This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Flammability of Plastics in Today's Automobiles
Technical Paper
2015-01-1380
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
According to the National Fire Protection Agency (NFPA), from the most recent available data, it was estimated that there were 164,000 highway vehicle fires in 2013 causing roughly 300 civilian fire deaths, 925 civilian fire injuries and $1.1 billion in property damages [1]. In a modern automobile, the plastics content is dramatically higher than it was in 1972, when Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (FMVSS) 302 was implemented [2]. FMVSS 302 applies only to materials in the passenger compartment and was put in place to address accidental fires started from sources such as cigarettes, matches, etc. There has never been any regulation for the plastic materials used outside the vehicle interior, including those used in under-the-hood (UTH) applications, and this is true even for today's automobiles. Combustible materials are roughly twice the weight and represent twice the heat content of the gasoline used in a typical passenger car today, constituting the major fire load [3]. In impact-survivable accidents, most frequently, plastic materials are the first to ignite; their ignition and continued burning are the major causes of death [3]. Increasing electronic content and the growth of electric and hybrid vehicles make material flammability even more critical [4]. Fire scientists have long recognized that FMVSS 302 is inadequate for interior materials in automobiles [5, 6, 7] and that there is a need for even stricter flammability regulations for UTH materials that are exposed to high heat and abuse [8].
The main objective of this paper is to address some of these concerns and provide additional information for what many have been advocating for a number of years [1,5, 6, 7, 8]. Several small scale tests like Limiting Oxygen Index, UL-94 and Cone Calorimetry were carried out, along with FMVSS 302, on representative plastic materials used in automobiles. Results from these studies are presented to show how one cannot rely on predicting the combustion behavior of these materials in a real fire and that significant improvements are needed to make today's and future automobiles safer.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Kumar, K., "Flammability of Plastics in Today's Automobiles," SAE Technical Paper 2015-01-1380, 2015, https://doi.org/10.4271/2015-01-1380.Also In
References
- Karter , M. Jr. Fire Loss in the United States during 2013 National Fire Protection Association, Fire Analysis and Research Division September 2014
- American Chemistry Council (ACC) Changing customer dynamics: Chemistry and light vehicles http://www.plastics-car.com/lightvehiclereport
- Diggs , K. , Stephenson , R. The basis for a fluid integrity NCAP rating http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/pdf/esv/esv21/09-0215.pdf
- Flame retarded plastics for electrical & electronic enclosures, components, wire & cables are used routinely to protect consumers from failures & malfunctions of these consumer products. There are several Consumer Product Safety Commission reports that recommend the use of flame retarded plastics in such EE applications see report CPSC-ES-TR-98-001 https://www.cpsc.gov//PageFiles/96136/electric.pdf
- Digges , K. , Gann , R. , Grayson , S. , Hirschler , M. , Lyon , R. , Purser , D. , Quintiere , J. , Stephenson , R. , Tewarson , A. Improving survivability in Motor Vehicle Fires International Interflam Conference, 11th Proceedings 1 September 3-5 2007 London, England 135 143 2007
- Lyon , R. and Walters , R. Flammability of Automotive Plastics SAE Technical Paper 2006-01-1010 2006 10.4271/2006-01-1010
- Storrs , C. and Lindemann , O. A General Discussion of Flammability as Related to the Automotive Industry and MVSS 302 SAE Technical Paper 720263 1972 10.4271/720263
- Digges , K. , Stephenson , R. Fire worthiness: A Final Report on the Technology Base Motor Vehicle Fire Research Institute USA
- How automakers are driving innovation http://www.autoalliance.org/index.cfm?objectid=A5CA0800-7EDD-11E3-9303000C296BA163
- Ghassemieh , E. Materials in Automotive Application, State of the Art and Prospects http://cdn.intechopen.com/pdfs-wm/13343.pdf
- Grayson , S. , Hirschler , M. Fire Performance of Plastics in Car Interiors Flame Retardants 2002 February 5-6 2002 London 197 207 Interscience Communications London, UK 2002
- Landry , S. Fire Safety Improvement of Vehicles Fire in Vehicles Sep 27-28 2012 Chicago, USA
- Brushlinsky , N. , Hall , J. , Sokolov , S. , and Wagner , P. Report No. 10 World Fire Statistics 2005 Centre of Fire Statistics of CTIF
- Ahrens , M. Automobile Fires in the US: 2006-2010 Estimates 2 nd International Conference on Fires in Vehicles September 27-28 2012 Chicago, USA
- Guide for identification and development of Mitigation strategies for fire hazard to occupants of passenger road vehicles National Fire Protection Association Quincy, MA 2005
- Highway Vehicle Fires Topical Fire Research Series 2(4) U.S. Fire Administration July 2001
- Tewarson , A. , Quintiere , J. , and Purser , J. Post Collision Motor Vehicle Fires FM Global Technical Report #0003018009 I October 2005 www.mvfri.org
- Tewarson , A. , Quintiere , J. , and Purser , J. Theory and Testing for the Fire Behavior of Materials for the Transportation Industry FM Global Technical Report #0003018009 II October 2005 www.mvfri.org
- Tewarson , A. , Quintiere , J. , and Purser , J. Thermophysical and Fire Properties of Automobile Plastic Parts and Engine Compartment Fluids FM Global Technical Report #0003018009 III October 2005 www.mvfri.org
- U.S.F.A. Highway Vehicle Fires Topical Fire Research Series 2 4 U.S. Fire Administration March 2002
- Figures approximated from average weight of large vehicles from GFEI's International Comparison of light-duty vehicles 2010 www.globalfueleconomy.org
- Weill , D. , Klink , G. , Besland , L. , Roiultoux , G. , Kearney A.T. Plastics. The future for automakers and chemical companies http://www.atkearney.com
- 49 CFR Part 571 FMVSS 302 Flammability of Interior Materials
- Goldsmith , A. Flammability Characteristics of Vehicle Interior Materials Final Technical Report, J6152 1969 Illinois Institute of Technology Research Institute Chicago
- Troitzsch , J. Flammability and Fire Behaviour of TV sets”., Fire Safety Science Proceedings of the 6 th International Symposium 979 990
- Babrauskas , V. , and Peacock , R. Heat release rate: the single most important variable in fire hazard Fire Safety J. 18 255 72 1992
- Babrauskas , V. , Harris , R. , Gann , R. , Levin , B. , Lee , B. , Peacock , R. , Paabu , M. , Twilley , W. , Yoklavich , M. , and Clark , H. Fire Hazard Comparison of fire-retarded and non-fire-retarded products NBS Special Publication 749 National Bureau of Standards Gaithersburg, MD 1988
- Babrauskas , V. , and Grayson , S. Heat Release in Fires Elsevier London, UK 1992
- Hirschler , M. Heat release from plastic materials Hirschler M. Heat Release in Fires Elsevier London, UK Babrauskas , V and Grayson , V. 1992 375 422
- Babrauskas , V. The Effects of FR Agents on Polymer Performance Heat Release in Fires Elsevier London, UK Babrauskas V. and Grayson S.J. 1992 423 446
- Hirschler , M. Use of Heat Release Rate to Predict Whether Individual Furnishings Would Cause Self Propagating Fires Fire Safety Journal 32 273 296 1999
- Janssens , M. Measurements Needs for Fire Safety: Proceedings of an International Workshop Ohlemiller , T. , Johnsson , E. , and Gann , R. NISTIR 6527 Gaithersburg, MD 2000
- Hirschler , M. Heat Release Testing of Consumer Products Journal ASTM International (JAI) 6 5 10.1520/JAI102258 May 2009 ASTM International West Conshohocken, PA