This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Music Analogy: An Alternative Strategy for Sound Quality Requirements
Technical Paper
2005-01-2477
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
In recent years a predominant strategy for setting sound quality (SQ) requirements has been the sensory correlation approach (also called sensory evaluation or sensory science). Some users of this approach have reported their progress in numerous papers. Other SQ practitioners have made presentations on specific topics that show the linkage to music and musical notation. These specific links point to an alternative general strategy - “the Music Analogy for Sound Quality.” This paper begins by comparing the general methods of the music analogy and sensory correlation. Some major differences will be identified and implications discussed. Some existing specific tools for the music analogy will be identified as well as some gaps that need to be filled. Finally, reasons will be presented concerning why the music analogy should be considered when developing sound quality requirements.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Measurement of Acoustical Response of Automotive Cabin Interior |
Technical Paper | Sensitivity Analysis of Complex Eigensolutions for Brake Noise |
Technical Paper | CONSIDERATIONS IN THE DESIGN OF SHOCK AND VIBRATION TESTS |
Citation
Fridrich, R., "Music Analogy: An Alternative Strategy for Sound Quality Requirements," SAE Technical Paper 2005-01-2477, 2005, https://doi.org/10.4271/2005-01-2477.Also In
References
- Russell M.F. Worley S.A. Young C.D. Towards an Objective Estimate of the Subjective Reaction to Diesel Engine Noise Proceedings of the 1987 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 870958 May 1987
- Wakita T. Kozawa Y. Samada K. Sugimoto G. Ogasawara T. Fujii Y. Objective Rating of Rumble in Vehicle Passenger Compartment During Acceleration Proceedings of the 1989 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 891155 May 1989
- Hussain M. Golles J. Ronacher A. Schiffbanker H. Statistical Evaluation of an Annoyance Index for Engine Noise Recordings Proceedings of the 1991 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 911080 May 1991
- Schiffbanker H. Brandl F.K. Thien F.E. Development and Application of an Evaluation Technique to Assess the Subjective Character of Engine Noise Proceedings of the 1991 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 911081 May 1991
- Takao H. Hashimoto T. Hatano S. Quantification of Subjective Unpleasantness Using Roughness Level Proceedings of the 1993 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 931332 May 1993
- Amman S. Otto N. Jones C. Sound Quality Analysis of Vehicle Windshield Wiper Systems Proceedings of the 1993 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 931345 May 1993
- Murata H. Tanaka H. Takada H. Ohsasa Y. Sound Quality Evaluation of Passenger Vehicle Interior Noise Proceedings of the 1993 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 931347 May 1993
- Cerrato G. Crewe A. Terech J. Sound Quality Assessment of Powered Seat Adjusters Proceedings of the 1995 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 951288 May 1995
- Feng B. Wakefield G.H. Good M.D. Otto N.C. Rebandt R. On the Perceived Roughness of Automotive Powertrain Sounds Proceedings of the 1995 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 951312 May 1995
- Amman S.A. Young C.S. A Perceptual Model for Power Adjustable Steering Column Sounds Proceedings of the 1995 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 951371 May 1995
- Zhang L. Vertiz A. What Really Affect Customer Perception? - A Window Regulator Sound Quality Example Proceedings of the 1997 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 971909 May 1997
- Champagne A.J. Shiau N-M. Commercial Van Diesel Idle Sound Quality Proceedings of the 1997 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 971980 May 1997
- Otto N. Feng J. Cheng R. Wisniewski E. Linearity of Powertrain Acceleration Sound Proceedings of the 1997 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 971982 May 1997
- Blommer M. Amman S. Otto N. The Effect of Powertrain Sound on Perceived Vehicle Performance Proceedings of the 1997 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 971983 May 1997
- Penfold J.N. Power Window Sound Quality - A Case Study Proceedings of the 1997 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 972017 May 1997
- Weisch G. Stucklschwaiger W. de Mendonca A.A. Monteiro N.T.S. dos Santos L.A. The Creation of a Car Interior Noise Quality Index for Evaluation of Rattle Phenomena Proceedings of the 1997 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 972018 May 1997
- Brandl F.K. Biermayer W. A New Tool for the Onboard Objective Assessment of Vehicle Interior Noise Quality Proceedings of the 1999 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 1999-01-1695 May 1999
- Becker S. Yu S. Objective Noise Rating of Gear Whine Proceedings of the 1999 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 1999-01-1720 May 1999
- Becker S. Yu S. Gear Noise Rating Prediction Based on Objective Measurement Proceedings of the 1999 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 1999-01-1721 May 1999
