This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Hydrogen Fuel Cell Transit Bus Technology into a Technical-Economical Perspective
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published October 07, 2013 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Intensive use of fossil fuels in densely populated areas has caused adverse environmental effects in cities all over the world. This has fostered the evaluation of alternative technologies for transit applications, like hydrogen fuel cells - electrochemical energy conversion devices that operate with zero emission, quieter and with higher efficiencies than internal combustion engines, specially at part load regimes. Transit bus market is particularly well suited to technology innovations because they are i) centrally fueled and maintained, ii) professionally operated on fixed routes and schedules, iii) tolerate weight and volume requirement of new technologies and, finally, whenever necessary, iv) can be subsidized by government. In this scenario, considerable research, development and testing effort has been dedicated to hydrogen fuel cell bus technology, with the engagement of governments and transit authorities, bus industry and operators. Early non hybrid fuel cell transit bus designs were focused in reliability rather than fuel economy, with efficiency penalties and reduced fuel cell lifetime, due to the impossibility of regeneration of kinetic energy and dynamic requirement on the power plant. Moreover, this design required larger fuel cells to supply all the power requirements of the vehicles, with direct effects into life cycle costs. In the light of these problems, fuel cell bus designs have evolved to hybridized concept, with fuel cell operating associated with energy storage devices/buffers (batteries, supercapacitors or both), with the possibility of recovery of part of kinetic energy and, hence, improvement of efficiency and fuel cell lifetime. Some state of art hybrid fuel cell drivetrains use a low power fuel cell working in steady state condition, recharging traction batteries, also recharged by the grid, in the so called plug-in configuration. This enables smaller fuel cells, working in a controlled regime, which means lower capital expenditures, higher efficiency and, hence, lower lifetime costs. However, when compared to non hybridized architecture, hybrid systems still present low availability, related to problems in power electronics and energy storage systems, as opposed to the fuel cell itself. Fortunately, ongoing industry effort to optimization of hybrid diesel electric concept, which uses the same electric hybrid architecture, will help to address this hurdle. To reach commercialization of Fuel Cell Transit Buses, few barriers need to be surpassed, with the optimization of i) fuel cell durability, ii) initial purchase cost, and iii) hydrogen production and delivery technology. On a Total Cost of Ownership - TCO perspective, current fuel cell buses are three to four times more costly than modern diesel buses. This additional cost is not acceptable to bus operators, unless with heavy public subsidies. This means that much has to be done in terms of technological improvement and increased volume production scale, to achieve, in the medium term, a reasonable TCO that would make fuel cell buses competitive with well established technologies on environmentally sensitive areas. This work is supposed to present an analysis of technical and economical features and performance of fuel cell bus technology, with a survey of the main barriers that need to be surpassed, and an overview of some ongoing fuel cell bus projects.
CitationBarbosa, F., "Hydrogen Fuel Cell Transit Bus Technology into a Technical-Economical Perspective," SAE Technical Paper 2013-36-0270, 2013, https://doi.org/10.4271/2013-36-0270.
- CUTE - Clean Urban Transport for Europe - A Hydrogen Fuel Cell Bus Project in Europe 2001 - 2006 Report. Detailed Summary of Achievments, 2006;
- BARBOSA F.C - Fuel Cell Transit Bus - A Step Forward (An Overview of the Main Recent World Experiences). SAE Paper 2008-36-0148;
