This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Occupant Kinematics and Restraint Effectiveness during a Quarter-Turn Rollover in a Heavy Truck
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published March 08, 2004 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The objective of this study was to examine the effectiveness of the typical 3-point restraint system during a quarter-turn rollover of a heavy truck. Five far-side, quarter-turn rollover dynamic tests (3 belted and 2 unbelted tests using a Hybrid II dummy) were conducted using a specially designed large hydraulic machine (causing typical real-world peak angular velocities such as 115° to 140° per second). Four far-side, quarter-turn+ (∼110°) static rollover tests (all belted - one test with a Hybrid II test dummy and the other three with human volunteers) were conducted using a specially designed machine driven by rotational motion from an electric motor (constant roll speed of approximately 6° to 7° per second). A tractor cab and seat and the most commonly used dual-sensitive 3-point belt system were mounted on the test machines. Instrumentation included various transducers, accelerometers, and high speed video cameras to record selected data. As expected, unbelted occupants experienced potential for serious head injuries and possible neck injuries. The shoulder belt was ineffective in these simulated far-side rollover tests (i.e. the upper torso slipped out of the shoulder belt early in the rollover; the ATD's motion was mostly lateral with minimal longitudinal acceleration/deceleration in this study). The lapbelt was effective at keeping the driver's pelvis in the seat. Drivers will stay in their seat while belted although these tests demonstrate that the driver's head will strike the interior headliner or other objects that may be mounted to the headliner (such as a CB radio). HIC values are low for belted headliner strikes (∼50); however the possibility for serious neck injuries may exist and cannot be ruled out for belted occupants from the results in this study. This is especially true due to the observed impact of the vertex of the ATD's head with the headliner. It may be useful to conduct future tests using a Hybrid III ATD to collect direct ATD data with respect to inferences about neck injury.
|Technical Paper||Safety Restraint Systems in Heavy Truck Rollover Scenarios|
|Technical Paper||Improving Seat Belt Comfort on Off-Highway Vehicles|
|Technical Paper||The Dynamics of Previously Conducted Full-Scale Heavy Vehicle Rollover Crashes|
CitationKress, T., Rink, R., and Sewell, P., "Occupant Kinematics and Restraint Effectiveness during a Quarter-Turn Rollover in a Heavy Truck," SAE Technical Paper 2004-01-0327, 2004, https://doi.org/10.4271/2004-01-0327.
- Saczalski K.J. et al. Biomechanical Simulation and Animation of Vehicle Occupant kinematics for Restrained and Unrestrained Conditions in Rollover Accidents. SAE Paper Number 1999-01-1885. 1995.
- Saczalski K.J. and Saczalski T.K.Analysis Methods for Prediction of Occupant Impact response and Interactions with Seats, Restraints, and Vehicle Interaction Structures. 2nd International KRASH Users Conference. Cranfield, England. 1998
- Pywell, J.F. et al. Characterizations of Belt Restraint Systems in Quasi-static Vehicle Rollover Tests. SAE Paper Number 973334. 1997.
- Sadeghi, M.M., Tidbury, G.H. Bus Rollover Accident Simulation. 3rd International Conference on Vehicle Structural Mechanics. SAE Paper Number 790994. 1979.
- Severy, D.M., et al. School Bus passenger protection. SAE Paper Number 670040. 1967.
- Sakri, T., et al. Study on Passenger Car Rollover Simulation. Paper Number 91-S6-O-10. 13th International ESV Conference. 1991.
- Herbst, B., et al. The Ability of 3-Point Safety Belts to Restrain Occupants in Rollover Crashes. Paper 96-S5-O-12. 15th International ESV Conference. 1996.
- Arndt, M.W., et al. Evaluation of Experimental Restraints in Rollover Conditions. SAE Paper Number 952712. 39th Stapp Car Crash Conference. 1995.
- Arndt, M.W., et al. The Development of a Method for Determining Effective Slack in Motor Vehicle Restraint Systems for Rollover Protection. SAE Paper Number 970781. SAE International Congress. 1997.
- Blower, D. and Campbell, K.: The Trucks involved in Fatal Accidents Project. In UMTRI Research Review 27:1-15. 1996
- Code of Federal Regulations. Part 571. Section 208. Occupant Crash Protection.
- Occupant Restraint System Evaluation - Lateral Rollover System - Level Heavy trucks. SAE J2426. Surface Vehicle Recommended Practice. January 1998.
- Instrumentation for Impact Testing. SAE J211. Surface Vehicle Recommended Practice. October 1995.
- Sign Convention for Vehicle Crash Testing. SAE J1733. Surface Vehicle Information Report. January 1994.
- Lissner, H.R., Lebow, M. and Evans, F.G.: Experimental Studies on the Relation between Acceleration and Intracranial Pressure Changes in Man. Surg. Gynecol. Obstet. 111:329-338. 1960.