This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Development of a Human Body Finite Element Model with Multiple Muscles and their Controller for Estimating Occupant Motions and Impact Responses in Frontal Crash Situations
Technical Paper
2012-22-0006
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
A few reports suggest differences in injury outcomes between cadaver tests and real-world accidents under almost similar conditions. This study hypothesized that muscle activity could primarily cause the differences, and then developed a human body finite element (FE) model with individual muscles. Each muscle was modeled as a hybrid model of bar elements with active properties and solid elements with passive properties. The model without muscle activation was firstly validated against five series of cadaver test data on impact responses in the anterior-posterior direction. The model with muscle activation levels estimated based on electromyography (EMG) data was secondly validated against four series of volunteer test data on bracing effects for stiffness and thickness of an upper arm muscle, and braced driver's responses under a static environment and a brake deceleration. A muscle controller using reinforcement learning (RL), which is a mathematical model of learning process in the basal ganglia associated with human postural controls, were newly proposed to estimate muscle activity in various occupant conditions including inattentive and attentive conditions. Control of individual muscles predicted by RL reproduced more human like head-neck motions than conventional control of two groups of agonist and antagonist muscles. The model and the controller demonstrated that head-neck motions of an occupant under an impact deceleration of frontal crash were different in between a bracing condition with maximal braking force and an occupant condition predicted by RL. The model and the controller have the potential to investigate muscular effects in various occupant conditions during frontal crashes.
Authors
Citation
Iwamoto, M., Nakahira, Y., Kimpara, H., Sugiyama, T. et al., "Development of a Human Body Finite Element Model with Multiple Muscles and their Controller for Estimating Occupant Motions and Impact Responses in Frontal Crash Situations," SAE Technical Paper 2012-22-0006, 2012, https://doi.org/10.4271/2012-22-0006.Also In
References
- Accident Analysis Report (JAPAN) Institute for Traffic Accident Research and Data Analysis (ITARDA) 2005
- Agur , A.M.R. , Dalley , A.F. II 2005 Grant's Atlas of Anatomy 11 th Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Baltimore, Maryland
- Andrey , H.-D. , Frederic , R. , Pascal , D. , Herve , M. 2009 Pre-Crash Phase Analysis using a Driving Simulator Influence of Atypical Position on Injuries and Airbag Adaptation, Proc. of 21th ESV Conference, No.09-0534
- Azar , N.R. , Kallakuri , S. , Chen , C. , Cavanaugh , J.M. 2011 Muscular Response to Physiologic Tensile Stretch of the Caprine C5/6 Facet Joint Capsule: Dynamic Recruitment Thresholds and Latencies Stapp Car Crash Journal 55 441 460
- Begeman , P. , King , A.I. , Levine , R. , Viano , D.C. 1980 Biodynamic Response of the Musculoskeletal System to Impact Acceleration Stapp Car Crash Conference, No.801312 479 509
- Behr , M. , Arnoux , P-J. , Serre , T. , Thollon , L. , Brunet , C. 2006 Tonic Finite Element Model of the Lower Limb Journal of Biomechanical Engineering 128 223 228
- Bowman , B.M. , Schneider , L.W. , Foust , D.R. 1975 Simulated Occupant Response to Side-Impact Collisions Proc.of the 19 th Stapp Car Crash Conference, No.751155 429 454
- Bowman , B.M. , Schneider , L.W. , Lustick , L.S. , Anderson , W.R. , Thomas , D.J. 1984 Simulation Analysis of Head and Neck Dynamic Response Proc. of the Stapp Car Crash Conference, No.841668 173 205
- Carlson , G.D. , Botte , K.J. , Josephs , M.S. , Newton , P.O. , Davis , J.L.W. , Woo , S.L-Y. 1993 Morphologic and biomechanical comparison of tendons used as free grafts Journal of hand surgery 18A 1 76 82
- Chang , C-Y. , Rupp , J. , Kikuchi , N. , Schneider , L. 2008 Development of a Finite Element Model to Study the Effects of Muscle Forces on Knee-Thigh-Hip Injuries in Frontal Crashes Stapp Car Crash Journal 52 475 504
- Chang , C-Y , Rupp , J.D. , Reed , M.P. , Hughes , R.E. , Schneider , L.W. 2009 Effects of Muscle Activation on Knee, Thigh, and Hip Injuries in Frontal Crashes Predicted Using a Finite Element Model with Muscle Forces from Subject Testing and Musculoskeletal Modeling Stapp Car Crash Journal 53
- Choi , H.Y. , Sah , S.J. , Lee , B. , Cho , H.S. , Kang , S.J. , Mun , M.S. , Lee , I. , Lee , J. 2005 Experimental and numerical studies of muscular activations of bracing occupant Proc. of 19 th ESV Conference, Paper No.05-0139-O
