Design Approach of Closed Loop Food Systems in Space
Published July 11, 2005 by SAE International in United States
Annotation of this paper is available
Interest on food production systems based on the cultivation of vegetables for future planetary exploration missions is increasing as these units can help overcoming difficult and costly re-supply logistics. In addition to producing edible biomass by growing vegetable species, these systems can be used in closed loop configuration with bio-regenerative life support subsystems for water and CO2 recycling and O2 production. Aiming at this objective, the European Space Agency (ESA) undertook a feasibility study on Closed Loop Food Systems (CLFS) for Low Earth Orbit (LEO), Transit to Mars and Mars Surface scenarios. This paper describes the study’s results. Firstly, candidate crops are selected based on nutritional characteristics and aspects like yield, cultivation surface and volume, and generated inedible biomass. A culture plan for these crops is then established. The design process of a Food Production Unit (FPU) begins with the definition of an On Ground Experimental Growth Unit (OGEGU), a ground reference system that is later adapted to the proposed Space scenarios. For Low Earth Orbit (LEO), two secondary structures options (racks and spiral), fitting a Columbus-sized module, are presented and their food production capabilities are analyzed. Similarly, design options for Transit to Mars and Mars Surface are described. Mass, power and volume budgets are determined and the Equivalent System Mass (ESM) methodology is used for trade-off study. For the LEO options process modeling and preliminary mechanical, thermal, safety and logistics analysis are done. Impacts on the International Space Station (ISS) due to potential FPU implementation are also studied. For the Mars surface scenario, an adapted FPU architecture is presented. Interface issues between FPU and bio-regenerative life support systems are also addressed. The study shows that FPU systems for LEO application could deliver ca. 12% of the food requirements, which makes them a very interesting platform for both space agriculture research and complementing nutritional requirements. For the Mars Surface application provision of up to 40 % food requirements is shown possible. Finally, relevant technological gaps identified throughout the study are outlined.
- J. L. Mas - NTE S.A
- X. Vanrobaeys - Unit Plant Hormone Signaling and Bio-imaging, Department of Molecular Genetics, Ghent University
- D. Hagenbeek. - Unit Plant Hormone Signaling and Bio-imaging, Department of Molecular Genetics, Ghent University
- L. Chaerle - Unit Plant Hormone Signaling and Bio-imaging, Department of Molecular Genetics, Ghent University
- D. Van Der Straeten - Unit Plant Hormone Signaling and Bio-imaging, Department of Molecular Genetics, Ghent University
- R. Kassel - Verhaert Design & Development
- E.G.O.N. Janssen - TNO Environment and Geosciences
- S. Hovland - Human Spaceflight, European Space Agency
CitationMas, J., Vanrobaeys, X., Hagenbeek., D., Chaerle, L. et al., "Design Approach of Closed Loop Food Systems in Space," SAE Technical Paper 2005-01-2920, 2005, https://doi.org/10.4271/2005-01-2920.
- Vanrobaeys, X. et al. A Crop Selection Algorithm for Closed Loop Food Systems. Paper # 2005-01-2817, ICES 2005.
- Janssen, E.G.O.N. et al. Design of an On Ground Experimental Growth Unit (OGEGU) for Space Applications. Paper # 2005-01-2871, ICES 2005
- Jansssen, E.G.O.N. et al. Design approach and implementation of a Mars Surface Food Production Unit. Paper # 2005-01-2824, ICES 2005
- Closed Loop Food Systems - Final Report NTE SA, Barcelona (E), February 2005.
- Horneck, G. et al. HUMEX (Study on the Survivability and Adaptation of Humans to Long-Duration Exploratory Missions). Executive Summary. ESTEC Contract No. 14056/99/NL/PA, 2002.
- Human Mission to Mars. Overall Architecture Assessment. CDF Study Report CDF-20(A). ESA-ESTEC Concurrent Design Facility, February 2004.
- Advanced Life Support Baseline Values and Assumptions Document”, JSC-47804. Document Number CTSD-ADV-484 A, Rev A, August 2004.
- Levri, J.A., Vaccari, D.A., Drysdale, A.E., Theory and Application of the Equivalent System Mass Metric. Paper # 2000-01-2395, ICES 2000
- Columbus Pressurised Payloads Interface Requirement Document, ref. COL-RIBRE-SPE-0164, March 2001
- Columbus: Europe’s Laboratory on the International Space Station. ESA Brochure 144, October 1999.
- International Space Station Evolution Data Book, Vol. 1, rev. A, October 2000.
- Rodriguez, L. F., Bell, S. Verification of the Modified Energy Cascade Model – Report, National Research Council at NASA Lyndon B. Johnson Space Centre, Houston, Texas. Internal NASA document, March 2004.
- Chiaramonte, F.P., Joshi, J.A. Workshop on Critical Issues in Microgravity Fluids, Transport and Reaction Processes in Advanced Human Support Technology. Final Report. Doc. Number NASA/TM-2004-212940, February 2004.