This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Serious Injury in Very-Low and Very-High Speed Rear Impacts
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 14, 2008 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The objective of this study was to analyze rear crashes for the risk of serious injury (AIS 3+) by delta V. Rear impacts were analyzed for occupants sitting in front seats of light vehicles. Data was obtained from NASS-CDS for calendar years 1991-2004. Tow-away crashes with ≤15 mph rear delta V account for 67% of rear impacts and 15% of serious injury. Even for crashes <30 mph delta V, the risk for serious injury is only 0.24% (less than 1 per 420 exposed occupants). Risks increase for higher delta Vs.
Individual cases in the 1997-2004 NASS-CDS electronic database were reviewed for serious injury in crashes with ≤15 mph delta V and ≥35 mph for light vehicles with calendar year >1996 to better understand injury mechanisms. Nine cases were available where a front-seat occupant was seriously injured in ≤15 mph rear delta V impact. Most cases involved older occupants, some of whom had stenosis of the cervical spine. These occupants experienced spinal cord injury and paralysis with or without fracture of the cervical spine. Frailty of the cervical spine was a factor in the very-low speed crash injuries.
There were 28 occupants in 26 crashes with serious injury at delta V ≥35 mph. In 7 of the cases, the most serious injury was to the cervical spine. Intrusion of rear structures was common leading to the front-seat occupant being supported upright or being pushed forward causing serious injury. Intrusion forces were associated with the injury. In the most severe rear crashes, rearward rotation of the seatback was not a factor in the occupant's injury as the early occurrence of intrusion limited seatback rotation.
This analysis has identified a class of seriously injured occupants in very-low speed rear crashes. Advanced age and degeneration of the cervical spinal canal can lead to spinal cord injury and paralysis in crashes otherwise not causing serious injury in normal adults. Yielding seats diminish the risk of cervical injury in frail occupants. Use of stiffer seats would increase the risk of injury in occupants with spinal stenosis. The very-high speed crashes involved substantial intrusion, which occurred early in the crash and supported the seatback from rotating rearward. The collision forces and intrusion were associated with injury to front-seat occupants.
CitationViano, D. and Parenteau, C., "Serious Injury in Very-Low and Very-High Speed Rear Impacts," SAE Technical Paper 2008-01-1485, 2008, https://doi.org/10.4271/2008-01-1485.
- Andrews FJ Transient cervical neurapraxia associated with cervical spine stenosis Emerg Med J 19 172 173 2002
- Augenstein J Digges K Bahouth G Dalmotas D Perdeck E Stratton J Investigation of the performance of safety systems for protection of the elderly Annu Proc Assoc Adv Automot Med 49 361 9 2005
- Burnett R Carter J Roberts V Myers B The influence of seatback characteristics on cervical injury risk in severe rear impacts Accid Anal Prev 36 4 591 601 2004
- Coughlin JM Investigation of Amusement Park and Roller Coaster Injury Likelihood and Severity Exponent, Report #DC18967.000 A0T0 0802 FR01 August 9 2002
- Finnoff JT Mildenberger D Cassidy CD Central Cord Syndrome in a Football Player With Congenital Spinal Stenosis: A Case Report Am J Sports Med ; 32 516 521 2004
- Firooznia H Ahn JH Rafii M Ragnarsson KT Sudden Quadriplegia After a Minor Trauma: The Role of Preexisting Spinal Stenosis Surg Neurol 23 165 168 1985
- Giovanini MA Day AL Spinal Injuries in Athletes With Cervical Stenosis Techniques Neurosurgery 5 2 185 193 June 1999
- Gupta V Menon R Gupta S Mani A Shanmugavelu I Kossar J Improved Occupant Protection Through Advanced Seat Design 15th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV) Melbourne, Australia May 13-17 1996
- Katoh S Ikata T Hirai N Okada Y Nakauchi K Influence of minor trauma to the neck on the neurological outcome in patients with ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament (OPLL) of the cervical spine Paraplegia Jun 33 6 330 3 1995
- Kelly JD Clancy M Marchetto PA et al The relationship of transient upper extremity paresthesias and cervical stenosis Orthop Trans 16 732 1992
- Koyanagi I Iwasaki Y Hida K Imamura H Fujimoto S Akino M Acute Cervical Cord Injury Associated With Ossification of the Posterior Longitudinal Ligament Neurosurgery Oct 53 4 887 91 2003
- Matsunaga S Kukita M Hayashi K Shinkura R Koriyama C Sakou T Komiya S Pathogenesis of Myelopathy in Patients With Ossification of the Posterior Longitudinal Ligament J Neurosurg Mar 96 168 72 2002
- Moiel R Raso E Waltz T Central Cord Syndrome Resulting From Congenital Narrowness of the Cervical Spinal Canal J Trauma 10 502 510 1970
- Molino L. Preliminary Assessment of NASS CDS Data Related to Rearward Seat Collapse and Occupant Injury NHTSA 1997
- Molino L. Determination of Moment-Deflection Characteristics of Automobile Seat Backs NHTSA report 1998
- NHTSA Data Collection, Coding, and Editing Manual, National Accident Sampling System Crashworthiness Data System USDOT, NCSA 1996
- NHTSA Initiatives to Address the Mitigation of Vehicle Rollover June 2003
- Ng TP Bussone WR Duma SM The effect of gender and body size on linear accelerations of the head observed during daily activities Biomed Sci Instrum 42 25 30 2006
- Parenteau C Viano DC Field Data Analysis of Rear Occupant Injuries Part I: Adults and Teenagers SAE 2003-01-0153 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 2003
- Parenteau C Viano DC Field Data Analysis of Rear Occupant Injuries Part II: Children, Toddlers and Infants SAE 2003-01-0154 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 2003
- Penning L. Some Aspects of Plain Radiography of the Cervical Spine in Chronic Myelopathy Neurology 12 513 9 1962
- Prasad P Kim A Weerappuli DVP Biofidelity of anthropomorphic test devices for rear impact SAE 973342 , 41 st Stapp Car Crash Conference Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1997
- Prasad P Kim A Weerappuli DVP Roberts V Schneider D Relationships between passenger-car seat back strength and occupant injury severity in rear-end collisions: field and laboratory studies SAE 973343 , 41 st Stapp Car Crash Conference Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1997
- Santanello SA Falcone R Poka A Johnson, J. Incomplete Quadriplegia Resulting from Minor Trauma: Initial Presentation of Ossification of the Posterior Longitudinal Ligament J Trauma 50 3 March 2001
- Schmidt MH Quinones-Hinojosa A Rosenberg WS Cervical Myelopathy Associated with Degenerative Spine Disease and Ossification of the Posterior Longitudinal Ligament Semin Neurol 22 143 148 2002
- Viano DC The Debate Between Stiff and Yielding Seats: A New Generation of Yielding Seats with High Retention in Rear Crashes SAE Book PT-106 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA 2003
- Viano DC Parenteau CS Prasad P Burnett R Stiff versus Yielding Seats: Analysis of Matched Rear Impact Tests SAE 2007-01-0708 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA 2007
- Viano DC Role of the Seat in Rear Crash Safety SAE Book 0-7680-0847-6 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 317 1 491 2002
- Viano DC Parenteau CS Prasad P Burnett R Occupant Responses in High-Speed Rear Crashes: Analysis of Government-Sponsored Tests SAE 2008-01-0188 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA 2008