- Dhaliwal , T.S. , Beillas , P. , Chou , C.C. , Prasad , P. , Yang , K.H. , King , A.I. 2002 Structural Response of Lower Leg Muscles in Comparison: A Low Impact Energy Study Employing Volunteers, and Cadavers and the Hybrid III Stapp Car Crash Journal 46 229 243
- Doya , K. 2000 Reinforcement Learning in Continuous Time and Space Neural Computation 12 1 219 245
- Du Bois , P.A. 2003 A simplified approach to the simulation of rubber-like materials under dynamic loading Proc. 4 th European LS-DYNA Users Conference, D-1 31 45
- Ejima , S. , Zama , Y. , Ono , K. , Kaneoka , K. , Shiina , I. , Asada , H. 2009 Prediction of Pre-impact Occupant Kinematic Behavior Based on the Muscle Activity during Frontal Collision Proc. of 21 st ESV Conference, No. 09-0913
- Ewing , C.L. , Thomas , D.J. 1973 Torque versus Angular Displacement Response of Human Head to -Gx Impact Acceleration Proc. of 17 th Stapp Car Crash Conference, No.730976 309 342
- Funk , J.R. , Crandall , J.R. , Tourret , L.J. , MacMahon , C.B. , Bass , C.R. , Khaewpong , N.K. , Rppinger , R.H. 2001 The effect of active muscle tension on the axial injury tolerance of the human foot/ankle compex Proc. of the 17 th ESV Conference, No. 237
- Gans , C. 1982 Fiber architecture and muscle function Exercise and Sports Sciences Reviws 10 106 107
- Hardy , W.N. , Schneider , L.W. , Rouhana , S.W. 2001 Abdominal Impact Response to Rigid-Bar, Seatbelt, and Airbag Loading Stapp Car Crash Journal 45 1 31 2001-22-0001
- Hedenstierna , S. , Halldin , P. , Brolin , K. 2007 Development and Evaluation of a Continuum Neck Muscle Model Proc. of 6th European LS-DYNA User's Conference, Session 2 80 99
- Hedenstierna , S. , Halldin , P. , Brolin , K. 2008 Evaluation of a combination of continuum and truss finite elements in a model of passive and active muscle tissue Computer Methods in Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering 11 6 Dec. 627 639
- Hill , A.V. 1938 The head of shortening and the dynamic constants of muscle Proc. Roy. Soc. B 126 136 195
- Itazaki , R. 2011 Government Status Report of Japan Proc. of the 22 nd ESV Conference, No.11-0459-G
- Iwamoto , M. , Kisanuki , Y. , Watanabe , I. , Furusu , K. , Miki , K. , Hasegawa , J. 2002 Development of a Finite Element Model of the Total Human Model for Safety (THUMS) and Application to Injury Reconstruction Proc. of IRCOBI Conference 31 42
- Iwamoto , M. , Nakahira , Y. , Kimpara , H. Sugiyama , T. 2009 Development of a Human FE Model with 3-D Geometry of Muscles and Lateral Impact Analysis for the Arm with Muscle Activity SAE paper, No. 2009-01-2266
- Iwamoto , M. , Nakahira , Y. , Sugiyama , T. 2011 Investigation of pre-impact bracing effects for injury outcome using an active human FE model with 3D geometry of muscles Proc. of the 22 nd ESV Conference, No.11-0150
- Iwamoto , M. , Min , K. , Kimpara , H. 2012 Prediction of Head-neck Motions during Rear-end Impacts Using a Human Body FE Model with Muscle Activity Transaction of Society of Automotive Engineers of Japan 43 5
- Kallieris , D. , Otte , D. , Mattern , R. , Wiedmann , P. 1995 Comparison of Sled Tests with Real Traffic Accidents Proc. of the 39 th Stapp Car Crash Conference, No.952707 51 58
- Kent , R. , Bass , C. D. , Woods , W. , Salzar , R. , Melvin , J. 2004a The Role of Muscle Tensing on the Force-Deflection Response of the Thorax and a Reassessment of Frontal Impact Thoracic Biofidelity Corridors Proc. of IRCOBI Conference 95 107
- Kent , R. , Lessley , D. , Sherwood , C. 2004b Thoracic Response to Dynamic, Non-Impact Loading from a Hub, Distributed Belt, Diagonal Belt, Double Diagonal Belts Stapp Car Crash Journal 48 495 519
- Levine , R.S. , Patrick , L.M. , Begeman , P.C. , King , A.I. 1978 Effect of quadriceps function on submarining Proc. of the 22th Conference of Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine (AAAM) 319 329
- Manning , P. , Wallace , W.A. , Roberts , A.K. , Owen , C.J. , Lowne , R.W. 1997 The Position and Movement of the Foot in Emergency Manoeuvres and the Influence of Tension in the Achilles Tendon Proc. of the 41 st Stapp Car Crash Conference 195 206
- Min , K. , Kimpara , H. , Iwamoto , M. 2012 Load Response Simulation of Human Arm Musculo-Skeletal FE Model with the Learning of Muscle Synergy Control Policy Neural Networks 2012
- Nemirovsky , N. , Rooij , L.v. 2010 A New Methodology for Biofidelic Head-Neck Postural Control Proc. of IRCOBI Conference 71 84
- Neumann , D.A. 2002 Kinesiology of the Musculoskeletal System: Fundations for Physical Rehabilitation Mosby Inc.