- HU. H., SMALING R. and BASELEY S. - Advanced Hybrid Powertrains for Commercial Vehicles, SAE International, Warrendale, PA, USA, 2012;
- LARMINIE J. and DICKS A. - Fuel Cells Systems Explained. John Wiley & Sons. ISBN - 13: 978-0-470-84857-9 (H/B), West Sussex, England, 2003;
- BORUP R. et al - Scientific Aspects of Polymer Electrolyte Fuel Cell Durability and Degradation. Chemical Reviews, Vol. 107, No. 10 3905, 2007;
- MME/EMTU. Ônibus Brasileiro a Hidrogênio. Tecnologias Renováveis para o Transporte Urbano no Brasil. Brasil, 2010;
- KNIGHTS s. et al - Next Generation Heavy Duty Bus Fuel Cells: An Industry-Academic Collaboration. Abstract n°. 306. Canada, 2012;
- FOLKESSON A. - Towards Sustainable Urban Transportation. Test, Demonstration and Development of Fuel Cell and Hybrid-Electric Buses. KTH - Royal Institute of Technology. Stockholm, Sweden, 2008;
- EMADI, A. et al - Power Electronics Intensive Solutions for Advanced Electric, Hybrid Electric and Fuel Cell Vehicular Power Systems - Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago IL, 2006. Available at http://xplqa30.ieee.org/xpl/login.jsp?tp=&arnumber=1628996&url=http%3A%2F%2Fxplqa30.ieee.org%2Fxpls%2Ficp.jsp%3Farnumber%3D1628996. Accessed on 07 12 2013;
- FOLKESSON A. et al - Real life testing of a Hybrid PEM Fuel Cell Bus. Royal Institute of Technology - Stockholm, Sweden, 2003;
- TCRP 132 Report - Assessment of Hybrid-Electric Transit Bus Technology, Transportation Research Board, Washington, 2009;
- FTA-TRI-MA-26-7125-2011.1 - Assesment of Needs and Research Roadmaps for Rechargeable Energy Storage System Onboard Electric Drive Buses. DOT/FTA, 2010;
- ELECTROPAEDIA - Battery and Energy Technologies. Available on http://www.mpoweruk.com/performance.htm. Accessed on 04 04 2013;
- CLEPS CEA - The Hydrogen Pathway. On Board Storage of Hydrogen, 2005. (Available at http://www.cea.fr/var/cea/storage/static/gb/library/Clefs50/pdf/056a060moysan-gb.pdf. Accessed on 04 21 2013);
- CARNEVALI C., GENOVA R., JENNÉ P., MAZZUCHELLI M, REIJALT M., PRIANO G. - Fuel cell electric buses and perspectives: High V.LO-City Project, 2012
- INTERNATIONAL FUELCELLBUS COLLABORATIVE Website. http://gofuelcellbus.com/index.php/commercialization/challenges/. Accessed on 04 24 2013;
- ZAETTA R., et al - Hydrogen Fuel Cell Bus Technology State of the Art Review - NEXTHYLIGHTS. European Commission. FCH-JU-2008-1 Grant Agreement Number 245133.
- VAN HOOL - Van Hool Fuel Cell Bus Brochure. 2010;
- HBA - Strategy for 2010-2015 Alliance Activities on Hydrogen Fuelled Public Transit Buses. Hydrogen Bus Alliance Report, 2008;
- CAFCP - A Roadmap for Fuel Cell Bus in California. California Fuel Cell Bus Partnership. West Sacramento, March, 2013;
- MCKINSEY & Company - A Portfolio of Power-trains for Europe: A Fact-Based Analysis. The Role of Battery Electric Vehicles, Plug-in Hybrids and Fuel Cell Electric Vehicles. Available at: http://www.europeanclimate.org/documents/Power_trains_for_Europe.pdf. Accessed on 04 20 2013;”
- NREL - Fuel Cell Buses in U.S. Transit Fleets: Current Status 2012. Technical Report NREL/TP-5600-56406, November 2012.
- EUDY L.-Technology Validation: Fuel Cell Bus Evaluations. 2012 DOE Annual Merit Review. May, 2012;
- BARBOSA, F.C. - Sustainable Transit Bus Technologies - A Focus on Traction Technologies. Paper SAE n°. 2011-36-0011;
- NEVES Jr., N.P and Pinto - Licensing a Fuel Cell Bus and a Hydrogen Fueling Station in Brazil. UNICAMP;
- REGINA I. - Brazilian Fuel Cell Bus Project PNUD BRA/99/G32. Presentation on 7th International Fuel Cell Bus Workshop. San Francisco, United States, 2011;”
- EMTU - EMTU/SP recebe técnicos internacionais para apresentar o ônibus movido a Hidrogênio e demais programas ambientais. Available at: http://www.emtu.sp.gov.br/emtu/imprensa/noticias/geral/emtu-sp-recebe-tecnicos-internacionais-para-apresentar-o-onibus-movido-a-hidrogenio-e-demais-program.fss. Accessd on 05 24 2013;
- MIRANDA P.E.V. and CARREIRA E.S - Brazilian Hybrid Electric Fuel Cell Bus. 18th World Hydrogen Conference 2010 - WHEC 2010. Essen, 2010;
- COPPE - Laboratório de Hidrogênio. Available at: http://www.onibush2.coppe.ufrj.br/index.php/extensions?start=6. Accessed on 04 24 2013;