- Sato N. Miura Y. Study on Exterior Idling Sound Quality Evaluation Method for Diesel Engine Trucks Proceedings of the 1999 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 1999-01-1739 May 1999
- Alt N. Wolff K. van den Eijkel P. Idle Comfort of Passenger Cars Proceedings of the 1999 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 1999-01-1805 May 1999
- Kato D.J. Eaton W.C. Sound Quality Engineering for RV Generator Sets Proceedings of the 1999 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 1999-01-1816 May 1999
- Zhang L. A Sensory Approach to Develop Product Sound Quality Criterion Proceedings of the 1999 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 1999-01-1818 May 1999
- Ingham R. Otto N. McCollum T. Sound Quality Metric for Diesel Engines Proceedings of the 1999 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 1999-01-1819 May 1999
- Amman S. Greenberg J. Gulker G. Abhyankar S. Subjective Quantification of Wind Buffeting Noise Proceedings of the 1999 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 1999-01-1821 May 1999
- Otto N. Amman S. Eaton C. Lake S. Guidelines for Jury Evaluations of Automotive Sounds Proceedings of the 1999 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 1999-01-1822 May 1999
- Pflueger M. Hoeldrich R. Brandl F.K. Biermayer W. Subjective Assessment of Roughness as a Basis for Objective Vehicle Interior Noise Quality Evaluation Proceedings of the 1999 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 1999-01-1850 May 1999
- Fernholz C.M. Bishop L.F. Use of Binaural Measurement and Analysis Techniques in the Establishment of Steering Pump Design Tolerances for Noise, Vibration and Harshness Performance Proceedings of the 1999 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 1999-01-1852 May 1999
- Fish D.G. Proceedings of the 2001 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers The Influence of In-Vehicle Noise on Speech Recognition for Automotive Voice-Activated Control Systems No. 2001-01-1530 May 2001
- Biermayer W. Thomann S. Brandl F. A Software Tool for Noise Quality and Brand Sound Development Proceedings of the 2001 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 2001-01-1573 May 2001
- Pflueger M. Stuecklschwaiger W. Sound and Vibration Quality Map for Commercial Vehicles Proceedings of the 2001 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 2001-01-1570 May 2001
- Lee S.K. Chae H.C. Park D.C. Jung S.G. Booming Index Development for Sound Quality Evaluation of a Passenger Car Proceedings of the 2003 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 2003-01-1497 May 2003
- Shkreli V. Vandenbrink K.A. The Use of Subjective Jury Evaluations for Interior Acoustic Packaging Proceedings of the 2003 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 2003-01-1506 May 2003
- Blommer M. Amman S. Abhyankar S. Dedecker B. Sound Quality Metric Development for Wind Buffeting and Gusting Noise Proceedings of the 2003 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 2003-01-1509 May 2003
- Noumura K. Yoshida J. Perception Modeling and Quantification of Sound Quality in Cabin Proceedings of the 2003 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 2003-01-1514 May 2003
- Grenier G.C. The Rattle Trap Proceedings of the 2003 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 2003-01-1525 May 2003
- Zwicker E. Fastl H. Psychoacoustics, Facts and Models Springer-Verlag 1990
- Fridrich R.J. Investigating Impulsive Sounds -- “Beyond Zwicker-Loudness,” Proceedings of the 1993 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 931329 May 1993
- Fridrich R.J. Pitch Matching for Impulsive Sounds Proceedings of the 1997 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 971981 May 1997
- Fastl H. Sound Design of Machines from a Musical Perspective Proceedings of the 2002 Sound Quality Symposium Institute of Noise Control Engineering August 2002
- Fridrich R.J. Pitch Intervals: Linking Sound Quality Engineering and Musical Acoustics Proceedings of the 2003 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 2003-01-1503 May 2003
- Alt J.W. Jochum S.E. Sound Design under the Aspects of Musical Harmony Theory Proceedings of the 2003 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 2003-01-1508 May 2003
- Standard Test Method for Odor and Taste Transfer from Polymeric Packaging Film ASTM International W. Coshohocken, PA, USA 2004
- Standard Test Method for Sensory Evaluation of Red Pepper Heat ASTM International W. Coshohocken, PA, USA 2004
- Standard Practice for Descriptive Skinfeel Analysis of Creams and Lotions ASTM International W. Coshohocken, PA, USA 2004
- Standard Guide for Quantitative Evaluation of Fragrance/Odors for Shampoos and Hair Conditioners ASTM International W. Coshohocken, PA, USA 2004
- Zwicker E. Fastl H. Psychoacoustics, Facts and Models Springer-Verlag 1990
- Fridrich R.J. Percentile Frequency Method for Evaluating Impulsive Sounds Proceedings of the 1999 Noise and Vibration Conference, Society of Automotive Engineers, No. 1999-01-1851 May 1999
- Fridrich R.J. Percentile Frequency Method and Zwicker Loudness Proceedings of Inter-noise 2002 Institute of Noise Control Engineering August 2002
- Zwicker E. Fastl H. Psychoacoustics, Facts and Models Springer-Verlag 1990