This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
On the Use of Reference Models in Automotive Aerodynamics
Technical Paper
2004-01-1308
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
In automotive aerodynamics much use has been made of generic reference models for research and correlation. Research work has been conducted mostly on small-scale versions of the models to investigate flow regimes and aerodynamic force and moment characteristics while correlation tests have made use of full-scale models to compare results between wind tunnels. More recently reference geometries have also been used as test cases in the validation of computational techniques.
This paper reviews the design characteristics and use of several key reference models. The advantages and disadvantages of these designs and also the applicability of the results in providing guidelines for the development of production vehicles are discussed.
It is advocated that when researchers choose to use simple models, existing reference geometries should be employed. It is also suggested that families of reference shapes could be extended to reflect the widening range of sizes and shapes of vehicles in the market-place.
Recommended Content
Citation
Le Good, G. and Garry, K., "On the Use of Reference Models in Automotive Aerodynamics," SAE Technical Paper 2004-01-1308, 2004, https://doi.org/10.4271/2004-01-1308.Also In
References
- JANSSEN, L.J. HUCHO, W.H. Aerodynamiische Formoptimierung der Type VW-Golf und VW-Scirocco Kolloquium under Industrie-aerodynamik Aachen 1974 46 49
- MOREL, T. Aerodynamic Drag of Bluff Body Shapes Characteristic of Hatch-Back Cars SAE Paper 780267 1978
- AHMED, S.R. RAMM, G. FALTIN, G. Some Salient Features of the Time-Averaged Ground Vehicle Wake SAE Paper 840300 1984
- LARSSON, L. BROBERG, L. JANSON, C-E. A Zonal Method for Predicting External Automobile Aerodynamics SAE Paper 910595 1991
- ALAJBEGOVIC, A et al Digital Physics Analysis of the Morel Model MIRA International Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 15-16 October 1996
- MAKOWSKI, F. KIM, S. Advances in External-Aer0 Simulation of Ground Vehicles Using the Steady RANS Equations SAE paper 2000-01-0484 2000
- PEARSON, W.E. MANNERS, A.P. PASSMORE, M.A. Prediction of the Flow Around A Bluff Body in Close Proximity to the Ground Royal Aeronautical Society Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 18-19 July 1994
- GRAYSMITH, J.L. BAXENDALE, A.J. HOWELL, J.P. HAYNES, T. Comparisons Between CFD and Experimental Results for the Ahmed Reference Model Royal Aeronautical Society Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 18-19 July 1994
- LIENHART, H. BECKER, S. Flow and Turbulence Structure in the Wake of a Simplified Model SAE paper 2003-01-0656 2003
- DUNCAN, B.D. SENGUPTA, R. MALLICK, S. SHOCK, R. SIMS-WILLIAMS, D.B. Numerical Simulation and Spectral Analysis of Pressure Fluctuations in Vehicle Aerodynamic Noise Generation SAE paper 2002-01-0597 2002
- SIMS-WILLIAMS, D.B. DUNCAN, B.D. The Ahmed Model Unsteady Wake: Experimental and Computational Analyses SAE paper 2003-01-1315 2003
- DUELL, E. GEORGE, A. Experimental Study of a Ground Vehicle Body Unsteady Near Wake SAE paper 1999-01-0812 1999
- BARNARD, R. LEDAKIS, N. Physical Modelling and Optimisation of Radiator Cooling Flow Systems 2 nd MIRA International Conference on Vehicle Aerodynamics UK 20-21 October 1998
- BARNARD, R. BULLEN, P. QIAO, J. Brake and Engine Cooling Flows: Influences and Interactions 4 th MIRA International Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 16-17 October 2002
- Closed-Test-Section Wind Tunnel Blockage Corrections for Road Vehicles SAE Report SP-1176 January 1996 1-56091-815-2
