This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Characteristics of Frontal Crashes with Serious Injuries and Airbag Non-deployment
Technical Paper
2010-01-1048
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The objective of the present study is to develop a better understanding of the reasons for airbag non-deployment in frontal crashes that produce serious injuries. The FARS data shows an increasing trend of fatal crashes involving airbag non-deployment with a higher fatality risk in recent model year vehicles. The reported number of fatalities in such crashes has increased by about 50 percent (from 500 per year to 780 per year) in the last five years. The percentage of fatalities with non-deployments has doubled in vehicles model year 1998 and later compared to earlier model years. Multiple impacts contribute to about 90 percent of the FARS frontal crashes with non-deployments. Crashes with a curb hit or guardrail impact as the first harmful event and a narrow impact crash with a tree or pole as a subsequent harmful event is the most frequent crash scenario in non-deployment related fatal crashes. The NASS-CDS analysis of frontal crashes with non-deployment and serious injuries revealed that for the un-weighted sample of crashes, about 27 percent may be related to multiple impacts. A common example is a curb or guardrail hit followed by pole impact. Most of these crashes experienced a second impact with Delta-V higher than 20mph. In such a crash, the air bag deployment would be expected to benefit the occupant.
Based on these findings, it is proposed to develop testing techniques to check the airbag deployment requirements in multiple impact crashes. Introducing a breakaway pole before the barrier may simulate the effects of pre-impacts like curb hits or guardrail impacts prior to main impact. It is anticipated that this test will encourage improvements in the airbag deployment algorithm which could possibly reduce the frequency of non-deployment in injury producing multiple impacts.
Recommended Content
Citation
Raj, P. and Digges, K., "Characteristics of Frontal Crashes with Serious Injuries and Airbag Non-deployment," SAE Technical Paper 2010-01-1048, 2010, https://doi.org/10.4271/2010-01-1048.Also In
References
- NCSA, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration “Fatality Analysis Reporting System and General Estimates System: 2006 Data Summary,” Report 810819 1 30 2006
- NCSA, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration “Traffic Safety Facts 2007: A compilation of Motor Vehicle Crash Data from the Fatality Analysis Reporting System and the General Estimates System” Report DOT809100 1 202 2007
- Insurance Institute for Highway Safety “Airbags Save Lives” Status Report 30 3 1 3 1995
- NCSA, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration “Fifth/Sixth Report to Congress; Effectiveness of Occupant Protection Systems and Their Use,” 2000
- Insurance Institute for Highway Safety “Deaths caused by inflating airbags have declined dramatically,” Status Report 37 4 6 7 2002
- Insurance Institute for Highway Safety “Depowered airbags have lessened the fatality risk for drivers of most passenger vehicles but not pickup trucks” Status Report 39 3 1 8 2004
- Insurance Institute for Highway Safety “Deaths caused by inflating airbags have been dramatically reduced,” Status Report 40 7 6 7 2005
- Casey, M. Montgomery, R. “Fatal Failures” The Kansas City Star, Metropolitan, National/ World:A1 2007
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration “UNS on the Web; Vehicle Crash Test Database” http://nhtsa.gov/portal/site/nhtsa/menuitem.8027fe7cfb6e727568d07a30343c44cc/ July 16 2008
- NCSA, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration “2006 FARS Coding and Validation Manual,” 2006
- Raj, P. “Analysis of frontal airbag non-deployment fatalities and severe injuries,” Civil and Environmental Engineering Department, The George Washington University Washington DC 2009
- NCSA, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration “Fatalities in Frontal Crashes without Airbag Deployment” 1 45 2008
- Insurance Institute for Highway Safety “Frontal Airbags Failed to Inflate, Newspaper Report” Status Report 44 2 6 7 2009
- Chan, C. “Fundamentals of Crash Sensing in Automotive Airbag Systems,” SAE International Warrendale, PA 978-0-7680-0499-1 2000
- Cooper, J. “Airbag system with biomechanical gray zones,” U.S. Patent 238668 12 23 2004
- Nusholtz et al. “Estimation of OOP from Conditional Probabilities of Airbag Fire-times and Vehicle Response” 16th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles Ontario, Canada 2 6 1998
- Nusholtz et al. “Fundamental Relation Between Fire Time and Impact Severity Estimation Uncertainty” The 18th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles Nogoya, Japan 1 2 1998
- Wang, T. Lin, C. “Collision sensing system” U.S. Patent 303677 1 17 2004
- Okano, M. “Control System For Actuating Vehicle Airbags” U.S. Patent 5122954 3 24 1992
- Hussain, A. Hannan, M. Mohamed, A. Majlis, B. “Decision Algorithm for Smart Airbag Deployment Safety Issues,” International Journal of Intelligent Technology 1 1 32 41 2006
- Gioutsos, T. “Important Issues in Crash Severity Sensing,” SAE Technical Paper 2002-01-0182 2002
- Chou, C.C. Le, J. Chen, P. Bauch, D.J. “Development of CAE Simulated Crash Pulses for Airbag Sensor Algorithm/Calibration in Frontal Impacts,” SAE Technical Paper 2001-06-0059 2001