This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Kinematics Validation of Age-Specific Restrained 50 th Percentile Occupant FE Model in Frontal Impact
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 16, 2012 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Recently, the global increase of elderly vehicle users has become an issue to be considered in the effort of enhancing safety performance of vehicle restraint system. It is thought that an evaluation tool for the system representing properties of age-specific human body will play a major role for that. In previous research, the authors had developed age-specific component finite element (FE) models for the lower limb, lumbar spine, and thorax representing the adult and elderly occupants. However, the models have not been validated in terms of full body kinematics. It is essential for such models to be validated in terms of full body kinematics in order to ensure validity of the results of the assessment of the safety performance of restraint systems.
In the present research, the adult and elderly occupant full body FE models were developed by incorporating the lower limb, lumbar spine and thorax of the adult and elderly FE models established in previous research. To represent the kinematics of the shoulder of the adult occupant model, the shoulder girdle muscles were modeled and incorporated into the models. The full body kinematics of the adult occupant model were validated against published frontal sled test results using post-mortem human subjects (PMHS). The seating position of the model was determined according to the average seating position in the PMHS tests. The frontal impact sled buck model consisted of the seat, knee bolster, footrest and pelvis block. These components were modeled with shell elements and treated as rigid bodies. The occupant restraint system consisted of the shoulder and lap belts, modeled with bar and membrane elements. The trajectories were compared between the model and the average PMHS test results by using the coordinates of the head, the first and eighth thoracic vertebrae, the second and fourth lumbar vertebrae and the pelvis. A published ranking system for the biofidelity was applied to them in order to quantitatively evaluate the appropriateness of the full body kinematics of the adult occupant FE model.
Model results include peak displacements of the head, the first and eighth thoracic vertebrae in the X direction of 362 mm at 112 ms, 267mm at 121 ms and 207 mm at 115ms, respectively. The peak displacements of the corresponding body regions in the X direction from the average PMHS test results were 354 mm at 113 ms, 257 mm at 115 ms and 216 mm at 113 ms, respectively. The error was less than 5 % compared with the average PMHS test results. The kinematics of the other points selected from the head to the pelvis on the spine of the model showed agreement with the average PMHS test results as well. In addition, the results of the biofidelity rating obtained by applying the rating system also supported good agreement of most of the kinematic parameters.
For the elderly model, the kinematics and the predicted rib fracture were compared with those of the adult model. Little difference was found in the whole body kinematics, while larger deflection was found at the thorax as well as a significant increase in rib fractures, which were assumed to be caused by the lowered body stiffness and tolerance by aging.
CitationIto, Y., Dokko, Y., Motozawa, Y., Mori, F. et al., "Kinematics Validation of Age-Specific Restrained 50th Percentile Occupant FE Model in Frontal Impact," SAE Technical Paper 2012-01-0565, 2012, https://doi.org/10.4271/2012-01-0565.
- National Police Agency ‘Traffic Accident Situation’ http://www.e-stat.go.jp 2011
- Ito, O. Dokko, Y. Ohashi, K. ‘Development of the Human Lower Limb FE Models of Adult and Elderly Person Considering Aging Effects’ Proceedings, JSAE Annual Congress (Spring), #20085048 2008
- Ito, O. Dokko, Y. Ohashi, K. “Development of Adult and Elderly FE Thorax Skeletal Models,” SAE Technical Paper 2009-01-0381 2009 10.4271/2009-01-0381
- Ito, O. Dokko, Y. Ohashi, K. ‘Development of Thorax Skeletal FE Models for Adult and the Elderly’ Transactions of JSAE 40 6 1457 1462 2009
- Dokko, Y. Ito, O. Ohashi, K. “Development of Human Lower Limb and Pelvis FE Models for Adult and the Elderly,” SAE Technical Paper 2009-01-0396 2009 10.4271/2009-01-0396
- Dokko, Y. Kanayama, Y. Ito, O. Ohashi, K. “Development of Human Lumbar Spine FE Models for Adult and the Elderly,” SAE Technical Paper 2009-01-0382 2009 10.4271/2009-01-0382
- Ito, O. Ito, Y. Dokko, Y. Mori, F. Ohhashi, K. ‘Development of Adult and Elderly FE Thorax Models(Second Report)’ Transactions of JSAE 42 3 703 708 2011
- ESI Group ‘H-model™ Version 2007 User's Manual’
- ESI Group ‘PAM-CRASH™ Version 2009 Explicit Solver Reference Manual’
- Ruan, J.S. El-Jawahri, R. Chai, L. Barbat, S. Prasad, P. ‘Prediction and Analysis of Human Thoracic Impact Responses and Injuries in Cadaver Impacts Using a Full Human Body Finite Element Model’ Stapp Car Crash Journal 47 299 321 2003
- Yamada, H. ‘Strength of Biological Materials’ Lippincott Williams & Wilkins US 1970
- Kroell, C. Schneider, D. Nahum, A. “Impact Tolerance and Response of the Human Thorax,” SAE Technical Paper 710851 1971 10.4271/710851
- Kroell, C. Schneider, D. Nahum, A. “Impact Tolerance and Response of the Human Thorax II,” SAE Technical Paper 741187 1974 10.4271/741187
- Lessley, D.J. Salzar, R. Crandall, J. Kent, R. Bolton, J.R. Bass, C.R. Guillemot, H. Forma, J.L. ‘Kinematics of the Thorax under Dynamic Belt Loading Conditions’ International Journal of Crashworthiness 15 2 175 190 2010
- Shaw, G. Parent, D. Purtsezov, S. Kerrigan, J. Shin, J. Crandall, J. Zama, Y. Ejima, S. Kamiji, K. Yasuki, T. ‘Frontal Impact PMHS Sled Tests for FE Torso Model Development’ Proceedings of IRCOBI Conference 341 356 2009a
- Shaw, G. Parent, D. Purtsezov, S. Lessley, D. Crandall, J. Kent, R. Guillemot, H. Ridella, S.A. Takhounts, E. Mortin, P. ‘Impact Response of Restrained PMHS in Frontal Sled Tests: Skeletal Deformation Patterns under Seat Belt Loading’ Stapp Car Crash Journal 53 1 48 2009b
- Zama, Y. Antona, J. Mikami, K. Ejima, S. Kamiji, K. Yasuki, T. ‘Development of Finete Element Human Model for Events of Frontal Impact’ Proceedings, JSAE Annual Congress (Spring) #20105193 2010
- Rhule, H.H. Maltese, M.R. Donnelly, B.R. Eppinger, R.H. Brunner, J.K. Bolte, J.H. ‘Development of a new biofidelity ranking system for anthropomorphic test devices’ Stapp Car Crash Journal 46 477 512 2002
- Lessley, D. et al. ‘Displacement response of the spine in restrained PMHS during frontal impacts’ Proceedings, JSAE Annual Congress (Spring), #20125182 2012
- Ash, J.H. et al. ‘PMHS restraint and support surface forces in simulated frontal crashes’ Proceedings, JSAE Annual Congress (Spring), #20125221 2012