- GARRY, K.P. WALLIS, S.B. COOPER, K.R. FEDIW, A. WILSDEN, D.J. The Effect on Longitudinal Position of a Road Vehicle Model in a Wind Tunnel Test Section SAE paper 940414 1994
- COOPER, K.R. BERTENYI, T. DUTIL, G. SYMS, J. SOVRAN, G. The Aerodynamic Performance of Automotive Underbody Diffusers SAE Paper 980030 1998
- COOPER, K.R. SOVRAN, G. SYMS, J. Selecting Automotive Diffusers to Maximise Underbody Downforce SAE paper 2000-01-0354 2000
- HOWELL, J.P. The Influence of Ground Simulation on the Aerodynamics of Simple Car Shapes with an Underfloor Diffuser Royal Aeronautical Society Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 18-19 July 1994
- HOWELL, J.P. GOODWIN, J. The Influence of Ground Simulation on the Aerodynamics of Simple Car-like Shapes with Underbody Roughness IMechE Autotech Congress NEC Birmingham 1995
- HOWELL, J. SHEPPARD, A. BLAKEMORE, A. Aerodynamic Drag Reduction for a Simple Bluff Body Using Base Bleed SAE paper 2003-01-0995 2003
- WINDSOR, S. The Effect of Rear End Shape on Road Vehicle Aerodynamic Drag IMechE Autotech UK 1991
- GARRY, K. LE GOOD, G. Investigation of the Influence of Body Geometry on the Ground Plane Pressure Signature Beneath a Simplified Car Shape 3 rd MIRA International Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 18-19 October 2000
- AHMADI, M. GARRY, K. Preliminary Investigation of a Ground-Plane Boundary Layer on the Aerodynamic Characteristics of Road Vehicle Models Tested Over a Fixed Ground Plane SAE paper 960675 1996
- RYAN, A. DOMINY, R. The Aerodynamic Forces Induced on a Passenger Vehicle in Response to a Transient Cross-Wind Gust at a Relative Incidence of 30° SAE paper 980392 1998
- DAVIS, J.P. Wind Tunnel Investigation of Road Vehicle Wakes University of London 1982
- BEARMAN, P.W. Some Observations on Road Vehicle Wakes SAE paper 840301 1984
- BEARMAN, P.W. DE BEER, D. HAMIDY, E. HARVEY, J.K. The Effect of a Moving Floor on Wind-Tunnel Simulation of Road Vehicles SAE paper 880245 1988
- BEARMAN, P.W. MULLARKY, S.P. Aerodynamic Forces on Road Vehicles Due to Steady Side Winds and Gusts Royal Aeronautical Society Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 18-19 July 1994
- DOCTON, M. DOMINY, R. The Simulation of Transient Crosswinds on Passenger Vehicles MIRA International Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 15-16 October 1996
- DOMINY, R. DOCTON, M. Numerical Predictions of a Flow Around a Simple Vehicle From Under the Influence of a Transient Cross-Wind Gust MIRA International Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 15-16 October 1996
- SIMS-WILLIAMS, D.B. DOMINY, R. Experimental Investigation into Unsteadiness and Instability in Passenger Car Aerodynamics SAE paper 980391 1998
- ROMBERG, G. GUNN, J.A. LUTZ, R.G. The Chrysler 3/8 Scale Pilot Wind Tunnel SAE paper 940416 1994
- WALTER, J. DUELL, E. MARTINDALE, B. ARNETTE, S. GEIERMAN, R. GLEASON, M. ROMBERG, G. The DaimlerChrysler Full-Scale Aeroacoustic Wind Tunnel SAE paper 2003-01-0426 2003
- RANZENBACH, R. BARLOW, J.B. ESMAILI, H. Practical Application of the Two-Variable Blockage Correction Method to Automobile Shapes SAE paper 2001-01-0632 2001
- BARLOW, J. GUTERRES, R. RANZENBACH, R. WILLIAMS, J. Wake Structures of Rectangular Bodies with Radiused Edges Near a Plane Surface SAE paper 1999-01-0648 1999
- WILLIAMS, J. BARLOW, J. RANZENBACH, R. Experimental Study of CD Variation with Aspect Ratio SAE paper 1999-01-0649 1999
- BARLOW, J. GUTERRES, R. RANZENBACH, R. Parametric Study of Wake Structures of Rectangular Bodies with Radiused Edges Near a Plane Surface SAE paper 2000-01-0490 2000
- HAN, T. Sumantran, V. Harris, C. Kuzmanov, T. Huebler, M. Zak, T. Flow-Field Simulations of Three Simplified Vehicle Shapes and Comparisons with Experimental Measurements SAE paper 960678 1996
