This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Experimental and CFD Comparative Case Studies of Aerodynamics of Race Car Wings, Underbodies with Wheels, and Motorcycle Flows
Technical Paper
2008-01-2997
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The validity and usefulness of low-complexity “fast-turnaround CFD” for motorsports design is investigated using results from three different combined experimental and CFD analyses of racing or high-speed vehicles. Analyses using both wind tunnel experiments and CFD simulations (with commercial software and moderate computing resources) found good agreement in some aspects of interest over a variety of applied situations. Key results were the ability for relatively simple CFD models to consistently predict CL in complex flows within 15-25% of experimental findings, predict the effect of design changes on flow, and accurately show qualitative flow phenomenon. However, CD values were not accurately predicted with the low-complexity simulations. Simulations were run using the commercial Fluent© 6.3 application. Experimental results were performed in the Cornell University 4 by 4 foot wind-tunnel.
The first investigation explored the development of front and rear wing packages for a formula-style race vehicle. After validation of Fluent© 6.3, basic 2D wing designs were optimized using CFD and tested in the wind-tunnel and on the track.
The second investigation explored the aerodynamics of underbody-equipped bluff bodies in ground-effect flow. Focus was on the influence of multiple surrounding elements (wheels) on underbody diffuser performance. Flow phenomena, such as trailing-edge diffuser separation and vortex development, and how they are affected by wheels and their wakes are discussed.
The third investigation explored flow structure predictions of motorcycle engines surrounded by interfering objects (wheel, forks, frame). CFD simulations isolated key factors influencing flow phenomenon and were useful in predicting the effects of modifications to the design.
“Fast-turnaround CFD” was found to yield robust and sufficiently accurate results for varied aerodynamic configurations useful for applied vehicle design. It accurately calculated CL in multiple configurations (less than 25% error) as well as successfully modeled flow field dynamics for single and multiple body situations. This was done in 2D with low y+, and in 3D with high y+ value models which were relatively easy to mesh and run. Limitations with the approach, such as inability to accurately predict CD, are discussed.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Desai, S., Leylek, E., Lo, C., Doddegowda, P. et al., "Experimental and CFD Comparative Case Studies of Aerodynamics of Race Car Wings, Underbodies with Wheels, and Motorcycle Flows," SAE Technical Paper 2008-01-2997, 2008, https://doi.org/10.4271/2008-01-2997.Also In
References
- Doddegowda, Punith Bychkovsky Aleksandr George A.R. “Use of Computational Fluid Dynamics for the Design of Formula SAE Race Car Aerodynamics,” SAE Paper 2006-01-0807 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA, USA 2006
- Desai, Sachin Lo Betty George A.R. “A Computational Study of Idealized Bluff Bodies, Wheels, and Vortex Structures in Ground Effect,” SAE Paper 2008-01-0327 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA, USA 1998
- Zhang, Xin Toet Willem Zerihan Jonathan “Ground Effect Aerodynamics of Race Cars,” ASME Applied Mechanics Reviews 59 33 49 American Society of Mechanical Engineers New York, NY, USA 2006
- Bell, Brian Cokljat D. Dai Y. Kim S. Mathey F. Rhee S. “Case Studies on Using the Turbulence Models in Fluent © 6,” Presented at 2004 CFD Training Summit Fluent© 2004
- McManus, James Zhang X. “A Computational Study of the Flow Around an Isolated Wheel in Contact With Ground,” ASME Fluids J. Eng. 128 520 530 American Society of Mechanical Engineers New York, NY, USA 2006
- Zerihan, Jonathan Zhang X. “Aerodynamics of a Single-Element Wing in Ground Effect,” J. Aircraft 37 6 1058 1064 American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics 2000
- Breslouer, Oren George Albert “Exploratory Experimental Studies of Forces and Flow Structure on a Bluff Body with Variable Diffuser and Wheel Configurations” SAE Paper 2008-01-0326 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA, USA
- Cooper, Kevin R. Bertenyi T. Dutil G. Syms J. Sovran G. “The Aerodynamic Performance of Automotive Underbody Diffusers,” SAE Paper 98-0030 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA, USA 1998
- George, Albert R. Donis J.E. “Flow Patterns, Pressures, and Forces on the Underside of Idealized Ground Effect Vehicles,” Proceedings of the ASME Fluids Engineering Division Symposium on Aerodynamics of Transportation-II 7 69 79 American Society of Mechanical Engineers New York, NY, USA 1983
- George, A. R. “Aerodynamic Effects of Shape Camber, Pitch, and Ground Proximity on Idealized Ground Vehicle Bodies,” ASME Fluids J. Eng. 103 631 638 American Society of Mechanical Engineers York, NY, USA 1981 Originally published in: Aerodynamics of Transportation Morel, T. Dalton, C., American Society of Mechanical Engineers New York, NY, USA 1979
- Desai, Sachin Leylek Emily Lo Chi-Man Betty George Albert “Computational Studies on Complex Multi-Body, Ground Effect and Underbody Flows,” Cornell University FDA Report 2008-22 Ithaca, NY 2008
- Katz, Joseph Race Car Aerodynamics - Designing for Speed Bentley Publishers 0837601428 1995
- Lewis, R. Postle P. “CFD Validation for External Aerodynamics,” 1 st European Automotive CFD Conference Fluent© Bingen, Germany 2003
- McBeath, Simon Competition Car Downforce: A Practical Handbook Haynes Publishing 1859606628 2000
- Soso, Michael Wilson P. Investigating Changes to the Downforce Curve of a Double Element Airfoil in Ground Effect SAE International, 2004-01-3558
- Cogotti, A. “Aerodynamic Characteristics of Car Wheels,” Int. Vehicle J. Design, Special Publication SP3 173 196 Interscience Enterprises Ltd. UK 1981