This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Statistical Analysis of Indicating Parameters for Knock Detection Purposes
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 20, 2009 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Specific power and efficiency of gasoline engines are influenced by factors such as compression ratio and Spark Advance (SA) regulation. These factors influence the combustion development over the crank angle: the trade-off between performance and the risk of irreversible damages is still a key element in the design of both high-performance (racing) and low-consumption engines.
This paper presents a novel approach to the problem, with the objective of defining a damage-related and operating conditions-independent index. The methodology is based on the combined analysis of indicating parameters, such as Cumulated Heat Release (CHR), Indicated Mean Effective Pressure (IMEP) and 50% Mass Fraction Burned (MFB50), and typical knock detection parameters, estimated by means of the in-cylinder pressure sensor signal.
Knocking combustions have several consequences, therefore they can be detected in many ways. As it is well known, knock excites the combustion chamber resonant frequencies, rising high frequency components in the in-cylinder pressure signal. Additionally, knocking combustions cause a higher heat flux through the combustion chamber walls, increasing the heat losses and lowering the IMEP: this effect can be observed by evaluating IMEP or CHR, that are based on the low-frequency content of the in-cylinder signal spectrum. A knock detection index can then be based on the crossed-observation of two phenomena, one set in the low-frequencies range and the other one on the high frequencies range of the in-cylinder pressure signal.
Knock-related parameters have been analyzed with a statistical approach, in order to define a detection strategy based on one single threshold value, to be used for all the engines, independently of engine speed and load: IMEP and CHR have been related to a typical high-frequency knock index, based on the Maximum Amplitude of Pressure Oscillations (MAPO) evaluated over the combustion angular window. It can be observed that, as knock intensity increases, the relationships between these parameters change. This change can be seized by evaluating the correlation coefficient between the parameters distributions and observing its trend as a function of SA (Spark Advance). The correlation coefficient is intrinsically normalized, therefore the index range is the same for every engine operating condition, and the paper shows that the threshold level, too, is constant. The same approach can be applied to determine SA corresponding to the best combustion phase, simply by evaluating the correlation coefficient for IMEP and MFB50 distributions.
The methodology has been successfully applied to different engines running in different speed and load conditions.
|Technical Paper||A Stochastic Knock Control Algorithm|
|Technical Paper||Evaluations of Combustion Parameters Using Engine Speed Fluctuation Measurements|
|Technical Paper||Combustion Chamber Gas Temperatures by a Benzene Light-Absorption Technique|
CitationCorti, E. and Forte, C., "Statistical Analysis of Indicating Parameters for Knock Detection Purposes," SAE Technical Paper 2009-01-0237, 2009, https://doi.org/10.4271/2009-01-0237.
- Worret R. Bernhardt S. Schwarz F. Spicher U. Application of Different Cylinder Pressure Based Knock Detection Methods In Spark Ignition Engines SAE World Congress, 2002-01-1668 2002
- Brecq G. Bellettre J. Tazerout M. Experimental Determination of Knock in Gas SI Engines SAE World Congress, 2001-28-0022 2001
- Millo F. Ferraro C. V. Knock in S.I. Engines: a Comparison Between Different Techniques for Detection and Control SAE World Congress, 982477 1998
- Brecq G. Bellettre J. Tazerout M. 2003 A New Indicator for Knock Detection in Gas SI Engines International Journal of Thermal Sciences 42 523 532
- Xiaofeng G. Stone R. Hudson C. Bradbury I. The Detection and Quantification of Knock in Spark Ignition Engines SAE World Congress, 932759 1993
- Nates R.J. Yates A.D.B. Knock Damage Mechanisms in Spark-Ignition Engines SAE World Congress, 942064 1994
- Fitton J. Nates R. Knock Erosion in Spark-Ignition Engines SAE World Congress, 962102 1996
- Minelli G. Corti E. Moro D. Solieri L. Knock Indexes Normalization Methodologies SAE World Congress, 2006-01-2998 2006
- Bertola A. Stadler J. Walter T. Wolfer P. Gossweiler C. Rothe M. Pressure Indication During Knocking Conditions 7 th International AVL Symposium on Internal Combustion Diagnostics 2006
- Heywood J.B. Internal Combustion Engine Fundamentals McGraw-Hill 1988
- Lu J.-h. Ezekoye. D. Iiama A. Greif R. Saweye R.F. Effect of Knock on Time-Resolved Engine Heat Transfer SAE World Congress, 890158 1989
- Ezekoye O.A. Heat Transfer Modeling During Knock and Flame Quenching in an Engine Chamber Twenty-Sixth Symposium on Combustion The Combustion Institute 1995 2661 2668
- Syrimis M. Shigahara K. Assanis D. N. Correlation Between Knock intensity and Heat Transfer Under Light and Heavy Knocking Conditions in a Spark Ignition Engine SAE World Congress, 960495 1996
- Syrimis M. Shigahara K. Assanis D. N. Piston Heat Transfer Measurements Under Varying Knock Intensity in a Spark-Ignition Engine SAE World Congress, 971667 1997
- Grandin B. Denbratt I. Bood J. Brackmann C. Bengtsson P. E. The Effect of Knock on the Heat Ttransfer in an S.I. Engine: Thermal Boundary Layer Investigation Using CARS Temperature Measurements and Heat Flux Measurements SAE World Congress, 2000-01-2831 2000
- Grandin B. Denbratt I. Bood J. Brackmann C. Bengtsson P. E. Gogan A. Mauss F. Sunden B. The effect of Knock on heat Transfer in S.I. Engines SAE World Congress, 2002-01-0238 2002
- Grandin B. Denbratt I. Bood J. Brackmann C. Bengtsson P. E. Gogan A. Mauss F. Sunden B. Heat Release in the End-Gas Prior to Knock in Lean, Rich and Stoichiometric Mixtures With and Without EGR SAE World Congress, 2002-01-0239 2002
- Cavina N. Corti E. Solieri L. A Heat Flux Damages-Related Index ASME ICES Congress, ICES2006-1425 2006
- Campbell J. Lovell W. G. Application of Statistical Concepts to the knock-Rating Problem SAE Technical Paper, 380169 1938
- Wu G. A Real Time Statistical Method for Engine Knock Detection SAE World Congress, 2007-01-1507 2007
- Zhu G. G. Haskara I. Winkelman J. R. Stochastic Limit Control and Its Application to Knock Limit Control Using Ionization Feedback SAE World Congress, 2005-01-0018 2005