This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Yaw Effects on the Narrowband Spectra Above a Delta Wing in Turbulent Flow
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published September 20, 2016 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Combat aircraft maneuvering at high angles of attack or in landing approach are likely to encounter conditions where the flow over the swept wings is yawed. This paper examines the effect of yaw on the spectra of turbulence above and aft of the wing, in the region where fins and control surfaces are located. Prior work has shown the occurrence of narrowband velocity fluctuations in this region for most combat aircraft models, including those with twin fins. Fin vibration and damage has been traced to excitation by such narrowband fluctuations. The narrowband fluctuations themselves have been traced to the wing surface. The issue in this paper is the effect of yaw on these fluctuations, as well as on the aerodynamic loads on a wing, without including the perturbations due to the airframe. A 42 degree delta wing with rounded leading edges, roughly equivalent to a 1/20 scale of existing combat aircraft, is used in a 2.74 m low speed wind tunnel in the angle of attack range 18 to 35 degrees and over a range of yaw settings. Aerodynamic load coefficients are measured using a 6-DOF load cell while the velocity field fluctuations are sensed using a hot-film anemometer probe. Results show that the spectra, while modified, still exhibit a narrow-band peak with only minor changes in peak frequency at all yaw conditions, showing that the basic phenomenon at the delta wing surface is unchanged. Load cell data show minor variations in integrated loads..
CitationThorell, N., Kumar, V., and Komerath, N., "Yaw Effects on the Narrowband Spectra Above a Delta Wing in Turbulent Flow," SAE Technical Paper 2016-01-2056, 2016, https://doi.org/10.4271/2016-01-2056.
- Komerath, N., Liou, S., Schwartz, R., and Kim, J., “Flow over a twin-tailed aircraft at angle of attack. 1 - Spatial characteristics”. Journal of Aircraft, 29(3), pp. 413-420, 1992.
- Komerath, N., Schwartz, R., and Kim, J.,. “Flow over a twin-tailed aircraft at angle of attack. 2- Temporal characteristics”. Journal of Aircraft, 29(4), pp. 553-558, 1992.
- Komerath, N., and Hubner, J., “Development of narrow-band velocity fluctuations in vortex flows”. In 26th AIAA Fluid Dynamics Conference, AIAA Paper 95-2304, 1995..
- Zharfa, M., Ozturk, I., and Yavuz, M. M., “Flow structure on nonslender delta wing: Reynolds number dependence and flow control”. AIAA Journal, 54(1), pp. 1-18, 2016.
- Campbell, J. P., Johnson J. L., Jr, and Hewes, D. E.,. “Low-speed study of the effect of frequency on the stability derivatives of wings oscillating in yaw with particular reference to high angle-of-attack conditions”, NACA Research Memorandum RM L55H05, 1955.
- Fletcher, H. S., “Low-speed experimental determination of the effects of leading-edge radius and profile thickness on static and oscillatory lateral stability derivatives for a delta wing with 60 degrees of leading-edge sweep”. NACA TN4341, July 1958.
- Levin, D., and Katz, J., “Dynamic load measurements with delta wings undergoing self-induced roll oscillations”. Journal of Aircraft, 21(1), pp. 30- 36. 1984
- Rao, D. M., and Campbell, J. F., “Vortical flow management techniques”. Progress in Aerospace Sciences, 24(3), pp. 173-224. 1987.
- Payne, F., Ng, T., Nelson, R., and Schiff, L.. “Visualization and wake surveys of vortical flow over a delta wing”. AIAA Journal, 26(2), pp. 137-143. 1988
- Verhaagen, N. G., and Naarding, S. H., “Experimental and numerical investigation of vortex flow over a sideslipping delta wing”. Journal of Aircraft, 26(11), pp. 971-978. 1989.
- Lee, M., and Ho, C.-M., “Lift force of delta wings”. Applied Mechanics Reviews, 43(9), pp. 209- 221. 1990.
- Stahl, W., MAHMOOD, and Asghar, A., “Experimental investigations of the vortex flow on delta wings at high incidence”. AIAA Journal, 30(4), pp. 1027-1032. 1992.
- Helin, H., and Watry, C., “Effects of trailing-edge jet entrainment on delta wing vortices”. AIAA Journal, 32(4), pp. 802- 804. 1994.
- Lowson, M., and Riley, A., “Vortex breakdown control by delta wing geometry”. Journal of Aircraft, 32(4), pp. 832-838. 1995.
- Honkan, A., and Andreopoulos, J., “Instantaneous three-dimensional vorticity measurements in vortical flow over a delta wing”. AIAA Journal, 35(10), pp. 1612-1620. 1997.
