This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Influence of Lubricant Formulations on Engine Oil Consumption using Radionuclide Technique
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published July 23, 2007 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
High lubricant consumption has a negative impact on the environment and on drain intervals. It also reduces the life-time of after-treatment systems by clogging particle filters or poisoning catalysts. Oil consumption rates of modern engines have been significantly reduced during the last decade, but they will still have to be reduced to meet the future Euro 5 European standard (COM(2007)19 final - SEC(2007) 60 and 61 - European Commission proposal for Euro V for passenger cars).
In order to study the impact of lubricants formulation on oil consumption, a new method based on lubricant labeling using new radiotracer compounds, was used on running engines. The radiotracers (derivative organic compounds of germanium-69) used for online oil consumption measurements were adapted in order to simulate the distillation interval of each lubricant. An in-house engine test was performed on a diesel 2.2 L direct injection Common Rail engine. A particle filter is installed in the exhaust line in order to trap residues coming from oil combustion and, in particular, radiotracer residues. A test procedure was specially developed in order to compare the selected lubricants. The very high sensitivity of the radiotracer method allowed shortening significantly engine test durations down to less than two hours, with an excellent repeatability on oil consumption.
The impact of lubricants formulation (base oil, viscosity grades, volatility and additives) on oil consumption has been studied in a very pertinent way. This has allowed a comparison of a wide range of SAE 5W-30 and 5W-40 lubricants on a unique engine, under very similar operating conditions.
- Thierry Delvigne - DSi - Delta Services Industriels, Belgium
- Olivier Courtois - DSi - Delta Services Industriels, Belgium
- Benoît Deconninck - DSi - Delta Services Industriels, Belgium
- Anne-Eline Gilles - Total Research Center of Solaize, France
- Ludivine Pidol - Total Research Center of Solaize, France
CitationGilles, A., Pidol, L., Delvigne, T., Courtois, O. et al., "Influence of Lubricant Formulations on Engine Oil Consumption using Radionuclide Technique," SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-1981, 2007, https://doi.org/10.4271/2007-01-1981.
- DSI & Total March 18 2004 “Method and Device for Continuous Determination of Lubricating Oil Consumption of an Internal Combustion Engine”
- Delvigne T. Deconninck B. Obiols J. China P. Carlier P. “A New Methodology for On-line Lubricant Consumption Measurement” SAE paper 2005-01-2172 2005
- van Dam W. Kleiser W. M. “Lubricant Related Fators Controlling Oil Consumption in Diesel Engines” SAE paper 952547
- Didot F. E. Green E. Johnson R. H. “Volatility and Oil Consumption of SAE 5W-30 Engine Oil” SAE paper 872126
- “C-Lube” system from Delta Services Industriels http://www.deltabeam.net
- “Evaporation Loss of Lubricating Oils using the Noack Evaporative Tester” CEC test Method L-40-93
- “Boiling Range Distribution of Petroleum Fractions by Gas Chromatography” ASTM D2887 Standard Test Method
- Boffa Alex B. Cook Greg G. “Impact of Oil Volatility in Extended Drain Service” SAE paper 1999-01-3469
- Yilmaz E. Tian T. Wong V. W. Heywood J. B. “An Experimental and Theoretical Study of the Contribution of Oil Evaporation to Oil Consumption” SAE paper 2002-01-2684
- Henderson H. E. Mack P. D. Steckle W. M. Swinney B. “Higher Quality Base Oils for Tomorrow's Engine Oil Performance Categories” SAE paper 982582