This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Ice Detection Systems: A Historical Perspective
Technical Paper
2007-01-3325
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Ice protection systems were installed on DC-3s, B-29s and other aircraft during World War II. Initially ice detection was not considered a requirement for aircraft safety.
One of the earliest ice detectors installed on a production aircraft (C-130) was pneumatic. Subsequently many other technologies have been applied to detect the presence of meteorological icing. Ice detectors employing visible light, infrared light, alpha radiation, natural resonance frequency, capacitance, speed of sound, heat of fusion, and microwaves have all been developed over the years.
This paper will review the different ice detection technologies and explore some of the similarities, differences, benefits and drawbacks for the purposes of performing their intended function.
One of the drivers for developing new ice detection technology has been aircraft icing accidents and incidents. For example, a number of MD-80 accidents caused by engine flame-outs during take-off have prompted development of surface-based ice detection solutions that could detect ice accretion on wing surfaces prior to take-off. Other accidents such as the Comair CRJ crash in Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada and the American Eagle ATR-42/72 crash in Roselawn, Indiana have spurred research into different ice detection technologies related to the Ludlam Limit and Supercooled Large Droplets (SLD) respectively. This paper will review various aircraft accidents and incidents that have had an impact on ice detection technology.
While no Federal Aviation Regulations (FARs) exist today which deal specifically with ice detection systems, there has been some industry guidance material published which provides information on the design of ice detection systems. Due to the increased industry awareness of aircraft icing issues, a number of industry committees such as EUROCAE and IPHWG have been established to develop new guidance material and proposed regulation changes related to ice detection systems. The release of the ED-103/104 Minimum Operational Performance Specifications and other guidance material such as the recent updates to AC 20 73 published by the FAA have had an impact on the development and certification of ice detection systems.
This paper will review the regulation changes that impact ice detection system design and certification, including a discussion regarding the ability of ice detection technologies to meet these requirements and to be certified as a Primary system.
Recommended Content
Book | The Design of Aircraft Landing Gear |
Technical Paper | Aircraft Landing Gear Dynamics Present and Future |
Book | Aircraft Wheels, Brakes, and Brake Controls: Key Principles for Landing Gear Design |
Authors
Citation
Jackson, D. and Goldberg, J., "Ice Detection Systems: A Historical Perspective," SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-3325, 2007, https://doi.org/10.4271/2007-01-3325.Also In
References
- “Minimum Operational Performance Specification for In-Flight Icing Detection Systems,” EUROCAE ED-103 SAE AS5498
- Results of Lufthansa German Airlines B-727 Flight Test of Rosemount Ice Detector,” Lufthansa German Airlines and Rosemount Inc. December 1 1981
- Jackson, D.G. Cronin, D.J. Severson, J.A. Owens, D.G. “Ludlam Limit Considerations on Cylinder Ice Accretion: Aerodynamics and Thermodynamics,”
- “Training, Deicing and Emergency Checklist Linked in MD-81 Accident Following Clear-ice Ingestine by Engines” Flight Safety Foundation Accident Prevention 50 12 December 1993
- Mason, J.G. Strapp, J.W. Chow, P. “The Ice Particle Threat to Engines in Flight,”
- Federal Aviation Regulations Part 25, Airworthiness Standards: Transport Category Airplanes
- “In-Flight Icing Encounter and Loss of Control Simmons Airlines Roselawn, Indiana October 31 1994 National Transportation Safety Board Aircraft Accident Report
- Cober, S.G. Korolev, A.V. Isaac, G.A. “Assessing Characteristics of the Rosemount Icing Detector Under Natural Icing Conditions,”
- “Loss of Control on Go-around (Rejected Landing) Air Canada Canadair CL-600-2B19 C-FSKI Fredericton Airport New Brunswick 16 December 1997 Transportation Safety Board of Canada Aviation Occurrence
- Cronin, D.J et. al. “Numerical Analysis of a BFG Ice Detector Location for the Learjet 45” 1999 SAE General, Corporate & Regional Aviation Meeting and Exposition
- Boutanios Z. Bourgault Y. et al “3-D Droplets Impingement Analysis Around an Aircraft's Nose and Cockpit Using FENSAP-ICE”
- “Aircraft Ice Detectors and Icing Rate Measuring Instruments” SAE AIR4367 April 1995
- Jackson, D.G. Owens, D.G. Cronin, D.J. Severson, J.A. “Certification and Integration Aspects of a Primary Ice Detection System,”
- Severson, J.A. “Considerations When Performing Wind Tunnel Testing to Determine Critical Temperature,” SAE 03FAAID-21
- “Environmental Conditions and Test Procedures for Airborne Equipment”
- “Software Considerations in Airborne Systems and Equipment Certification”
- FAA Notice of Proposed Rule Making for FAR 25.1419
- “Primary In-flight Ice Detection System” EASA Certification Review Item Post F-14 April 5 2000
- FAA In-Flight Ice Detection Sensing Systems Policy Memo July 9 1986
- FAA Advisory Circular 20-73A “Aircraft Ice Protection.” August 16 2006
- “General Specification for Aircraft Engines and Airframe Air Intake Duct Ice Detector” March 1965 SAE AS8181 Aug. 1997
- EASA ETSO-2C507 “Inflight Icing Detection Systems”
- EASA ETSO-2C508 “Ground Icing Detection Systems”
- “Minimum Operational Performance Specification for Ground Icing Detection Systems,” EUROCAE ED- 104 and SAE AS5116