- Ono , K. , Kaneoka , K. , Wittek , A. , Kajzer , J. 1997 Cervical Injury Mechanism Based on the Analysis of Human Cervical Vertebral Motion and Head- Neck-Torso Kinematics during Low Speed Rear Impacts Proc. of the 41st Stapp Car Crash Conference, 973340 339 356
- Owen , C. , Roberts , A. , Manning , P. , Lowne , R. 1998 Positioning and bracing of the lower leg during emergency braking - A volunteer study Proc. of IRCOBI Conference 147 159
- Palmertz C. , Jakobsson , L. , Karlsson A.-S. 1998 Pedal Use and Foot Positioning during Emergency Braking Proc. of IRCOBI Conference 135 146
- Panjabi , M.M. , Brand , R.A. , White , A.A. 1976 Mechanical Properties of the Human Thoracic Spine The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery 642 652
- Pioletti , D.P. , Rakotomanana , L.R. , Benvenuti , J.-F. , Leyvraz , P.-F. 1998 Viscoelastic constitutive law in large deformations: application to human knee ligaments and tendon Journal of Biomechanics 31 753 757
- Ruan , J.S. , El-Jawahri , R. , Barbat , S. , Prasad , P. 2005 Biomechanical Analysis of Human Abdominal Impact Responses and Injuries through Finite Element Simulations of a Full Human Body Model Stapp Car Crash Journal 49 343 366
- Rooij , L.v. 2011 Effect of Various Pre-crash Braking Strategies on Simulated Human Kinematic Response with Varying Levels of Driver Attention Proc. of the 22 nd ESV Conference, Paper No. 11-0306
- Rupp , J.D. , Miller , C.S. , Reed , M.P. , Madura , N.H. , Klinich , K.D. 2008 Characterization of Knee-Thigh-Hip Response in Frontal Impacts Using Biomechanical Testing and Computational Simulations Stapp Car Crash Journal 52 421 474 2008-22-0017
- Shigeta , K. , Kitagawa , Y. Yasuki , T. 2009 Development of Next Generation Human Body FE Model Capable of Organ Injury Prediction Proc. of the 21 st ESV Conference, Paper No. 09-0111-O
- Stalnaker , R.L. , McElhaney , J.H. , Roberts , V.L. , Trollope , M.L. 1973 Human Torso Response to Blunt Trauma, Human Impact Response, Measurement and Simulation 181 199 PLENUM PRESS New York-London
- Sugiyama , T. Kimpara , H. , Iwamoto , M. , Yamada , D. , Nakahira , Y. , Hada , M. 2007 Effects of muscle tense on impact responses of lower extremity Proc. of IRCOBI Conference 127 140
- Takakusaki , K. , Habaguchi , T. , Ohtinata-Sugimoto , J. , Saitoh , K. , Sakamoto , T. 2003 Basal Ganglia Efferents to the Brainstem Centers Controlling Postural Muscle Tone and Locomotion: A New Concept for Understanding Motor Disorders in Basal Ganglia Dysfunction Neuroscience 119 293 308
- Takakusaki , K. , Saitoh , K. , Harada , H. , Kashiwayanagi , M. 2004 Role of Basal Ganglia-Brainstem Pathways in the Control of Motor Behaviors Neuroscience Research 50 137 151
- Tennyson , S.A. , King , A.I. 1976 A Biodynamic Model of the Human Spinal Column SAE Paper No. 760771
- Thelen , D. G. 2003 Adjustment of Muscle Mechanics Model Parameters to Simulate Dynamic Contractions in Older Adults Transaction of the ASME 125
- Vezin , P. , Bruyère , K. , Bermond , F. 2001 Comparison of Head and Thorax Cadaver and Hybrid III Responses to a Frontal Sled Deceleration for the Validation of a Car Occupant Mathematical Model Proc. of the 17 th ESV Conference, No.114
- Vezin , P. , Verriest , J.P. 2005 Development of a Set of Numerical Human Models for Safety Proc. of the 19 th ESV Conference, Paper No. 05-0163
- White , N.A. Begeman , P.C. , Hardy , W.N. , Yang , K.H. , Ono , K. , Sato , F. , Kamiji , K. , Yasuki , T. , Bey , M.J. 2009 Investigation of Upper Body and Cervical Spine Kinematics of Post Mortem Human Subjects (PMHS) during Low-Speed, Rear-End Impacts SAE 2009-01-0387
- Winters , J.M. 1990 Hill-Based Muscle Models A System Engineering Perspective; Multiple Muscle Systems: Biomechanics and Movement Organization Winters , J.M. and Woo , S. New York Springer 69 93 726 749
- Wismans , J. , Philippens , M. , Oorschot , E.v. , Kallieris , D. , Mattern , R. 1987 Comparison of Human Volunteer and Cadaver Head-Neck Responses in Frontal Flexion Proc. of the 31 st Stapp Car Crash Conference, No. 872194
- Yamada , H. 1970 Strength of Biological Materials Williams & Wilkins Company