This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Field Relevance of NHTSA's Oblique Research Moving Deformable Barrier Tests
Published November 10, 2014 by The Stapp Association in United States
This content contains downloadable datasetsAnnotation ability available
A small overlap frontal crash test has been recently introduced by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety in its frontal rating scheme. Another small overlap frontal crash test is under development by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). Whereas the IIHS test is conducted against a fixed rigid barrier, the NHTSA test is conducted with a moving deformable barrier that overlaps 35% of the vehicle being tested and the angle between the longitudinal axis of the barrier and the longitudinal axis of the test vehicle is 15 degrees. The field relevance of the IIHS test has been the subject of a paper by Prasad et al. (2014). The current study is aimed at examining the field relevance of the NHTSA test. The field relevance is indicated by the frequency of occurrence of real world crashes that are simulated by the test conditions, the proportion of serious-to-fatal real world injuries explained by the test condition, and rates of serious injury to the head, chest and other body regions in the real world crashes resembling the test condition. The database examined for real world crashes is NASS. Results of the study indicate that 1.4% of all frontal 11-to-1 o'clock crashes are simulated by the test conditions that account for 2.4% to 4.5% of all frontal serious-to-fatal (MAIS3+F) injuries. Injury rates of the head and the chest are substantially lower in far-side than in near-side frontal impacts. Crash test ATD rotational responses of the head in the tests over-predict the real world risk of serious-to-fatal brain injuries.
CitationPrasad, P., Dalmotas, D., and German, A., "The Field Relevance of NHTSA's Oblique Research Moving Deformable Barrier Tests," SAE Technical Paper 2014-22-0007, 2014, https://doi.org/10.4271/2014-22-0007.
Data Sets - Support Documents
|[Unnamed Dataset 1]|
- Bean, J., Kahane, C. K., Mynatt, M., Rudd, R. W., Rush, C. J. and Wiacek, C. (2009), Fatalities in Frontal Crashes Despite Seat Belts and Air Bags-Review of All CDS Cases- Model and Calendar Years 2000-2007 - 122 Fatalities. Report No. DOT HS 811 102. US DOT, Sept. 2009.
- Lindquist, M., Hall, A., and Björnstig, U. (2003), Real world car crash investigations - A new approach. IJCrash. (4) 375-384. 2003.
- Lindquist, M., Hall, A. and Bjornstig (2004), Car Structural Characteristics of fatal frontal crashes in Sweden, IJCrash, 2004 Vol 9.
- Morgan, R. M., Cui, C., Marzougi, D., Digges, K. H., Cao, L. and Kan, C-D (2012), Frontal Pole Impacts, Proc. IRCOBI Confc., 2012.
- Morgan, R. M., Cui, C., Digges, K. H., Cao, L. and Kan, C-D. (2012), Impact and Injury Patterns in Between-Rails Frontal Crashes of Vehicles with Good Ratings for Frontal Crash Protection, Proc. 56th AAAM Conference, 2012.
- Prasad, P., Dalmotas, D., and German, A. (2014), An Examination of Crash and NASS Data to evaluate the Field Relevance of IIHS Small Offset Tests, SAE 2014-01-1989, SAE International Journal of Transportation Safety, July 2014.
- Rudd, R. W., Scarboro, M., Saunders, J. (2011), Injury Analysis of Real-World Small Overlap and Oblique Frontal Crashes, Proc. ESV Conference, 2011.
- Rudd, R. W., Bean, J., Cuentas, C., Kahane, C. J., Mynatt, M. and Wiacek, C. (2009), A Study of the Factors Affecting Fatalities of Airbag and Belt Restrained Occupants in Frontal Crashes, Proc. ESV Conference, 2009.
- Samaha, R, R., Prasad, P., and Nix, L. (2013), Opportunities for Injury Reduction in US Frontal Crashes: An Overview by Structural Engagement, Vehicle Class, and Occupant Age, Stapp Car Crash Journal, Vol. 57, 2013.
- Saunders, J. and Parent, D. (2014), Update on NHTSA's Oblique Research Program, SAE 2014 Government Industry Meeting, NHTSA Website, Public Meeting, http://www.nhtsa.gov/Research/Public+Meetings/SAE+2014+Government+Industry+Meeting.
- Saunders, J., Craig, M. J. and Suway, J. (2011), NHTSA's Test Procedure Evaluations for Small Overlap/Oblique Crashes, Proc. ESV Conference, 2011.
- Saunders, J., Craig, M. and Parent, D. (2012), Moving Deformable Barrier Test Procedure for Evaluating Small Overlap/Oblique Crashes, SAE World Congress, Paper No. 2012-01-0577, 2012.
- Saunders, J. and Parent, D. (2013), Repeatability of a Small Overlap and an Oblique Moving Barrier Test Procedure, SAE World Congress, Paper No. 2013-01-0762, 2013.
- Saunders, J. and Parent, D. (2013), Assessment of an Oblique Moving Deformable Barrier Test Procedure, Paper No.: 13-0402, 23rd ESV Conference, Seoul, Korea, 2013.
- Scullion, P., Morgan, R. M., Mohan, P., Kan, C-D, Shanks, K., Jin, W. and Tangirala, R. (2010), A Reexamination of the Small Overlap Frontal Crash, Proc. 54th AAAM, 2010.
- Scullion, P., Morgan, R. M., Digges, K. H. and Kan, C-D (2011), Frontal Crashes Between the Logitudinal Rails, Proc. ESV Conference, 2011.
- Sullivan, K., Henry, S. and Laituri, T. R. (2008), A Frontal Impact Taxonomy for USA Field Data, SAE 2008-01-0526.
- Viano, D.C. and Parenteau, C.S. (2010), Injury Risks in Frontal Crashes by Delta V and Body region With Focus on Head Injuries in Low-Speed Collisions, Traffic Injury Prevention, 11:382-390, 2010.