This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
On Automotive Body Closure Panel Dent Resistance
Technical Paper
2003-01-2856
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The definitions and evaluation methods used to determine dent resistance for automotive closure panels are reviewed. Although dent resistance is required under both static and dynamic loading conditions, dynamic dent resistance is emphasized because the basic definitions and methods for evaluating dynamic denting are still not well established. In order to design automotive body panels to resist denting, a fundamental understanding of the interaction between the evaluation method and the material's, mechanical, and panel's geometric parameters is required. Currently there is no standard for indenter type, speed, or indenter material to be utilized or on the basic definition of “acceptable” dent resistance. The interpretation of results is dependent on these parameters. Predictive methodologies using the finite element method are reviewed. Technical challenges in developing a quantitative measure of dent resistance are highlighted.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Designing With RRIM |
Technical Paper | Door Seal Behavior Prediction and Enhancement in Performance Using Digital Simulation |
Technical Paper | Finite Element Analysis of FEAD Bracket and Correlation with Test |
Topic
Citation
Seksaria, D., Brockenbrough, J., and Forsythe, L., "On Automotive Body Closure Panel Dent Resistance," SAE Technical Paper 2003-01-2856, 2003, https://doi.org/10.4271/2003-01-2856.Also In
References
- Yutori Y. et al. Memoires Scientifiques Revue Metallurgie 77 4 561 569 1980
- Ekstrand G. Asna N. Materials and Design 19 145 156 1998
- Asnafi N. J. of Materials Processing Technology 49 13 31 1995
- Shi M.F. Wilczynski J.S. Automotive Body Materials IBEC'93 IBEC 1993
- Krupitzer R.P. Harris R.P. Paper 920243 SAE 1992
- Raghavan K.S. Arwashan N. Paper 970984 SAE 1997
- Shi M.F. et al. Paper 970158 SAE 1997
- Hodgins B. et al. Paper 01B-119, SAE 2001 Burley C.E. Niemeier B.A. Paper 770199 SAE 1977
- van Veldhuizen B. Kranendonk W. Ruifrok R. Materials and Body Testing IBEC '95 62 70 IBEC 1995
- Mahmood H.F. Paper 810099 SAE 1981
- Sabbagh M.A. Chavali R.N. Montgomery J.S. IBEC '95 Materials and Body Testing 87 90 IBEC 1995
- Montgomery J. Brooks A. IBEC '94
- Werner M.F. IBEC '93 Automotive Body Materials 87 90 IBEC 1993
- Chen K. Salamie P.A. Paper 841201 SAE 1984
- Arwashan N. Lou M.M. “Computer prediction of quasi-static resistance of automotive steel panels, Innovations in Processing and Manufacturing Sheet Materials,” Demeri M.Y. TMS 2001
- DiCello J.A. George R.A. Paper 740081 SAE 1974
- Johnson T.E., Jr Schaffnit W.O. Paper 730528 SAE 1973
- Vreede P.T. Tamis P.J. Roelofsen M.E. MATERIALS AND BODY TESTING IBEC'95 79 86 IBEC 1995
- Shi M.F. et al. Paper 910287 SAE 1991
- Niemeier B.A. Alcoa Report No. 78-38 1978
- Hart C.J. Alcoa Report No. ERD 1979
- Shih H. Shi M.F. Advances in Forming and Modeling Sheet Materials SP-1767, SAE Int, 2003-01-0607
- Couque H. SwRI Project 06-5540 Southwest Research Institute 1993
- Barlat F. Lian J. Int. J. of Plasticity 5 51 66 1989
- Thomas D. University of Waterloo 2001
- Rolf R.L. Sharp M.L. Stroebel H.H. Paper 770200 SAE 1977
- Nomura S. et al. IDDRG Conference Proceedings 394 402 IDDRG 1984
- Burley C.E. Reynolds Aluminum Internal Report 1977
- Burley C.E. Niemeier B.A. Paper 770199 SAE 1977
- Niemeier B.A. Burley C.E. Paper 780398 SAE 1978
- Shi M. F. et al. Paper 910288 SAE 1991
- Sakai H. Saito K. Tsukada H. International Journal of Vehicle Design 4 1 13 22 1983
- Sato K. et al. Advances in Forming and Modeling Sheet Materials SP-1767, SAE Int, 2003-01-0606
- ABAQUS/Standard User Manual Hibbit, Karlsson, & Sorensen 1080 Main Street Pawntucket, RI 02860-4847 USA 2002
- LS-DYNA USERS MANUAL (Nonlinear Dynamic Analysis of Structures in Three Dimensions) Livermore Software Technology Corporation 2002
- Burley C.E. Niemeier B.A. Koch G.P. Paper 760165 SAE 1976
- Sanders S.R. “Dynamic Denting Simulations Using LS_DYNA3D - Correlation and Experiment,” Reynolds Report No. 97-06 1997
- Rolf R.L. “Falling Weight Impact Tests of Canoe Sheet,” Alcoa Report No., 76-75-08 1975
- Niemeier B.A. “Dynamic Denting of Aluminum Canoe Stock,” Reynolds Report No., 78-38, 1978
- Settle E.E. Hart C.J. Gardner E.D. “Impact Tests of Prototype Aluminum Bumpers,” Reynolds Report No. 79-031 1979
- Niemeier B.A. Redford L.F. “The Dent Resistance of Aluminum Cans,” Reynolds Report 1961
- Howell A.G. Jr. Settle E.E. Gardner E.D. “Impact Tests of Aluminum Bumpers,” Reynolds Report No. 41-376-4MO 1976
- Stumpf T. “Dent Resistance Testing of Steel and Aluminum Sheet,” Alumax Report No. 98-ML-18-03 1998
- Rolf R.L. “Dent Resistance of Aluminum and Steel Sheet,” Alcoa Report No. 12-73-10 1974
- Rolf R.L. Sharp M.L. Stroebel H.H. “Structural Characteristics of Aluminum Body Sheet,” Alcoa Report No. 57-77-02 1977
- Painter M.J. Pearce R. “The Denting Behavior of Sheet Materials,” Proc. Of 12 th IDDRG Conf. 1982
- Alaniz L. Brooks L.E. Seel T.N. “Investigation of Body Panel Stiffness as Predicted by Finite Element Analysis,” SAE Paper 900716 1990
- Chang D.C. Justusson J.W. “Structural Requirements in Material Substitution for Car-Weight Reduction,” SAE Paper 760023 1976
- Evanko J.W. Kaufman J.G. “New 6000 Series Alloys for Auto Body Sheet,” SAE 1977
- Rolf R.L. “The Relative Structural Performance of Aluminum and Steel in Auto Body Panels,” Alcoa Report No., 57-78-09 1978
- Rolf R.L. “Finite Element Studies of Local Stiffness, Oil canning Resistance of Automobile Hoods,” Alcoa Report No. 55-77-4 1977
- Chen C. Rastogi P.K. Horvath C.D. “Effects of Steel Thickness and Mechanical Properties on Vehicle Outer Panel Performance: Stiffness, Oil Canning, Load and Dent Resistance,” IBEC '93 1993
- Bryant J. Beaudoin A.J. Van Dyke R.T. “The Effect of Crystal Texture on the Formability of AA2036 Auto Body Sheet,” SAE 940161 1994