- KHALIGHI, B. ZANG, S. KOROMILAS, C. BALKANYI, S.R. BERNAL, L.P. LACCARINO, G. MOIN, P. Experimental and Computational Study of Unsteady Wake Flow Behind a Bluff Body with a Drag Reduction Device SAE paper 2001-01-1042 2001
- ARONSON, D. BRAHIM, S.B. PERZON, S. On the Underbody Flow of a Simplified Estate SAE paper 2000-01-0485 2000
- ALAM, F. WATKINS, S. ZIMMER, G. HUMPHRIS, C. Effects of Vehicle A-pillar Shape on Local Mean and Time-Varying Flow Properties SAE Paper 2001-01-1086 2001
- COGOTTI, A. BUCHHEIM, R. GARRONE, A. KUHN, A. Comparison Tests Between Some Full-Scale European Automotive Wind Tunnels - Pininfarina Reference Car SAE paper 800139 1980
- BUCHHEIM, R. UNGER, R. CARR, G.W. COGOTTI, A. KUHN, A. NILSSON, L.U. Comparison Tests Between Major European Automotive Wind Tunnels SAE paper 800140 1980
- COSTELLI, A. GARRONE, A. VISCONTI, A. BUCHHEIM, R. COGOTTI, A. KUHN, A. FIAT Research Center Reference Car: Correlation Tests Between Four Full Scale European Wind Tunnels and Road SAE paper 810187 1981
- CARR, G. W. Correlation of Aerodynamic Force Measurements in MIRA and Other Automotive Wind Tunnels SAE paper 820374 1982
- BUCHHEIM, R. UNGER, R. JOUSSERANDOT, P. MERCKER, E. SCHENKEL, F.K. NISHIMURA WILSDEN, D.J. Comparison Tests Between Major European and North American Automotive Wind Tunnels SAE paper 830301 1983
- HUCHO, W-H. Vehicle Aerodynamics - Present Status and Future Development 3 rd MIRA International Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 18-19 October 2000
- CARR, G.W. STAPLEFORD, W. Blockage Effects in Automotive Wind Tunnel Testing SAE paper 860093 1986
- VON SCHULZ-HAUSMANN, F.K. VAGT, J.D. Influence of Test Section Length and Collector Area on Measurements in ¾ Open Jet Wind Tunnels SAE paper 880251 1988
- HOFFMAN, J. MARTINDALE, B. ARNETTE, S. WILLIAMS, J. WALLIS, S. Effect of Test Section Configuration on Aerodynamic Drag Measurements SAE paper 2001-01-0631 2001
- HOFFMAN, J. MARTINDALE, B. ARNETTE, S. WILLIAMS, J. WALLIS, S. Development of Lift and Drag Corrections for Open Jet Wind Tunnel Tests for an Extended Range of Vehicle Shapes SAE paper 2003-01-0934 2003
- CARR, G.W. A Comparison of the Ground-Plane-Suction and Moving-Belt Ground-Representation Techniques 880249 1988
- BENDTSSON, A. ECKERT, W. MERCKER E. The Effect of Groundplane Boundary Layer Control on Automotive Testing in a Wind Tunnel SAE paper 880248 1988
- CARR, G.W. ECKERT, W. A Further Evaluation of the Ground-Plane Suction Method for Ground Simulation in Automotive Wind Tunnels SAE paper 940418 1994
- RAWNSLEY, S. TATCHELL, D. Application of the PHOENICS Code to the Computation of the Flow Around Automobiles SAE paper 860217 1986
- SHAW, C.T. Predicting Vehicle Aerodynamics Using Computational Fluid Dynamics - A Users Perspective SAE paper 880455 1988
- GAYLARD, A. BAXENDALE, A. HOWELL, J. The Use of CFD to Predict the Aerodynamic Characteristics of Simple Automotive Shapes SAE paper 980036 1998
- GAYLARD, A. BICKERTON, J. HOWELL, J. Current Issues in the Use of CFD to Predict Aerodynamic Characteristics of Car Shapes 2 nd MIRA International Conference on Vehicle Aerodynamics UK 20-21 October 1998
- KNIGHT, J. SHAW, C. LUCEY, A. Fluid-Structure Modelling of Convertible Car Roofs 3 rd MIRA International Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 18-19 October 2000
- RICHARDS, K. WRIGHT, N. BAKER, C. BAXENDALE, A. Computational Modelling of Pollution Dispersion in the Near Wake of a Vehicle 3 rd MIRA International Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 18-19 October 2000
- WRIGHT, N. RICHARDS, K. BAKER, C. BAXENDALE, A. Computational Modelling of Pollution Dispersion in the Near Wake of a Vehicle 4 th MIRA International Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 16-17 October 2002
