This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Seat Belt Entanglement in Rollover Accidents: Physical Evidence and Occupant Kinematics
Technical Paper
2008-01-1237
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
In rollover accidents, physical evidence of seat belt usage is occasionally difficult to discern. Typically, if a seat belt is used by an occupant in an accident, various seat belt components will display characteristic marks in well-defined locations. These marks are known as “witness marks” or “occupant load marks.” Witness marks in a rollover accident may be faint in comparison to those caused by the occupant restraint forces in high-energy planar collisions. Additionally, in situations where a seat belt buckle is alleged to have unlatched early in a rollover accident, the lack of clear occupant load marks may in some cases be attributed to an alleged “buckle release” that occurred very early in the rollover sequence, so that the seat belt did not sustain loading while in a latched condition. However, a documented Case Study and preliminary testing indicate that release of a seat belt buckle during a rollover accident leads to entanglement of the occupant's torso and/or outboard arm in the webbing. This entanglement produces distinctive evidence on the seat belt assembly and vehicle, as well as injury to the occupant. To further evaluate occupant load marks unique to entanglement, dolly rollover tests were performed using a vehicle with a reinforced roof. Hybrid III Anthropomorphic Test Devices (ATDs) were seated in the front outboard seats with their respective seat belt tongues connected to their buckles using nylon cable ties to produce a simulated “buckle unlatching” very early in the rollover event. This testing showed that if the roll rate was high enough to produce occupant ejection, both driver and passenger-side occupants became entangled in the unlatched seat belts during ejection from the vehicle. This entanglement created occupant load marks substantially different from typical occupant restraint evidence, with a characteristic pattern observed on the vehicle and seat belt.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Raasch, C., Davee, D., and Luepke, P., "Seat Belt Entanglement in Rollover Accidents: Physical Evidence and Occupant Kinematics," SAE Technical Paper 2008-01-1237, 2008, https://doi.org/10.4271/2008-01-1237.Also In
References
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration “Effectiveness of Occupant Protection Systems and Their Use,” Fifth/Sixth Report to Congress DOT HS 809 442 November 2001
- Huelke D.F. “The Effectiveness of Belt Systems in Frontal and Rollover Crashes,” SAE 770148
- Evans L. “Restraint Effectiveness, Occupant Ejection from Cars, and Fatality Reductions,” General Motors Research Laboratories GMR-6398 September 1 1988
- Digges K.H. Malliaris A.A. DeBlois H.J. “Opportunities for Casualty Reduction in Rollover Crashes,” Proceedings of the 14th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV) Paper No. 94-S5-O-11 1994
- Green P.D. Robertson N.K.B. Bradford M.A. Bodiwala G.G. “Car Occupant Ejection in 919 Sampled Accidents in the UK – 1983-1986,” SAE 870323
- Moore T.L.A. Vijayakumar V. Steffey D.L Ramachandran K. Ford Corrigan C. “Biomechanical Factors and Injury Risk in High-Severity Rollovers,” 49th Annual Proceedings of the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine September 12-14, 2005
- Moffatt C.A. Moffatt E.A. Weiman T.R. “Diagnosis of Seat Belt Usage in Accidents,” SAE 840396
- Gorski Z.M. German A. Nowak E.S. Examination and Analysis of Seat Belt Loading Marks Journal of Forensic Sciences, JFSCA 35 1 Jan. 1990 69 79
- Bready J.E. Nordhagen R.P. Kent R.W. “Characteristics of Seat Belt Restraints Systems Markings,” SAE 2000-01-137
- Bready J.E. Nordhagen R.P. Kent R.W. “Seat Belt Survey: Identification and Assessment of Noncollision Markings,” SAE 1999-01-0441
- Tanner C.B. Durisek N.J. Hoover T.D. “Automotive Restraint Loading Evidence for Moderate Speed Impacts and a Variety of Restraint Conditions,” SAE 2006-01-0900
- Raymond D.E. Bir C.A. Begeman P.C. Chien H-C. Wheeler J.B. “Forensic Determination of Seat Belt Usage in Automotive Collisions: Development of a Diagnostic Tool,” SAE 2006-01-1128
- Toomey D.E. Van Ee C. Klima M.E. “Safety Restraint System Physical Evidence and Biomechanical Injury Potential Due to Belt Entanglement,” SAE 2006-01-1670
- Raphael E. Piziali R. Le H. Hinger J. Cooper E. Croteau J. “Physical Evidence Associated with Seatbelt Entanglement During a Collision,” SAE 2007-01-1501