This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Aircraft In Situ Validation of Hydrometeors and Icing Conditions Inferred by Ground-based NEXRAD Polarimetric Radar
Technical Paper
2015-01-2152
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
MIT Lincoln Laboratory is tasked by the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration to investigate the use of the NEXRAD polarimetric radars* for the remote sensing of icing conditions hazardous to aircraft. A critical aspect of the investigation concerns validation that has relied upon commercial airline icing pilot reports and a dedicated campaign of in situ flights in winter storms. During the month of February in 2012 and 2013, the Convair-580 aircraft operated by the National Research Council of Canada was used for in situ validation of snowstorm characteristics under simultaneous observation by NEXRAD radars in Cleveland, Ohio and Buffalo, New York. The most anisotropic and easily distinguished winter targets to dual pol radar are ice crystals. Accordingly, laboratory diffusion chamber measurements in a tightly-controlled parameter space of temperature and humidity provide the linkage between shape and the expectation for the presence/absence of water saturation conditions necessary for icing hazard in situ. In agreement with the laboratory measurements pertaining to dendritic and hexagonal flat plate crystals, the aircraft measurements have verified the presence of supercooled water in mainly low concentrations coincident with regions showing layered anomalies of positive differential reflectivity (ZDR) by ground-based radar, otherwise known as +ZDR ‘bright bands’. Extreme values of ZDR (up to +8 dB) have also been found to be coincident with hexagonal flat plate crystals and intermittent supercooled water, also consistent with laboratory measurements.
The icing conditions found with the anisotropic description are considered non-classical (condensation/collision-coalescence) and require the ascent of air and availability of ice nuclei. A modest ascent rate (<1 m/s) is needed for preservation of the anisotropic ice crystal shapes, making them identifiable to dual-pol radar. In the other limit of strong ascent (several m/s and greater), a vigorous riming process is present leading to graupel and hail, and with attendant radar reflectivity of 30 dBZ and greater. These rimed hydrometeors are also readily verified by dual pol hydrometeor classification and in situ aircraft measurements. For the intermediate level of ascent speed, snow can become rimed, diluting its anisotropy, and presents a challenge to unambiguous detection of an icing condition by dual pol radar. This challenge is under current study.
Authors
- Earle Williams - Massachusetts Institute of Technology
- Michael F. Donovan - Massachusetts Institute of Technology
- David J. Smalley - Massachusetts Institute of Technology
- Robert G. Hallowell - Massachusetts Institute of Technology
- Elaine P. Griffin - Massachusetts Institute of Technology
- Kenta T. Hood - Massachusetts Institute of Technology
- Betty J. Bennett - Massachusetts Institute of Technology
- Mengistu Wolde - National Research Council of Canada
- Alexei V. Korolev - Environment Canada
Topic
Citation
Williams, E., Donovan, M., Smalley, D., Hallowell, R. et al., "Aircraft In Situ Validation of Hydrometeors and Icing Conditions Inferred by Ground-based NEXRAD Polarimetric Radar," SAE Technical Paper 2015-01-2152, 2015, https://doi.org/10.4271/2015-01-2152.Also In
References
- Atlas , D. 1966 The balance level in convective storms J. Atmos. Sci. 23 635 651
- Bailey , M.P. and Hallett J. 2009 A comprehensive habit diagram for atmospheric ice crystals: Confirmation from the laboratory, AIRS II and other field studies J. Atmos. Sci. 66 2888 2899
- Bernstein , B.C. , McDonough F. and Wolff C.A. 2004 Diagnosis of supercooled large drop conditions using cloud water content and drop concentration 11 th Conference on Aviation, Range and Aerospace Meteorology Hyannis, MA 11 14
- Bernstein , B. , McDonough F. , Politovich M. , Brown B. , Ratvasky T. , Miller D. , Wolff C. and Cunning G. 2005 Current Icing Potential: Algorithm description and comparison to aircraft observations J. Appl. Met. 44 919 986
- Cober , S.G. , Isaac G.A. , and Strapp J.W. 2001 Characterizations of aircraft icing environments that include supercooled large drops J. Appl. Met. 40 1984 2002
- Cober , S. , Bernstein B. , Jeck R. , Hill E. , Isaac G. , Riley J. and Shah A. 2009 Data and analysis for the development of an engineering standard for supercooled large drop conditions DOT/FAA/AR-09/10 U.S. Department of Transportation
- Elmore , K.L. The NSSL hydrometeor classification algorithm on winter surface precipitation: Evaluation and future development Weather and Forecasting 26 756 765 2011
- Evaristo , R. , Bals-Elsholz T. , Williams E. , Fenn A. J. , Donovan M. and Smalley D. 2013 Relationships of graupel shape to differential reflectivity: Theory and observations Annual Meeting, American Meteorological Society Austin, TX
- Hallowell , R. G. , Donovan M. F. , Smalley D. J. , Bennett B. J. 2013 Icing hazard detection with NEXRAD IHL 36 th AMS Conference on Radar Meteorology Breckenridge, CO.