- BROWN, M. BAXENDALE, A. HICKMAN, D. Recent Enhancements of the MIRA Model Wind Tunnel 2 nd MIRA International Conference on Vehicle Aerodynamics UK 20-21 October 1998
- WOODWARD, S. GARRY, K. KENDALL, G. LE GOOD, G. A Comparison of Ground-Plane Pressure Signatures for the Model and Full-Scale MIRA Reference Car 4 th MIRA International Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 16-17 October 2002
- NGUYEN, T.M. SAUNDERS, J.W. WATKINS, S. The Sideways Dynamic Force on Passenger Cars in Turbulent Winds SAE paper 970405 1997
- GILHAUS, A.M. RENN, V.E. Drag and Driving-Stability-Related Aerodynamic Forces and Their Interdependence - Results of Measurements on 3/8 Scale Basic Car Shapes SAE paper 860211 1986
- CARR, G.W. New MIRA Drag Reduction Prediction Method for Cars Automotive Engineer 12 3 June July 1987 34 38
- CARR, G.W. ATKIN, P.D. SOMMERVILLE, J. An Empirically-Based Method for Car Aerodynamic Lift and Side Force Royal Aeronautical Society Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 18-19 July 1994
- CARR, G.W. Influence of Moving Belt Dimensions on Vehicle Aerodynamic Forces MIRA International Vehicle Aerodynamics Conference UK 15-16 October 1996
- HOWELL, J. HICKMAN, D. The Influence of Ground Simulation on the Aerodynamics of a Simple Car Model SAE paper 970134 1997
- MACKLIN, R. GARRY, K. HOWELL, J. Comparing Static and Dynamic Testing Techniques for the Crosswind Sensitivity of Road Vehicles SAE paper 960674 1996
- MACKLIN, R. GARRY, K. HOWELL, J. Assessing Effects of Shear and Turbulence on the Crosswind Sensitivity of Road Vehicles SAE Paper 970135 1997
- COGOTTI, A. Wake Surveys of Different Car-Body Shapes with Coloured Isopressure Maps SAE paper 840299 1984
- COGOTTI, A. Car-Wake Imaging Using a Seven Hole Probe SAE paper 860213 1986
- COGOTTI, A. Flow-Field Surveys Behind Three Squareback Car Models Using a New Fourteen Hole Probe SAE paper 870243
- COGOTTI, A. A Parametric Study on the Ground Effect of a Simplified Car Model SAE paper 980031 1998
- Aerodynamic Testing of Road Vehicles in Open Jet Wind Tunnels SAE Report J2071 (Open Throat Wind Tunnel Adjustments) October 1997
- BASARA, B, PRZULI, V. TIBAUT, P. On the Calculation of External Aerodynamics: Industrial Benchmarks SAE paper 2001-01-0701 2001
- WILLIAMS, J. QUINLAN, W.J. HACKETT, J.E. THOMPSON, S.A. MARINACCIO, T. ROBERTSON, A. A Calibration Study of CFD for Automotive Shapes and CD SAE paper 940323 1994
- HAJILOO, A. WILLIAMS, J. HACKETT, J.E. THOMPSON, S.A. Limited Mesh Refinement Study of the Aerodynamic Flow Field Around a Car-Like Shape: Computational Versus Experimental Fluid Dynamics SAE paper 960677 1996
- LIETZ, R. MALLICK, S. KANDASAMY, S. CHEN, H. Exterior Airflow Simulations Using a Lattice Boltzmann Approach SAE paper 2002-01-0596 2002
- JENKINS, L. An Experimental Investigation of the Flow Over the Rear End of a Notchback Automobile Configuration SAE paper 2000-01-0489 2000
- RAMNEFORS, M. BENSRYD, R. HOLMBERG, E. PERZON, S. Accuracy of Drag Predictions on Cars Using CFD - Effect of Grid Refinement and Turbulence Models SAE paper 960681 1996
- AXELSSON, N. RAMNEFORS, M. GUSTAFSSON, R. Accuracy in Computational Aerodynamics Part 1: Stagnation Pressure SAE paper 980037 1998
- PERZON, S. SJOGREN, T. JONSON, A. Accuracy in Computational Aerodynamics Part 2: Base Pressure SAE paper 980038 1998
- HALLIDAY, J. NOELTIG, S. GRUEN, N. Aerodynamics Simulation of Flow Around Volvo ECC Concept Vehicle 2 nd MIRA International Conference on Vehicle Aerodynamics UK 20-21 October 1998
- YEN, J. MARTINDALE, B. DUELL, E. ARNETTE, S. Determining Blockage Correction in Climatic Wind Tunnels Using CFD SAE paper 2003-01-0936 2003
- LOKHANDE, B. SOVANI, S. KHALIGHI, B. Transient Simulation of the Flow Field Around a Generic Pickup Truck SAE paper 2003-01-1313 2003