This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Frontal Impact Rear Seatbelt Load Marks: An In-Depth Analysis
Technical Paper
2009-01-1249
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Forensic evidence left behind in the form of markings on the seatbelt system can reveal details of how the belt system was being used and how it performed in a collision. Information about how belt systems are being used and how they perform in the field is useful to the design engineer, but interpreting this forensic evidence can be very difficult. Most studies to date have looked at the evidence left behind after a collision simply to determine if the seat belt was being used. This study undertakes the next step and addresses the question of how the belt system was being used. Test data is also presented to allow investigators to determine if the retractor locked and remained locked during the collision or if it spooled out during the collision.
The results of 22 HYGE sled tests were analyzed to investigate the types and patterns of marks left behind. Frontal impact sled tests were conducted using a variety of dummy sizes and belt configurations including several types of belt misuse conditions. A standardized process of documenting seatbelt load marks using objective measurements was developed and used to catalog the marks left behind by the crash test dummies loading the seatbelt systems in frontal impacts. The results of this study give insight into some unusual seatbelt load mark patterns that have been observed in the field. The results also demonstrate how a careful analysis of the forensic seatbelt evidence combined with an understanding of occupant belt fit and accident geometry can determine not only if a seatbelt was being used during an accident, but how it was being used.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Burnett, R., Ballard, W., Marth, D., and Van Arsdell, W., "Frontal Impact Rear Seatbelt Load Marks: An In-Depth Analysis," SAE Technical Paper 2009-01-1249, 2009, https://doi.org/10.4271/2009-01-1249.Also In
References
- Malliaris, A. C. DeBlois, J. H. “Overstated Safety Belt Use Rates – Evidence, Consequences, and Remedies,” SAE 980351
- Moffatt, C. A. Moffatt, E. A. Weiman, T. R. “Diagnosis of Seatbelt Usage in Accidents,” SAE 840396
- Gorski, Z. M. German, A. Nowak, E. S. “Examination and Analysis of Seatbelt Loading Marks,” Journal of Forensic Sciences, JFSCA 35 No. 1 Jan. 1990 69 79
- Felicella, D. J. “Forensic Analysis of Seatbelts,” Kinetic Energy Press Salem, Oregon 2003
- Bready, J. E. Nordhagen, R. P. Kent, R. W. “Seatbelt Survey: Identification and Assessment of Noncollision Markings,” SAE 1999-01-0441
- Bready, J. E. Nordhagen, R. P. Kent, R. W. Jakstis, M. W. “Characteristics of Seatbelt Restraint System Markings,” SAE 2000-01-1317
- Tanner, C. B. Durisek, N. J. Hoover, T. D. Guenther, D. A. “Automotive Restraint Loading Evidence for Moderate Speed Impacts and a Variety of Restraint Conditions,” SAE 2006-01-0900
- Raymond, D. E. Bir, C. A. Begeman, P. C. Chien, Hai-Chun Wheeler, J. B. “Forensic Determination of Seatbelt Usage in Automotive Collisions: Development of a Diagnostic Tool,” SAE 2006-01-1128
- Halonbrenner, R. “The Investigation of Traffic Accidents by the Police,” IRCOBI
- Davee, D. Brown, J. C. Raasch, C. “Case Study of Clothing Fabric Transfer to Seatbelt Webbing Under Accident Forces,” SAE 2006-01-0904
- Cromack, J. R. Schneider, D. Blaisdell, D. “Occupant Kinematics & Belt Markings in Crash Tests with Unrestrained and Partially Restrained Test Dummies,” 34 th Annual Proceedings Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine 1990
- Beaudoin, B. Peterson, D. Hoover, R. Newberry, W. Smyth, B. “Restraint Load Marks in Sled Testing Conducted with the Hybrid III 3-Year-Old and 6-Year-Old Anthropomorphic Test Devices,” SAE 2008-01-1239
- Green, R. N. German, A. Gorski, Z. M. Nowak, E. S. Tryphonopoulos, J. P. “Improper Use of Occupant Restraints: Case Studies From Real-World Collisions,” 30 th Annual Proceedings Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine 1986
- Heydinger, G. J. Uhlenhake, G. D. Guenther, D. A. Dunn, A. “Comparison of Collision and Noncollision Marks on Vehicle Restraint Systems,” SAE 2008-01-0160