Technical Paper 940523 1994 10.4271/940523
- Fusco A. , Knox-Kelecy A. L. , and Foster D. E. Application of a phenomenological soot model to diesel engine combustion Conference on Modeling and Diagnostics for Advanced Engine Systems COMODIA 94 1994 571 576
- Kazakov , A. and Foster , D. Modeling of Soot Formation During DI Diesel Combustion Using a Multi-Step Phenomenological Model SAE Technical Paper 982463 1998 10.4271/982463
- Liu , Y. , Tao , F. , Foster , D. , and Reitz , R. Application of A Multiple-Step Phenomenological Soot Model to HSDI Diesel Multiple Injection Modeling SAE Technical Paper 2005-01-0924 2005 10.4271/2005-01-0924
- Idicheria , C. and Pickett , L. Formaldehyde Visualization Near Lift-off Location in a Diesel Jet SAE Technical Paper 2006-01-3434 2006 10.4271/2006-01-3434
- Tao F. , Golovvitchev V. I. , and Chomiak J. Application of complex chemistry to investigate the combustion zone structure of DI diesel sprays under engine-like conditions (DE-3) diesel engine combustion 3-modeling) Proceedings of the conference on modeling and diagnostics for advanced engine systems (COMODIA) 2001 92 100
- Tao F. , Reitz R. D. , Foster D. E. , and Liu Y. Nine-step phenomenological diesel soot model validated over a wide range of engine conditions Int. J. Therm. Sci. 48 6 1223 1234 2009
- Vishwanathan G. and Reitz R. D. Development of a practical soot modeling approach and its application to low-temperature diesel combustion Combust. Sci. Technol. 182 8 1050 1082 2010
- Cheng X. , Chen L. , Yan F. , and Dong S. Study on soot formation characteristics in the diesel combustion process based on an improved detailed soot model Energy Convers. Manag. 75 1 10 2013
- Pang B. , Xie M.-Z. , Jia M. , and Liu Y. Development of a phenomenological soot model coupled with a skeletal PAH mechanism for practical engine simulation Energy & Fuels 27 1699 1711 2013
- Kong S.-C. , Sun Y. , and Rietz R. D. Modeling diesel spray flame liftoff, sooting tendency, and NOx emissions using detailed chemistry with phenomenological soot model J. Eng. Gas Turbines Power 129 245 251 2007
- Kolaitis D. I. and Founti M. A. On the assumption of using n-heptane as a ‘surrogate fuel’ for the description of the cool flame oxidation of diesel oil Proc. Combust. Inst. 32 3197 3205 2009
- Omidvarborna H. , Kumar A. , and Kim D. Recent studies on soot modeling for diesel combustion Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 48 635 647 2015
- Richards K. J. , Senecal P. K. , and Pomraning E. CONVERGE (v2.2.0) Madison, WI, WI Convergent Science, Inc. 2014
- Choi M. Y. , Hamins A. , Mulholland G. W. , and Kashiwagi T. Simultaneous optical measurement of soot volume fraction and temperature in premixed flames Combust. Flame 99 174 186 1994
- Zeuch T. , Moréac G. , Ahmed S. S. , and Mauss F. A comprehensive skeletal mechanism for the oxidation of n-heptane generated by chemistry-guided reduction Combust. Flame 155 651 674 2008
- Mauss F. , Trillken B. , Breitbach H. , and Peters N. Soot Combustion - Mechanisms and Models Berlin Springer-Verlag 1994
- Wen J. Z. , Thomson M. J. , Park S. H. , Rogak S. N. , and Lightstone M. F. Study of soot growth in a plug flow reactor using a moving sectional model Proc. Combust. Inst. 30 1477 1484 2005
- Kumar S. and Ramkrishna D. On the solution of population balance equations by discretization - II. A moving pivot technique Chem. Eng. Sci. 51 8 1333 1342 1996
- Heywood J. B. Internal Combustion Engine Fundamentals USA 1988
- Reitz R. D. and Bracco F. V. Mechanisms of breakup of round liquid jets Encyclopedia of Fluid Mechanics Houston Gulf Pub. 1986 233
- Ricart , L. , Xin , J. , Bower , G. , and Reitz , R. In-Cylinder Measurement and Modeling of Liquid Fuel Spray Penetration in a Heavy-Duty Diesel Engine SAE Technical Paper 971591 1997 10.4271/971591
- Liu , A. , Mather , D. , and Reitz , R. Modeling the Effects of Drop Drag and Breakup on Fuel Sprays SAE Technical Paper 930072 1993 10.4271/930072
- Schmidt D. P. and Rutland C. J. A new droplet collision algorithm J. Comput. Phys. 164 62 80 2000
- Naber , J. and Reitz , R. Modeling Engine Spray/Wall Impingement SAE Technical Paper 880107 1988 10.4271/880107
- Gonzalez D., M. , Lian , Z. , and Reitz , R. Modeling Diesel Engine Spray Vaporization and Combustion SAE Technical Paper 920579 1992 10.4271/920579
- Han Z. and Reitz R. D. Turbulence modeling of internal combustion engines using RNG κ - ϵ models Combust. Sci. Technol. 106 4-6 267 295 1995
- Senecal , P. , Pomraning , E. , Richards , K. , Briggs , T. et al. Multi-Dimensional Modeling of Direct-Injection Diesel Spray Liquid Length and Flame Lift-off Length using CFD and Parallel Detailed Chemistry SAE Technical Paper 2003-01-1043 2003 10.4271/2003-01-1043
- Computational Engineering International Inc. EnSight User Manual for version 10.1 USA Computational Engineering International, Inc. 2013
- Hiroyasu , H. and Kadota , T. Models for Combustion and Formation of Nitric Oxide and Soot in Direct Injection Diesel Engines SAE Technical Paper 760129 1976 10.4271/760129
- Walls J. R. and Strickland-Constable R. F. Oxidation of Carbon between 1000-2400 C Carbon N. Y. 1 333 338 1964
- Zuber M. A. , Wan Mahmood W. M. F. , Zainol Abidin Z. , and Harun Z. In-cylinder soot particle distribution in squish region of a direct injection diesel engine Int. J. Mech. Mechatronics Eng. 14 05 51 58 2014
- Kazakov A. and Frenklach M. Dynamic modeling of soot particle coagulation and aggregation: implementation with the method of moments and application to high-pressure laminar premixed flames Combust. Flame 114 484 501 1998
- Frenklach M. and Wang H. Detailed modeling of soot particle nucleation and growth Twenty-Third Symposium (International) on Combustion 1990 1559 1566
- Alkidas , A. Relationships Between Smoke Measurements and Particulate Measurements SAE Technical Paper 840412 1984 10.4271/840412