- Hobbs , P.V. 1974 Ice Physics Clarendon Press Oxford
- Hogan , R.J. , Field P.R. , Illingworth A.J. , Cotton R.J. , and Choularton T.W. 2002 Properties of embedded convection in warm-frontal mixed-phase cloud from aircraft and polarimetric radar data Q.J.R.M.S. 128 451 476
- Houghton , H.G. 1985 Physical Meteorology MIT Press Cambridge, MA.
- Kennedy , P.C. and Rutledge S.A. 2011 S-band dual polarization radar observations in winter storms J. Appl. Met. Clim. 50 844 858
- Korolev , A.V. , Strapp J.W. , Isaac G.A. , and Nevzorov A.N. 1998 The Nevzorov airborne hot wire LWC-TWC probe: Principles of operation and performance characteristics J. Atmos. Ocean. Tech. 15 1495 1510
- Korolev , A.V. , Isaac G.A. , and Hallett J. 1999 Ice particle habits in Arctic clouds Geophysical Research Letters 26 1299 1302
- Korolev , A. and Sussman B. 2000 A technique for habit classification of cloud particles J. Atmos. Ocean. Tech. 17 1048 1057
- Korolev , A. , Emery E.F. , Strapp J.W. , Cober S.G. , Isaac G.A. , Wasey M. , Marcotte D. 2011 Small ice particles in tropospheric clouds: fact or artifact? Airborne Icing Instrumentation Evaluation Experiment Bull. Amer. Meteor. Soc. 92 967 973
- Korolev , A.V. , Emery E.F. , Strapp J.W. , Cober S.G. , Isaac G.A. 2014 Quantification of the effects of shattering on airborne ice particle measurements Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic Technology 30 2527 2553
- Ludlam , F.H. 1980 Clouds and Storms: The Behavior and Effect of Water in the Atmosphere Pennsylvania State University Press 405
- Park , H.S. , Ryzhkov A.V. , Zrnic D.S. and Kim K.-E. 2009 The hydrometeor classification algorithm for the polarimetric WSR-88D: Description and application to an MCS Weather and Forecasting 24 730 748
- Thompson , E.J. , Rutledge S.A. , Dolan B. , Chandrasekhar V. and Cheong B.L. 2014 A dual-polarization radar hydrometeor classification algorithm for winter precipitation J. Atmos. Oceanic Technol. 31 1457 1481 http://dx.doi.org/10.1175/JTECH-D-13-00119.1
- Vivekanandan , J. , Ellis S.M. , Oye R. , Zrnic D.S. , Ryzhkov A.V. and Straka J. Cloud microphysics retrieval using S-band dual-polarization radar measurements Bull. Am. Met. Soc. 80 381 388 1999
- Williams , E. , Rutledge S. , Geotis S. , Renno N. , Rasmussen E. and Rickenback T. 1992 A radar and electrical study of tropical ‘hot towers’ J. Atmos. Sci. 49 1386 1395
- Williams , E.R. and Zhang R. 1996 Density of rime in laboratory simulations of thunderstorm microphysics and electrification J. Geophys. Res. 101 D23 29715 29719
- Williams , E.R. , Smalley D.J. , Donovan M.F. , Hallowell R.G. , Hood K.T. , Bennett B.J. , Evaristo R. , Stepanek A. , Bals-Elsholz T. , Cobb J. , Ritzman J. 2011 Dual-polarized radar winter storm studies supporting development of NEXRAD-based aviation hazards products 35 th AMS Conference on Radar Meteorology Pittsburgh, PA
- Williams , E. , Smalley D. , Donovan M. , Hallowell R. , Hood K. , Bennett B. , Victoria E. , Wolde M. , Bastian M. , Korolev A. 2013 Validation of NEXRAD radar differential reflectivity in snowstorms with airborne microphysical measurements: Evidence for hexagonal flat plate crystals 36 th AMS Conference on Radar Meteorology Breckenridge, CO.
- Williams , E.R. , Smalley D.J. , Donovan M.F. , Hallowell R.G. , Hood K.T. , Bennett B.J. , Evaristo R. , Stepanek A. , Bals-Elsholz T. , Cobb J. , Ritzman J. , Korolev A. , Wolde M. 2015 A: Measurements of differential reflectivity in snowstorms and warm season stratiform systems J. Appl. Met. Clim.
- Williams , E.R. , Donovan M.F. , Smalley D.J. , Hallowell R.G. , Griffin E. , Hood K.T. , Bennett B.J. 2015 B: The 2013 Buffalo area icing and radar study (BAIRS) Project Report ATC-419 MIT Lincoln Laboratory Lexington, MA 132