This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
From Trolley to Autonomous Vehicle: Perceptions of Responsibility and Moral Norms in Traffic Accidents with Self-Driving Cars
Technical Paper
2016-01-0164
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Autonomous vehicles represent a new class of transportation that may be qualitatively different from existing cars. Two online experiments assessed lay perceptions of moral norms and responsibility for traffic accidents involving autonomous vehicles. In Experiment 1, 120 US adults read a narrative describing a traffic incident between a pedestrian and a motorist. In different experimental conditions, the pedestrian, the motorist, or both parties were at fault. Participants assigned less responsibility to a self-driving car that was at fault than to a human driver who was at fault. Participants confronted with a self-driving car at fault allocated greater responsibility to the manufacturer and the government than participants who were confronted with a human driver at fault did. In Experiment 2, 120 US adults read a narrative describing a moral dilemma in which a human driver or a self-driving car must decide between either allowing five pedestrians to die or taking action to hit a single pedestrian in order to save the five. The “utilitarian” decision to hit the single pedestrian was considered the moral norm for both a self-driving and a human-driven car. Moreover, participants assigned the obligation of setting moral norms for self-driving cars to ethics researchers and to car manufacturers. This research reveals patterns of public perception of autonomous cars and may aid lawmakers and car manufacturers in designing such cars.
Recommended Content
| Technical Paper | Real Time Drivable Surface Determination Based on Stereo Vision |
| Technical Paper | The Automobile-the Unwanted Child |
| Technical Paper | Motion Planning of Vehicle Obstacle Avoidance in Complex Traffic Scenarios |
Authors
Citation
Li, J., Zhao, X., Cho, M., Ju, W. et al., "From Trolley to Autonomous Vehicle: Perceptions of Responsibility and Moral Norms in Traffic Accidents with Self-Driving Cars," SAE Technical Paper 2016-01-0164, 2016, https://doi.org/10.4271/2016-01-0164.Also In
References
- Hood , J. Google Defends Its Self-Driving Cars' Accident Rate Consumer Affairs May 12 2015 http://www.consumeraffairs.com/news/google-defends-its-self-driving-cars-accident-rate-051215.html
- Barry , K. Safety in Numbers: Charting Traffic-Safety and Fatality Data Car and Driver 2011 http://www.caranddriver.com/features/safety-in-numbers-charting-traffic-safety-and-fatality-data
- Lin , P. The Ethics of Autonomous Cars The Atlantic Oct 8 2013 http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/10/the-ethics-of-autonomous-cars/280360/
- Beiker , S. Legal Aspects of Autonomous Driving Santa Clara Law Review 52 4 1145 1156 2012
- Venkatesh , A. and Brown S. A Longitudinal Investigation of Personal Computers in Homes: Adoption Determinants and Emerging Challenges MIS Q 25 1 71 102 2012
- Malhotra , N. , Shotts , K. and Melvin , S. The Nut Behind the Wheel’ to ‘Moral Machines’: A Brief History of Auto Safety Stanford Graduate School of Business Case No. ETH4 2014
- Chipman , I. Exploring the Ethics Behind Self-Driving Cars Stanford Graduate School of Business 2015 http://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/exploring-ethics-behind-self-driving-cars
- Marcus , R. B. Moral dilemmas and consistency The Journal of Philosophy 177 3 121 136 1980
- Foot , P. The Problem of Abortion and the Doctrine of the Double Effect Oxford Review 5 1967
- Hevelke , A. and Nida-Rümelin , J. Responsibility for Crashes of Autonomous Vehicles: An Ethical Analysis Sci. Eng. Ethics 21 3 619 630 2014
- Goodall , N. Ethical Decision Making During Automated Vehicle Crashes Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board 2424 58 65 2014
- Złotowski , J. , Proudfoot , D. , Yogeeswaran , K. and Bartneck , C. Anthropomorphism: opportunities and challenges in human- robot interaction International Journal of Social Robotics 7 3 347 360 2015
- Reeves , B. and Nass , C. The Media Equation Cambridge Cambridge University Press 1996
- Parasuruman , R. , Sheridan , T. and Wickens , C. A Model for Types and Levels of Human Interaction with Automation IEEE Transactions of Systems, Man and Cybernetics - Part A 30 3 2000
- Payton , D. An architecture for reflexive autonomous vehicle control Robotics and Automation. Proceedings. 1986 IEEE International Conference on 3 1838 1845 1986
- Coeckelbergh , M. Moral Appearances: Emotions, Robots, and Human Morality Ethics and Information Technology 12 3 235 241 2010
- Malle , B. F. and Scheutz , M. Moral competence in social robots IEEE International Symposium on Ethics in Engineering, Science, and Technology 30 35 2014 Chicago, IL IEEE
- Barrett , J. and Johnson , A. The Role of Control in Attributing Intentional Agency to Inanimate Objects Journal of Cognition and Culture 3 3 208 217 2003
- Breazeal , C. Toward Sociable Robots Robotics and Autonomous Systems 42 3 167 175 2003
- Malle , B. , Scheutz , M. , Arnold , T. , Voiklis , J. et al. Sacrifice One for the Good of Many? People Apply Different Moral Norms to Human and Robot Agents HRI ’15 117 124 2015
- Public Opinion Survey Traffic and Public Safety Lafayette Parish 2001 http://www.lafayettela.gov/TrafficAndTransportation/SafeLight/SiteAssets/Files/WalkerAssociatedSurvey101101.pdf
- Streff , F. and Kostynuik , L. Survey of Public Perception of Traffic Law Enforcement in Michigan Transportation Research Institute UMTRI-2000-37 2000 http://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/handle/2027.42/1338
- Stern , D. A Survey to Determine the Influence of Traffic Accident Severity and Selected Variables on Seat Belt Usage by the General Public 1977
- Greene , J. D. , Sommerville , R. B. , Nystrom , L. E. , Darley , J. M. and Cohen , J. D. An fMRI investigation of emotional engagement in moral judgment Science 293 5537 2105 2108 2001
- O’Hara , R. Wording Effects in Moral Judgment Judgment and Decision Making 5 7 547 554 2010
- Ulfarsson , G. , Kim , S. and Booth , K. Analyzing fault in pedestrian-motor vehicle crashes in North Carolina Accident Analysis and Prevention 42 6 1805 1813 2010
- Broggi , A. , Bertozzi , M. , Fascioli , A. and Sechi , M. Shape-Based Pedestrian Detection Proceedings of the IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium 215 220 2000
- Gavrila , D. Pedestrian Detection from a Moving Vehicle ECCV 2000
- Young , K. and Salmon , P. Sharing the Responsibility for Driver Distraction Across Road Transport Systems: A Systems Approach to the Management of Distracted Driving Accident Analysis & Prevention 74 350 359 2015
- Stewart , A. Attributions of Responsibility for Motor Vehicle Crashes Accident Analysis & Prevention 37 4 681 688 2005
- Atchley , P. , Hadlock , C. and Lane , S. Stuck in the 70s: The Role of Social Norms in Distracted Driving Accident Analysis & Prevention 48 279 284 2012
- Gerstenberg , T. and Lagnado , D. A. Spreading the Blame: The Allocation of Responsibility Amongst Multiple Age nts Cognition 115 1 166 171 2010
- Folkes , V. Consumer Reactions to Product Failure: An Attributional Approach Journal of Consumer Research 10 4 398 409 1984