This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Required Measures to Improve the Structural Interaction Potential of Passenger-Cars
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 11, 2005 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Compatibility has been a passive safety research issue for many years. Great advancements in secondary (passive) safety have been achieved in the last decades through focussing on the self-protection level provided by passenger cars. The next step is to consider the other vehicle involved in the collision as well. Compatibility relates to the simultaneous improvement of both self- and partner- protection. Several tests procedures have been proposed around the world to assess the compatibility of passenger cars. None are considered ready to be implemented.
This paper shows that controlling vehicle front-end geometry is the most feasible step to improve both self- and partner-protection. Through this, an increase in the structural interaction potential offered by passenger cars would result. To improve structural interaction, a convergence of front-end structures, to within certain vertical limits, is necessary. The required vertical width of a structural interaction zone is investigated in this paper, based on results to car-to-car, head-on crash-test simulations.
Based on conclusions drawn from the car-to-car, head-on crash simulations, a new compatibility assessment method and a vertical width for a structural interaction zone is proposed. The sufficient support test (SST) evaluates the degree of support provided by a vehicle within the structural interaction zone, based on barrier deformation.
CitationThomas, G., Zobel, R., and Schwarz, T., "Required Measures to Improve the Structural Interaction Potential of Passenger-Cars," SAE Technical Paper 2005-01-1351, 2005, https://doi.org/10.4271/2005-01-1351.
Vehicle Aggressivity and Compatibility in Automotive Crashes, and Pedestrian Safety
Number: SP-1936 ; Published: 2005-04-11
Number: SP-1936 ; Published: 2005-04-11
- Appel, H. 1975. Sind kleine Wagen unsicherer als große?, VDI Nachrichten No. 7. 14. February 1975, pp 14-16.
- Decker, J. Grösch, L. Justen, R. Schwede, W. 1990. Realitätsnahe Frontale Crash-Versuche und daraus abgeleitete Schutzmaßnahmen in Merecedes Benz Fahrzeuge. AZT, 1990.
- Edwards; M. Davies, H. Hobbs, A. 2003. DEVELOPMENT OF TEST PROCEDURES AND PERFORMANCE CRITERIA TO IMPROVE COMPATIBILITY IN CAR FRONTAL COLLISIONS. ESV Conference 2003, Japan. Paper number 86.
- European Commission Regulation for motor vehicles and their trailers. (ECE Regulation) ECE-R 94, Kirschbaum Verlag Bonn, 1998.
- Federal motor vehicle standard (USA) 49CFR Part 571
- Haenchen, D. Schwarz, T. Thomas, G. Zobel, R. 2003. Feasible Steps Towards Improved Crash Compatibility. SAE Conference 2003, Detroit, Paper No. 2004-01-1167. 2004.
- Lund, A. Chapline, J. 1999. Potential Strategies for Improving Crash Compatibility in the U.S. Vehicle Fleet. SAE Conference 1999, Detroit, Paper No. 1999-01-0066.
- Mizuno, K. Kajzer, J. 1998. Compatibility problems in frontal, side, single car collisions and car-to-pedestrian accident in Japan, Accident Analysis and Prevention, pp 381-391. 1998.
- O'Reilly, P. 2003. STATUS REPORT OF IHRA COMPATIBILITY AND FRONTAL IMPACT WORKING GROUP. ESV Conference 2003 Paper number 402.
- Schwarz, T. 2002. Selbst und Partnerschutz bei frontalen Pkw-Pkw-Kollisionen (Kompatibilität). VDI Fortschrittbericht, Düsseldorf, Germany
- Workshop, ACEA Sub-group compatibility / ACEA Working Group Truck Safety, Official Minutes, UTAC Paris, 01.12.2003.
- Wu, W. 2003. Geometric Compatibility Between Cars and Roadside Safety Equipment, European Vehicle Passive Safety Network 2, Workshop Oct 16-17 Rhode, Germany.
- Zeidler, F.Knöchelmann, F 1997. The influence of Frontal Crash Test Speeds on the Compatbility of Passenger Cars in Real World Accidents (GERMAN) VDI conference “Innovativer Insassenschutz in PKW Kollisionen” Düsseldorf, Germany
- Zobel, R. 1996. Überlegungen zur strukturellen Abstimmung von Fahrzeugen unterscheidlicher Masse bei unterscheidlichen Kollisionstypen, Fachtagung Fahrzeugsicherheit/Kleinwagen, Haus der Technik Essen, 12-13 July 1996.
- Zobel, R. 1999 Accident Analysis and Measures to Improve Compatibility, SAE Conference 1999. Paper No. 1999-01-0065.