This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Exploring the Manual Forming of Complex Geometry Composite Panels for Productivity and Quality Gains in Relation to Automated Forming Capabilities
Technical Paper
2011-01-2547
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
In a variety of industries there is a growing need to manufacture high quality carbon fibre epoxy matrix composite structures at greater production rates and lower costs than has historically been the case. This has developed into a desire for the automation of the manufacture of components, and in particular the lay-up phase, with Automated Tape Laying (ATL) and Fibre Placement (AFP) the most popular choices. When used for large primary structures there are such potential gains to be had that both techniques have seen rapid implementation into manufacturing environments. But significant concerns remain and these have limited their wider adoption into secondary structure manufacturing, where manual forming of woven broadgoods is dominant. As a result the manufacture of secondary structures is generally explored for costs reduction through drape simulation and lower cost materials. Improvements in lay-up quality and yield are possible, but the effect of this approach on productivity and build costs has perhaps been under explored. This paper investigates this by reviewing the manufacture of a complex geometry representative of a fixed trailing edge panel, identifying the current forming philosophy and then applying novel drape simulation tools to improve on that forming route to facilitate productivity increases. This was possible by the development of unambiguous forming instruction sets, that when combined with some preforming solutions further increased the productivity and cost reduction potential. The low cost manual forming was compared to an in-house AFP productivity assessment, and it was found that the rates were comparable on an hourly deposition rate, but when assessed in terms of other metrics manual forming could still remain the most suitable manufacturing route. The work has shown that for complex structures manual forming with well developed drape solutions can still be the most low cost and productive process.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Ward, C., Lukaszewicz, D., and Potter, K., "Exploring the Manual Forming of Complex Geometry Composite Panels for Productivity and Quality Gains in Relation to Automated Forming Capabilities," SAE Technical Paper 2011-01-2547, 2011, https://doi.org/10.4271/2011-01-2547.Also In
References
- Melville, R. 2007 Introduction to NGCW and the future product perspective Lavaur, Fr Airbus SAS
- DeLong, D.J. 2007 Global market outlook for carbon fiber 2006 and beyond SAMPE J 43 1 39 46
- Ward, C. 2009 Personal communication
- Grant, C. 2006 Automated processes for composite aircraft structure Industrial robot 33 2 117 121
- Evans, D.O. 2001 Fiber Placement ASM Handbook v21 xx, Composites Materials Park OH, USA ASM Intl 1135 1147
- Grimshaw, M.N. 2001 Automated Tape Laying ASM Handbook v21 xx, Composites Materials Park Ohio, USA ASM Intl 1147 1152
- Lukaszewicz, D. H.-J. A. et al 2009 An empirical model for the automated deposition of thermoset composite ASC 24 th Ann Tech Conf 15 17 September Neward, DE, USA. Dayton, OH, USA ASC 1 15
- Lukaszewicz, D. H.-J. A. Potter, K.D. 2011 The internal structure and conformation of prepreg with respect to reliable automated processing Composites 42 3 283 292
- Mayerhofer, L. 2010 The process chain of CFRP XXL-Structures in CFK Nord Cologne, DE German Aerospace Center (DLR) http://www.cfk-valley.com 24 06 2011
- Oldani, T. “Increasing Productivity in Fiber Placement Process,” Oral Only Presentation, 2008 SAE International AMAF Conference and Exhibit
- Apmann, H. “Automatic Handling of CFRP-Material for Frame and Stringer Production,” SAE Technical Paper 2008-01-2289 2008 10.4271/2008-01-2289
- Reinhart, G. Straβer, G. Ehinger, C. “Highly Flexible Automated Manufacturing of Composite Structures Consisting of Limp Carbon Fibre Textiles,” SAE Int. J. Aerosp. 2 1 181 187 2010 10.4271/2009-01-3213
- Hancock, S. Potter, K. 2006 Implementation and applications of virtual fabric placement in forming fabric reinforcement for production of complex shaped components 8th Intl Conf Textile Compos 16 18 Oct Nottingham, UK. Nottingham, UK NCN/ SAMPE UK & EIRE
- Hancock, S.G. 2006 Forming woven fabric reinforced composite materials for complex shaped components - informing manufacture with virtual prototyping Thesis (PhD) University of Bristol
- Ward, C. Hancock, S. Potter, K. “Forming Complex Shaped Components Using Drape Simulation Software: Informing Manual and Automated Production Needs,” SAE Int. J. Aerosp. 1 1 798 810 2009 10.4271/2008-01-2316
- Ward, C. Potter, K. 2009 Composites component design & the role of drape simulation SAMPE Europe SEICO 09 23 25 March Paris, Fr. Covina, CA, USA SAMPE 78 83
- Parker, R. 2010 Technology for high value added manufacture ‘The engine of economic growth’ London, UK Rolls-Royce plc
- Potter, K. et al 2009 Approaches to automating the manufacture of complex sandwich panels SAMPE Europe Tech Conf 09 18 19 Sept Bristol UK. Covina, CA, USA SAMPE 78 85
- Potter, K.D. 2004 Deformation properties of uncured reinforcements - a reappraisal Int J Mater Prod Technol 21 1/2/3 4 23
- Potter, K. 2009 Achieving low variability, rework and scrap rates in the production of advanced composite parts SAMPE Europe SEICO 09 23 25 March Paris, Fr. Covina, CA, USA SAMPE 265 270
- Ward, C. Potter, K. 2008 A novel approach to manufacture complex lightly loaded structures using vacuum forming; technique and first trials assessment SAMPE Europe SEICO 08 31 March 2 April Paris, Fr. Covina, CA, USA SAMPE 92 97
- ANON, 2002 Military Handbook 17, Composite Materials Handbook v3: Polymer matrix composites usage, design & analysis Philadelphia, USA Department of Defence
- Postier, R.A. 1985 Factory automation for composite structures manufacturing SAMPE Quarterly 16 45 49
- Lukaszewicz, D. H.-J. A. 2011 Considerations for automated layup of thermoset carbon-fibre preimpregnates Thesis (PhD) University of Bristol
- Belfourd, D. et al 2009 HIVOL WP 2.3 - Optimised Manufacturing Processes Lavaur, Fr Airbus SAS
- Lees, M. 2010 Complex AFP i-Composites Grand Challenge Research Event 15 September Bristol, UK. Bristol, UK University of Bristol
- Marengo, G. 2007 Double diaphragm forming the A400M wing composite spars Design and manufacture for next generation composite applications 20 September BAWA Filton, Bristol, UK. Bristol, UK I Mech E
- Ward, C. 2010 Personal communication
- Krolweski, S. Gutowski, T. 1986 Effect of the automation of advanced composite fabrication processes on part cost SAMPE Q 18 1 43 51
- Allison, H.B. Pitman, W.A. 1980 Future trends in technology and automation AIAA international meeting & technical display “global technology 2000” 6 8 May Baltimore, USA. New York, USA AIAA 1 8