This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Forensic Seat Belt Evidence as an Indicator of Impact Angle
Technical Paper
2007-01-0719
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Forensic evidence within a crash vehicle's occupant compartment as well as the occupant injuries may provide important validation tools for the accident reconstructionist, particularly to corroborate the principal direction of force (PDOF) on the occupant. The objective of this study was to evaluate forensic evidence of dynamic loading found on the seat belt webbing, latch plate, D-ring, and any other associated restraint components as a function of frontal impact angle in a series of sled tests utilizing 95th percentile male, 5th percentile female, and 6 year old Hybrid III ATDs.
A late 1990s full size SUV was converted to a sled buck for testing. The test series included impact angles from 0 degrees to 60 degrees in 15 degree increments. The tests were conducted at approximately 35 kph (22 mph) on a rebound style sled. Post-impact, the seat belt systems were removed from the sled, labeled and archived for subsequent detailed analysis. Physical evidence for each belt assembly was documented using macroscopic and photographic techniques.
The results in this study indicate the occupant PDOF can be confirmed by examining the safety belt systems, but that the evidence alone cannot qualitatively determine the occupant or crash PDOF. The forensic evidence can be used as a validation tool as related to the calculated PDOF.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Hauschild, H. and Syson, S., "Forensic Seat Belt Evidence as an Indicator of Impact Angle," SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-0719, 2007, https://doi.org/10.4271/2007-01-0719.Also In
References
- Bidez M. W. et. al “Lap-Shoulder Belt Performance as a Function of Occupant Size” SAE 2005-01-1705 2005
- Bidez M. W. et. al. “Small Occupant Dynamics in the Rear Seat: Influence of Impact angle and Belt Restraint Design” 2005-01-1708 2005
- Bready Jon et. al. “Characteristics of Seat Belt Restraint Markings” SAE 2000-01-1317 2000
- Bready Jon E. Nordhagen Ronald P. Kent Richard W. “Seat Belt Survey: Identification and Assessment of Noncollision Markings” SAE 1999-01-0441 1999
- Chou C.C. “Vehicle Crashworthiness & Occupant Protection” Chapter 4, SAE 2000
- Cooper E “Traveler Bar Research” Exponent 2002
- Cromack J. Robert Schneider Dennis Blaisdell David “Occupant Kinematics & Belt Markings in Crash Tests with Unrestrained and Partially Restrained Dummies” 34 Proceedings of Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine 1990
- Davee Daniel Brown Jeffery C. Raasch Christine “Case Studies of Clothing Fabric Transfer to Seat Belt Webbing Under Accident Forces” SAE 2006-01-0904 2001
- Felicella D.J. “Forensic Analysis of Seat Belts” Kinetic Energy Press 2002
- Gamero F. “Tangled Web” Movin’ Parts, General Motors Parts Division June 1991
- Gorski Z.M. German A. Nowak E.S. “Examination & Analysis of Seat Belt Loading Marks” Journal of Forensic Sciences 35 1 69 79 American Academy of Forensic Sciences (AAFS) January 1990
- Jacobson O.H. Ziernicki R.M. “Field Investigation of Automotive Seatbelts” Accident Investigation Quarterly 9 16 19 Accident Reconstruction Journal, Winter 1996
- Hauschild Hans W. “Forensic Evidence of Chid Restraint Devices in Vehicle Crashes” SAE 2004-01-1218 2004
- Moffatt C.A. Moffatt E.A. Weiman T.R. Diagnosis of Seat Belt Usage in Accidents” SAE 840396 1984
- Muttart JW. “Post Impact Seat Belt Examination” Accident Reconstruction Journal May June 1991
- Phillips E. “An Examination Guide for Determining Seat Belt Use During a Collision” Traffic Accident Reconstruction Origin 1999
- Raymond David E. et. al “Forensic Determination of Seat Belt Usage in Automotive Collisions: Development of a Diagnostic Tool” SAE 2006-01-1128 2006
- Rivers R.W. “Seat Belt & Airbag Systems Maual for Traffic Investigation and reconstruction” IPTM 2002
- Tanner Brian C. et. al. “Automotive Restraint Loading Evidence for Moderate Speed Impacts and a Variety of Restraint Conditions” SAE 2006-01-0900 2006
- Toomey Daniel E. Van Ee Chris Klima Michael Safety Restraint System Physical Evidence & Biomechanical Injury Potential Due to Belt Entanglement” SAE 2006-01-1670 2006
- Wirth Jeffery L Marine Micky C. Thomas Terry M. “An Analysis of a Staged Two Vehicle Impact” SAE 2000-01-0464 2000