This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Comparison Exercise of Ice Accretion Simulations with 2D and 3D Solvers
Technical Paper
2007-01-3338
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
There are many different numerical approaches to ice accretion simulation. Little comparison has been made between those approaches to identify the best tool for a given application. This paper presents a comparison exercise between 2D codes (CANICE-BA and LEWICE) and 3D codes (CANICE3D-BA, LEWICE3D and FENSAP-ICE). It also compares the 3D first generation code (panel method with Lagrangian droplet trajectory tracking) CANICE3D-BA to the 3D second generation code (Navier-Stokes with Eulerian droplet tracking) FENSAP-ICE. The paper includes a description of the different methodologies. The first comparison exercise is done using three 2D cases for which experimental ice shapes are available. The second exercise addresses a water collection efficiency over an isolated tail for which experimental data is available. Finally, an ice accretion comparison is presented in a DLR4 wing-body configuration.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Pueyo, A., Brette, C., Vafa, S., and Akel, I., "A Comparison Exercise of Ice Accretion Simulations with 2D and 3D Solvers," SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-3338, 2007, https://doi.org/10.4271/2007-01-3338.Also In
References
- Tran, P. Brahimi, M.T. Paraschivoiu, I. Pueyo, A. Tezok, F. “Ice Accretion on Aircraft Wings with Thermodynamic Effects” Journal of Aircraft 32 2 1994
- Ruff, G.A. Berkowitz, B.M. “Users manual for the NASA Lewis Ice Accretion Prediction code (LEWICE),” May 1990
- Gent R. W. “TRAJICE2, A Combined Water Droplet and Ice Accretion Prediction Program for Aerofoil” 1990
- Guffond D. Bruent L. “Validation du Programme Bidimensional de Captation” 1985
- Bidwell, C.S. Potapczuk, M.G. “Users Manual for the NASA Lewis Three-Dimensional Ice Accretion Code (LEWICE3D),” December 1993
- Hedde, T. Guffond, D. “ONERA three-dimensional icing model” AIAA Journal 1995 33 6 1038 1045
- Dezitter, F. Chene, G. Viala, S. Calmels, B. “3D Ice Accretion And Aerodynamic Penalties Prediction on Aircraft” AIAA paper 2003-3833 Orlando Florida June 2003
- Bourgault, Y. Habashi, W. G. Dompierre, J. Baruzzi, G. S. “A Finite Element Method Study of Eulerian Droplets impingement Models” International Journal For Numerical Methods In Fluids 429 449 1999
- Pueyo, A. “Simulation numerique de la formation de la glace pour des ecoulements tridimensionnels ” Ecole Polytechnique de Montreal 1992
- Saeed, F. Brette, C. Fregeau, M. Trifu, O. Paraschivoiu I. “A Three-Dimensional Water Droplet Trajectory and Impingement Analysis Program” AIAA Paper 2005-4838
- “Ice Accretion Simulation Evaluation Test”
- Wright, W.B. Rutkowski, A. “Validation Results for LEWICE 2.0” January 1999
- Wright, W.B. Validation results for LEWICE 3.0 CR-2005-213561
- Hedde, T. Guffond, D. “Improvement of the ONERA 3D icing code, comparison with 3D experimental shapes”
- Pueyo, A. Chocron, D. Kafyeke, F. “Improvements to the Ice Accretion Code CANICE” CASI 8 th Aerodynamics Symposium Toronto May 2001
- www.am-inc.com
- Brette, C. Vafa, S. Pueyo, A. Akel, I. “3D Local Impingement Efficiency Validation with CANICE3D-BA and FENSAP-ICE” Canadian Aeronautic and Space Institute 12 th Aerodynamics Symposium 2007
- Messinger, B. Equilibrium Temperature of an Unheated Icing Surface as a Function of Air Speed Journal of Aeronautical Sciences January 1953
- Incropera, F. DeWitt, D. “Fundamentals of Heat and Mass Transfer” 4th John Wiley & Sons 1996
- Mavriplis, D.J. Venkatakrishnan, V. “A Unified Multigrid Solver for the Navier-Stokes Equations on Mixed Element Meshes” International Journal for Computational Fluid Dynamics 8 247 263 1997
- Mavriplis, D., J. Levy, D., W. “Transonic Drag Prediction Using an Unstructured Multigrid Solver” Journal Of Aircraft 42 4 2005
- Beaugendre, H. Morency, F. Habashi, W.G. ““ICE3D, FENSAP-ICE's In-flight Ice Accretion Module” Proceeding of the 48th CASI Annual Conference May 2001 Toronto, Ontario, Canada 271 276
- Papadakis, M. Hung, K. E. “Experimental Investigation of Water Droplet Impingement on Airfoils, Finite Wings, and an S-Duct Engine Inlet” October 2002