This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Observations on Pedestrian Pre-Crash Reactions during Simulated Accidents
Published November 11, 2013 by The Stapp Association in United States
Annotation ability available
Pedestrian protection systems, both active and passive systems, are being introduced in the EU and Japan to comply with regulatory requirements. Their designs are specific and, in general, reflect an accident scenario of the pedestrian being struck on the side by a vehicle traveling at a maximum travel speed of 40 kph. The present study is an effort to quantify the effects of pedestrian reaction prior to an accident and identify characteristics that may help minimize or prevent the pedestrian to vehicle interaction. Accident situations were simulated with volunteers using a non-impacting methodology. Fifty one reactions from 23 volunteers of two age groups were observed. Most of the volunteers were found to run, step-back or stop in fright in a dangerous situation. Volunteer speed was an important parameter which could help in differentiating these reactions. Age related differences were also observed, both for reaction strategy and reaction times. While the majority of young subjects ran, elderly stopped as often as they run. Volunteers' posture at the time of impact was found to be highly variable irrespective of the type of reactions. The exception was when a volunteer stopped/braced in apparent fright and raised their arms to form a triangle covering their face and their head. Results of the present study may be helpful when selecting or evaluating the benefit of pedestrian safety strategies by allowing the inclusion of information about types of reaction, pedestrian speed, reaction time and age differences in the scenarios. In addition, pedestrian pre-crash postures and muscle activities could be utilized for evaluating/improving the passive safety systems and active models.
CitationSoni, A., Robert, T., Rongiéras, F., and Beillas, P., "Observations on Pedestrian Pre-Crash Reactions during Simulated Accidents," SAE Technical Paper 2013-22-0006, 2013, https://doi.org/10.4271/2013-22-0006.
- APROSYS SP3 (2006); Stiffness corridors for the current European fleet, Project APROSYS, Deliverable Report - D312B.
- CARE database (2009), Road fatalities by Country. http://ec.europa.eu/transport/road_safety/specialist/statistics/ (Accessed 2012-03-10).
- Carthy, T., Packham, D., Salter, D., and Silcock, D. (1995), Risk and safety on the roads: the older pedestrian, Report prepared for the AA Foundation for Road Safety Research, University of Newcastle upon Tyne. http://roadsafetyfoundation.org/media/14097/risk_and_safety_on_the_roads_-_the_older_pedestrian.pdf. (Accessed 2012-08-15).
- Cavallo, V., Lobjois, R.7 and Vienne, F., (2006) The interest of an interactive road crossing simulation for the study of adaptive road crossing behaviour. Proc. 1st Driving Simulation Conference Asia-Pacific. Tsukuba, Japan.
- Chawla, A., Mukherjee, S., Soni, A., and Malhotra R., (2007) Effect of active muscle forces on knee injury risks for pedestrian standing posture at low speed impacts. Traffic Injury Prevention, 9 (6):544-551.
- Ebner, A., Samaha, RR., Scullion, P., Helmer, T. (2010) Methodology for the development and evaluation of active safety systems using reference scenarios: Application to preventive pedestrian safety. Proc. IRCOBI, 38:155-168.
- Habibovic, A., and Davidsson, J., (2011) Requirements of a system to reduce car-to-vulnerable road user crashes in urban interactions. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 43:1570-1580.
- Hochheim, W., H., (2002), Close quarter combat Magazine, Lauric Enterprises, Inc. USA
- Gandhi, T., and Trivedi, M. (2007) Pedestrian protection systems: Issues, survey, and challenges. IEEE Trans. on ITS, 8(3):413-430.
- Gavrila, D.M., Marchal, P., and Meinecke, M.-M., (2003) Vulnerable Road User Scenario Analysis. Project SAVE-U, Deliverable Report 1-A.
- Kausler D., (1991), Experimental Psychologiy, Cognition, and Human Aging, Second Edition. Springer-Verlag Inc. New York.
- Lubbe, N., Edwards, M., Wisch, M., (2012) Towards an Integrated Pedestrian Safety Assessment Method. Proc. IRCOBI conference, IRC-12-81, pp. 761-765.
- McCarthy, M.G, Moxey, E., Johnson, N., and McLundie, W., (2004) The Advanced Protection of Vulnerable Road Users (APRVU). Final Report. PR/SE/970/04. TRL Limited, Crowthorne, UK.
- Meulen, P. V. D., and Seidl, A., (2007) Ramsis - The leading CAD tool for ergonomic analysis of vehicles. Digital Human Modeling, Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg, pp: 1008-1017.
- Mohan, D., (2003), Safety as a human right, Health and Human Rights, Vol. 6(2), pp. 161-167.
- Nantulya, V., and Reich, M., (2002), The neglected epidemic: road traffic injuries in developing countries, BMJ; Vol. 324, pp. 1139-41. Organisation for Economic Co-operation Development (OECD), (2001), Aging and Transport. Mobility Needs and Safety Issues. OECD Publications, Paris.
- Niewöhner, W., Roth, F., Gwehenberger, J., Gruber, C., Kuehn, M., Sferco, R., Pastor, C.H., Nagel, U., Stanzel, M., (2011) Proposal for a Test Procedure of Assistance Systems regarding Preventive Pedestrian Protection. Proc. 22nd ESV conference, Paper no 11-0393.
- Overstall, P., Exton-smith, A., Imms, F., and Johnston, A., (1977) Falls in the elderly related to postural imbalance. British Medical Journal, 1:261-269.
- Rosén, E. and Fredriksson, R., (2012) Integrated pedestrian countermeasures-Potential of head injury reduction combining passive and active countermeasures. Safety Science, 50 (3). pp. 400-407.
- Schramm, S., and Roth, F., (2009) Method to asses the effectiveness of active pedestrian protection safety systems. Proc. ESV conference, Paper No. 09-0398.
- Sharples, S., Cobb, S., Moody, A., Wilson, J.R., (2008) Virtual reality induced symptoms and effects (VRISE): Comparison of head mounted display (HMD), desktop and projection display systems. Displays. 29:58-69.
- Soni, A., Robert, T., and Beillas, P., (2013) Effects of pedestrian pre-crash reactions on crash outcomes during multi-body simulations. Proc. IRCOBI conference, IRC-13-65, pp. 762-776.
- Sparrow, W.A., Bradshaw, E.J., Lamoureux, E., and Tirosh, O., (2002) Ageing effects on the attention demands of walking. Human Movement Science, 21:961-972.
- Verillo, T. T., and Verillo, V., (1985), Sensory and perceptual performance. In Charness N. [Ed.], Aging and Human Performance. Pp.1-46, John Wiley & Sons.
- Wang, X., Chevalot, N., Monnier, G., Ausejo, S., Suescun, A., Celigüa, J., (2005) Validation of a model-based motion reconstruction method developed in the REALMAN project. SAE Technical Paper 2005-01-2743
- Winter, D.A., (1990) Biomechanics and motor control of human movement. (2nd ed.) John Wiley & Sons, New York
- Yuasa, H., Nakanishi, M., Mochida, T., Yamada, N., and Nakai, M., (2013) Research in evaluation method for pedestrian pre-collision system. Proc. ESV conference, Paper No. 13-0110-O