- Ho, C., Jiang, F., Grosjean, C., Tai, Y., Lee, G., Chen, M., Newbern, S., and Simi Valley, C., “Application of MEMS devices to delta wing aircraft: from concept development to transonic flight test”. AIAA Paper 2001-0124, 39th Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit, Reno, NV, U.S.A
- Hebbar, S., Platzer, M., and Fritzelas, A., “Reynolds number effects on the vortical-flow structure generated by a double-delta wing”. Experiments in Fluids, 28(3), pp. 206-216. 2000.
- Morton, S. A., Forsythe, J. R., Mitchell, A. M., and Hajek, D., “DES and RANS simulations of delta wing vortical flows”. AIAA Paper AIAA-02-0587, 2002.
- Sohn, M. H., and Lee, K. Y., “Experimental investigation of vortex flow of a yawed delta wing having leading edge extension”. AIAA Paper, 2002-3267, 2002.
- Yaniktepe, B., and Rockwell, D., “Flow structure on a delta wing of low sweep angle”. AIAA Journal, 42(3), pp. 513-523. 2004.
- Mitchell, A. M., Morton, S. A., Forsythe, J. R., and Cummings, R. M., “Analysis of delta-wing vortical substructures using detached-eddy simulation”. AIAA Journal, 44(5), pp. 964-972. 2006.
- Canpolat, C., Yayla, S., Sahin, B., and Akilli, H., “Dye visualization of the flow structure over a yawed nonslender delta wing”. Journal of Aircraft, 46(5), pp. 1818-1822. 2009.
- Yayla, S., Canpolat, C., Sahin, B., and Akilli, H., “Yaw angle effect on flow structure over the nonslender diamond wing”. AIAA Journal, 48(10), pp. 2457-2461, 2010.
- Colvin, B., Mullans, R., Paul, R., and Roos, H.,. F-15 vertical tail vibration investigations. MDC Report A6114, McDonnell-Douglas Corporation, September 1979.
- Ferman, M., Huttsell, L., and Turner, E.,. “Experiments with tangential blowing to reduce buffet response on an F-15 model”. Journal of Aircraft, 41(4), pp. 903-910, 2004.
- Sheta, E. F., “Prediction and control of twin- tail buffet of fighter aircraft”. DTIC document, CFD Research Corporation. 2002.
- Wolfe, S., “Impingement of a streamwise vor- tex from a delta wing on a thin plate: a source of turbulent buffeting”. PhD thesis, Lehigh University. 1994.
- Lambert, C., and Gursul, I., “Characteristics of fin buffeting over delta wings”. Journal of fluids and structures, 19(3), pp. 307-319. 2004.
- Hubner, J. P., 1995. “An investigation of quasiperi- odic structures in the vortical flow over delta wing configuration”. PhD thesis, Daniel Guggenheim School of Aerospace Engineering.
- Hubner, J. P., and Komerath, N. M., “Spectral mapping of quasiperiodic structures in a vortex flow”. Journal of aircraft, 32(3), pp. 493-500. 1995.
- Hubner, J., and Komerath, N., “Counter-rotating structures over a delta wing”. AIAA Journal, 34(9), pp. 1958-1960, 1996.
- Klein, M., and Komerath,N.,”Reduction of narrow-band velocity fluctuations over an aircraft model”. In 15th AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Conference, AIAA Paper 97-31740, 1997.
- Josyula, E., and Gordnier, R. E., “Computational simulation of the f-22 aircraft”. Journal of Aircraft, 36(3), pp. 614-616. 1999.
- Kandebo, S. W., “Investigators scrutinizing f-22 vertical tall buffet”. Aviation Week & Space Technology, 156(18), pp. 26-26, 2002.
- Moses, R. W., and Huttsell, L., “Fin buffeting features of an early F-22 model”. No. 2000-1695 in AIAA Paper, 2000.
- Moses, R. W., Wieseman, C. D., Bent, A. A., and Pizzochero, A. E., “Evaluation of new actuators in a buffet loads environment”. In SPIE’s 8th Annual International Symposium on Smart Structures and Materials, International Society for Optics and Photonics, pp. 10-21, 2001.
- Black, C. L., Patel, S. R., and Anderson, W. D., “Low speed wind tunnel buffet testing on the F/A-22”. Journal of Aircraft, 43(4), pp. 879-885. 2006.
- Ashley, H., Rock, S., Digumarthi, R., and Chaney, K., Further study of active control for fin buffet alleviation, with application to f-22. Technical Report, WL-TR-97-3073, July 1997.
- Black,C., Patel, S., and Zapata, F., “Buffet fatigue sequence generation from F-22 flight test data using frequency domain methods”. 48th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics and Materials Conference, 2007.
- Wray W. R., Jr,. F-22 structural coupling lessons learned. Technical Report, DTIC Document ADP010475, May 2000