This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Use of Life Cycle Assessment with Crankcase Lubricants to Yield Maximum Environmental Benefit – Case Study of Residual Chlorine in Lubricant
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published October 06, 2008 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) is a methodology used to determine quantitatively the environmental impacts of a range of options. The environmental community has used LCA to study all of the impacts of a product over its life cycle. This analysis can help to prevent instances where a greater degree of environmental harm results when changes are made to products based on consideration of impacts in only part of the life cycle.
This study applies the methodology to engine lubricants, and in particular chlorine limits in engine lubricant specifications. Concern that chlorine in lubricants might contribute to emissions from vehicle exhausts of polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins (PCDD) and polychlorinated dibenzofurans (PCDF), collectively called PCDD/F, led to the introduction of chlorine limits in lubricant specifications. No direct evidence was available linking chlorine in lubricants to PCDD/F formation, but precautionary principles were used to set lubricant chlorine limits.
To complete this study, the LCA was supplemented by detailed emissions testing from the use and disposal phase of lubricants. Used in this way, it provides a model methodology to determine the optimal method of engine oil specifications to reduce total environmental impact. In the specific case of chlorine limits, the LCA and testing demonstrate that restricting chlorine does not (at least below 259 mgkg-1- the highest level tested in the study) produce lower PCDD/F, and the higher energy costs and reduced frictional performance of low-chlorine dispersants can lead to greater overall environmental impacts.
CitationDyke, P., Sutton, M., Thiele, T., and Collins, M., "The Use of Life Cycle Assessment with Crankcase Lubricants to Yield Maximum Environmental Benefit – Case Study of Residual Chlorine in Lubricant," SAE Technical Paper 2008-01-2376, 2008, https://doi.org/10.4271/2008-01-2376.
- Eduljee, G. H. Dyke P. H. 1996 ‘An updated inventory of potential PCDD and PCDF emission sources in the UK’ Science of the Total Environment 177 303 321
- Van den Berg, M. Birnbaum, L.S. Bosveld, A.T.C. Brunström, B. Cook, P. Feeley, M. Giesy, J.P. Hanberg, A. Hasegawa, R. Kennedy, S.W. Kubiak, T. Larsen, J.C. van Leeuwen, F.X.R. Liem, A.K.D. Nolt, C. Peterson, R.E. Poellinger, L. Safe, S.H. Schrenk, D. Tillit, D. Tysklind, M. Younes, M. Wærn, F. Zacharewski, T. 1998 ‘Toxic Equivalency Factors (TEFs) for PCBs, PCDDs, PCDFs for Humans and Wildlife.’ Environmental Health Perspectives 106 12 775 792
- Marklund, S. Rappe, C. Tysklind, M. Egebäck, K. E. 1987 ‘Identification of polychlorinated dibenzofurans and dioxins in exhausts from cars run on leaded gasoline’ Chemosphere 16 1 29 36
- CE-CERT 1998 ‘Evaluation of Factors That Affect Diesel Exhaust Toxicity’ Center for Environmental Research and Technology, College of Engineering, University of California Norbeck, J. M. Smith, M. R. Arey, J. Kado, N. Okamoto, B.
- Hagenmaier, H. Dawidowsky, N. Weberruss, U. Hutzinger, O. Schwind, K.H. Thoma, H. Essers, U. Bühler, U. Greiner, R. 1990 ‘Emission of polyhalogenated dibenzodioxins and dibenzofurans from combustion engines’ Dioxin '90, Organohalogen Compounds 2 329 334
- Schwind, K. H. 1991 et al ‘Emission halogenierter dibenzodioxine (PXDD) und dibenzofurane (PXDF) aus verbrennungsmotoren’ UWSF-Z. Umweltchem. Oekotox. 3 291 298
- Essers U. et al 1992 Untersuchen zur Emission halogenierter Dibenzodioxine und Dibenzofurance aus Verbrennungsmoteren beim Betreib mit handelsublichen Betreibsstoffen Investigations of the emission of halogenated dibenzodioxin and didbenzofuran from combustion engines 0937-9932 Research Centre for Environment and Health Munich
- Hagenmaier, H. 1994 ‘Contributions of diesel-powered vehicles and wood burning to overall PCDD/PCDF emissions’ Dioxin '94, 11th International Symposium on Chlorinated Dioxins, PCB and Related Compounds November 21-25 1994 Kyoto, Japan
- Hagenmaier, H. 1995 ‘Eintrag und verbleib von PCDD/PCDF -Bedeutung der eintrage durch automobilabgase und holzfeuerungen’ Organohalogen Compounds 22 49 54
- Mayer, A. 2002 Definition, Measurement and Filtration of ultrafine solid particles emitted by diesel engines ATW-EMPA-Symposium 19 April 2002
- Mayer, A. Heeb, N. Czerwinski J. Wyser, M. 2003 Secondary Emissions from catalytic active particle filter systems 2003-01-0291 SAE International
- Dyke, P. H. Sutton, M. Thiele, T. Collins, M. 2006 Lessons Learned: Reflection on dioxins in the life cycle assessment of lubricating oil Organohalogen Compounds 68
- Sutton, M. Marshall, J. Dyke, P. H. Collins, M. Relationship of Chlorine Content in Lubricants to Dioxin Exhaust Emissions Asia F&L Conference March 2006
- CML 2.7 Centre for Environmental Studies (CML), University of Leiden The Netherlands April 2004
- EPS 2000 Steen Bengt Chalmers University of Technology, Technical Environmental Planning, Centre for Environmental Assessment of Products and Material Systems 2000
- EDIP/UMIP 1996 Danish EPA, the Technical University of Denmark, Confederation of Danish Industries, Bang & Olufsen A/S, Danfoss A/S, Gram A/S, Grundfos A/S and KEW A/S 1996
- Eco-Indicator 99 Dutch Ministry of Environment, Swiss National Science Foundation and the Swiss Agency for the Environment, Forests and Landscapes (BUWAL) 1999
- Sofres Taylor Nelson 2001 Critical review of existing studies and life cycle analysis on the regeneration and incineration of waste oils Internet document Dec. 2004 www.europa.eu.int/comm/environment/waste/studie s/oil/waste_oil.pdf
- Dyke, P. H. Sutton, M. Wood, D. Marshall, J. 2007 Investigations on the effect of chlorine in lubricating oil and the presence of a diesel oxidation catalyst on PCDD/F releases from an internal combustion engine Chemosphere 67 1275 1286
- European Union Directive 1999/96/EC
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Method 23a, Revision #1 - Determination of Polychlorinated Dibenzo-p-dioxins and Polychlorinated Dibenzofurans from Stationary Sources US EPA Office of Solid Waste December 1996
- EN (European Standard) 1948-1, Stationary Source Emissions, Determination of the Mass Concentration of PCDDs/PCDFs Part 1: Sampling CEN 1996
- EN 1948-2, Stationary Source Emissions, Determination of the Mass Concentration of PCDDs/PCDFs Part 2: Extraction and Clean up CEN 1996
- EN 1948-3, Stationary Source Emissions, Determination of the Mass Concentration of PCDDs/PCDFs Part 3: Identification and Quantification CEN 1996