This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Fleet Fatality Risk and its Sensitivity to Vehicle Mass Change in Frontal Vehicle-to-Vehicle Crashes, Using a Combined Empirical and Theoretical Model
Published November 09, 2015 by The Stapp Association in United States
Annotation ability available
The objective of this study is to analytically model the fatality risk in frontal vehicle-to-vehicle crashes of the current vehicle fleet, and its sensitivity to vehicle mass change. A model is built upon an empirical risk ratio-mass ratio relationship from field data and a theoretical mass ratio-velocity change ratio relationship dictated by conservation of momentum. The fatality risk of each vehicle is averaged over the closing velocity distribution to arrive at the mean fatality risks. The risks of the two vehicles are summed and averaged over all possible crash partners to find the societal mean fatality risk associated with a subject vehicle of a given mass from a fleet specified by a mass distribution function.
Based on risk exponent and mass distribution from a recent fleet, the subject vehicle mean fatality risk is shown to increase, while at the same time that for the partner vehicles decreases, as the mass of the subject vehicle decreases. The societal mean fatality risk, the sum of these, incurs a penalty with respect to a fleet with complete mass equality. This penalty reaches its minimum (∼ 8% for the example fleet) for crashes with a subject vehicle whose mass is close to the fleet mean mass.
The sensitivity, i.e., the rate of change of the societal mean fatality risk with respect to the mass of the subject vehicle is assessed. Results from two sets of fully regression-based analyses, Kahane (2012) and Van Auken and Zellner (2013), are approximately compared with the current result. The general magnitudes of the results are comparable, but differences exist at a more detailed level. The subject vehicle-oriented societal mean fatality risk is averaged over all possible subject vehicle masses of a given fleet to obtain the overall mean fatality risk of the fleet. It is found to increase approximately linearly at a rate of about 0.8% for each 100 lb decrease in mass of all vehicles in the fleet.
CitationShi, Y. and Nusholtz, G., "Fleet Fatality Risk and its Sensitivity to Vehicle Mass Change in Frontal Vehicle-to-Vehicle Crashes, Using a Combined Empirical and Theoretical Model," SAE Technical Paper 2015-22-0011, 2015, https://doi.org/10.4271/2015-22-0011.
- Buzeman, D.G., Viano, D,C., Lövsund, P. (1998) Car Occupant Safety in Frontal Crashes: A Parameter Study of Vehicle Mass, Impact Velocity, and Inherent Vehicle Protection. Accident Analysis and Prevention 20(6):713-722.
- Buzeman-Jewkes, D.G., Viano, D.C., Lövsund P. (2000) Occupant Risk, Partner Risk and Fatality Rate in Frontal Crashes: Estimated Effects of Changing Vehicle Fleet Mass in 15 Years. J. of Crash Prevention and Injury Control 2(1):1-10.
- Evans, L., Frick, M.C. (1993) Mass Ratio and Relative Driver Fatality Risk in Two-vehicle Crashes. Accident Analysis and Prevention 25(2):213-224.
- Evans, L. (1994) Driver Injury and Fatality Risk in Two-car Crashes versus Mass Ratio Inferred Using Newtonian Mechanics. Accident Analysis and Prevention 26(5):609-616.
- Evans, L. (2004) How to Make a Car Lighter and Safer. SAE Technical Paper 2004-01-1172.
- Eyges, V., Padmanaban, J. (2009) Updated Evaluation of Size and Mass Effects in Front-to-Front Crashes Involving Light Vehicles. SAE Technical Paper 2009-01-0375.
- Green, P.E., Kostyniuk, L., Gordon, T.J., Reed, M.P. (2011) Independent Review: Statistical Analyses of Relationship between Vehicle Curb Weight, Track Width, Wheelbase and Fatality Rates. DOT HS 811 465.
- Joksch, H. (1993) Velocity Change and Fatality Risk in a Crash - a Rule of Thumb”, Accident Analysis and Prevention 25(1):103-104.
- Kahane, C.J. (1997) Relationship between Vehicle Size and Fatality Risk in Model Year 1985-93 Passenger Cars and Light Trucks. NHTSA Technical Report DOT HS 808 570.
- Kahane, C.J. (2003) Vehicle Weight, Fatality Risk and Crash Compatibility of Model Year 1991-99 Passenger Cars and Light Trucks. NHTSA Technical Report DOT HS 809 662.
- Kahane, C.J. (2012) Relationships between Fatality Risk, Mass, and Footprint in Model Year 2000-2007 Passenger Cars and LTVs - Final Report. NHTSA Technical Report DOT HS 811 665.
- Mizuno, K., Umeda, T., Yonezawa, H. (1997) The Relationship between Car Size and Occupant Injury in Traffic Accidents in Japan. SAE Technical Paper 970123.
- Nusholtz, G.S., Rabbiolo, G., Shi, Y. (2003) Estimation of the Effect of Vehicle Size and Mass on Crash-Injury Outcome through Parameterized Probability Manifolds. SAE Technical Paper 2003-09-05.
- Nusholtz, G.S., Xue, J. et al (2006) Effects of Different Vehicle Parameters on Car to Car Frontal Crash Fatality Risk Estimated Through a Parameterized Model. SAE Technical Paper 2006-01-1134.
- Shi, Y., Nusholtz, G.S. (2013) Effects of Vehicle Mass and Other Parameters on Driver Relative Fatality Risk in Vehicle-Vehicle Crashes. SAE Technical Paper 2013-01-0466.
- Van Auken, R.M., Zellner, J.W. (2002) An Assessment of the Effects of Vehicle Width on Fatality Risk in Model Year 1985-98 Passenger Cars and 1985-97 Light Trucks. DRI-TR-02-02, Dynamic Research, Inc.
- Van Auken, R.M., Zellner, J.W. (2003) A Further Assessment of the Effects of Vehicle Weight and size Parameters on Fatality Risk in Model Year 1985-98 Passengers Cars and 1985-97 Light Trucks. DRI-TR-03-01, Dynamic Research, Inc.
- Van Auken, R.M., Zellner, J.W. (2013) Updated Analysis of the Effects of Passenger Vehicle Size and Weight on Safety, Phase II: Results Based on 2002-2008 Calendar Year Data for 2000-2007 Light Passenger Vehicles. DRI-TR-13-02, Dynamic Research, Inc.
- Wenzel, T. (2012) An Analysis of the Relationship between Casualty Risk Per Crash and Vehicle Mass and Footprint for Model Year 2000-2007 Light-Duty Vehicles. Final Report Prepared for the Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, US Department of Energy, LBNL-5697E.