This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Turbocharged vs. Turbo-Compounded Ethanol Engine: Fuel-Air Equivalence Ratio Impact
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published October 06, 2009 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The quest for high efficient internal combustion engines has intensified in the last years due to, among other reasons, increasing fuel costs and the pressure to reduce environmental deterioration. One of the possible alternatives capable of providing the sought efficiency gains is the recovery of the energy wasted in the exhaust gases and turbo-compounding is one obvious option. Compression ignition engines are usually the target of turbo-compounding, however, the rising interest for alternative fuels could result in the use of turbo-compounding for spark ignition engines as well. Due to its different flame propagation mechanism, spark ignition engines may force operation at higher fuel-air ratios, eventually creating a quite distinctive operational behavior.
This paper evaluates the impact of fuel-air ratio on losses and efficiencies of a 12-liter, 6-cylinder intercooled turbocharged engine and its turbo-compounded version, both running on ethanol, applying a method described by Winterbone et al [15–18], named turbine work function, as an alternative to the 2nd law of Thermodynamics.
Engine performance simulations showed turbo-compounded configuration featuring an optimum fuel-air ratio due to a trade-off between combustion rate and pumping losses, on one hand, and exhaust energy recovery on the other, trend not detected in the turbocharged configuration. This trade-off may impose a fundamental limitation on turbo-compounded spark ignition engines.
CitationHindi, G., Zabeu, C., and Langeani, M., "Turbocharged vs. Turbo-Compounded Ethanol Engine: Fuel-Air Equivalence Ratio Impact," SAE Technical Paper 2009-36-0050, 2009, https://doi.org/10.4271/2009-36-0050.
- Wilson, D. E. “The design of a low specific fuel consumption turbocompound engine” SAE paper No 860072
- Hountalas, D. T. Katsanos, C. O. Lamaris, V. T. “Recovering energy from the diesel engine exhaust using mechanical and electrical turbocompounding” SAE paper No 2007-01-1563
- Hopmann, U. Algrain, M. C. “Diesel engine electric turbo compound technology” SAE paper No 2003-01-2294
- Brands, M. C. Werner, J. Hoehne, J. L. Saunders Kramer “Vehicle testing of cummins turbocompound diesel engine” SAE paper No 810073
- Sendyka, B. Soczowka, J. “Recovery of exhaust gases energy by means of turbocompound” Politechnika Krakowska
- Bromberg, L. Cohn, D. R. Heywood, J. B. “Calculations of knock suppression in highly turbocharged gasoline/ethanol engines using direct ethanol injection” MIT report LFEE 2006-01
- Flynn, P. F. Hoag, K. L. Kamel, M. M. Primus, R. J. “A new perspective on diesel engine evaluation based on second law analysis” SAE paper No 840032
- Primus, R. J. “A second law approach to exhaust system optimization” SAE paper No 840033
- Primus, R. J. Hoag, K. L. Flynn, P. F. Brands, M. C. “An Appraisal of Advanced Engine Concepts Using Second Law Analysis Techniques,” SAE Paper no. 841287
- Caton, J. A. “Operating characteristics of a spark-ignition engine using the second law of thermodynamics: effects of speed and load” SAE paper No 2000-01-0952
- Caton, J. A. “A review of investigations using the second-law of thermodynamics to study internal combustion engines” SAE paper No 2000-01-1081
- Caton, J. A. “A cycle simulation including the second law of thermodynamics for a spark-ignition engine: implications of the use of multiple-zones for combustion” SAE paper No 2002-01-0007
- Rakopoulos, C. D. Giakounis, E. G. “Parametric study of transient turbocharged diesel engine operation from the second-law perspective” SAE paper No 2004-01-1679
- Edwards, K. D. Wagner, R. M. Graves. R. L. “Identification of potential efficiency opportunities in internal combustion engines using a detailed thermodynamic analysis of engine simulation results” SAE paper No 2008-01-0293
- Winterbone, D. E. Nichols, J. R. Alexander, G. I. Sinha, S. K. 1985 “The evaluation of the performance of exhaust systems equipped with integral pulse converters” CIMAC
- Winterbone, D. E. Nichols, J. R. Alexander, G. I. 1985 “Efficiency of manifolds of turbocharged engines” Proc. Inst. Mech. Engrs, Part D, J. Auto. Engrg 199 D2 137 149
- Winterbone, D. E. Pearson, R. J. “Design techniques for engine manifolds” Professional Engineering Publishing Limited 1999
- Winterbone, D. E. Pearson, R. J. “Theory of engine manifold design” Professional Engineering Publishing Limited 2000
- van Wylen, G. J. Sonntag, R. E. “Fundamentals of classical themodynamics” John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 1990
- Watson, N. Janota, M. S. “Turbocharging the internal combustion engine” John Wiley & Sons 1982
- Heywood, J. B. “Internal combustion engine fundamentals” McGraw-Hill Book Company 1988