This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Case Study of Vehicle Maneuvers Leading to Rollovers: Need for a Vehicle Test Simulating Off-Road Excursions, Recovery and Handling
Technical Paper
2003-01-0169
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Rollovers are an important vehicle safety issue. Various technologies have been developed to help prevent rollovers from occurring, but the evaluation of rollover resistance typically involves vehicle-handling tests that are conducted on flat road surfaces with a uniform or split coefficient of friction. The purpose of this study is to determine the precipitating events leading to rollovers by analyzing real-world rollover crashes. This is a first step in identifying and developing vehicle tests that are representative of the principal driving scenarios leading to rollovers.
The sequence of events leading to rollovers was determined from 63 in-depth investigated cases in the NASS-CDS database from 1995-1999. The sequence was evaluated by vehicle maneuvers, vehicle stability, surface type, road and shoulder transition condition, posted and estimated speeds, vehicle type and driver injury severity. The cases were divided into 3 categories defining the precipitating event leading to a rollover: 1.) negotiating a curve at usually too high a speed, 2.) drifting off the road, or 3.) avoiding an obstacle in the traveling lane.
47% of the precipitating events were negotiating a curve at too high a speed prior to the sequence leading to a rollover, 27% were drifting off the road, and 25% left the road after avoiding an obstacle, such as an animal or vehicle in the traveling lane. 90% left the roadway with 66% having four wheels off the road and 34% two wheel off the road. The transition from a road surface to the shoulder often involved a drop of approximately 50 mm onto grass, gravel or dirt from an asphalt or concrete road surface. In 45% of the cases, the driver attempts a recovery to the road and steers. When the front wheel regains the road surface, the vehicle abruptly crosses the road and often departs it on the opposite side and then rolls over. In 45% of the cases, the driver attempts to keep the vehicle on the shoulder, but drifts further off road until it leaves the roadway and rolls over. In 10% of the cases, the precipitating event happens on the road, leading to a loss of control and rollover.
This study prioritizes the need to carry out tests that simulate a vehicle leaving the road and having at least two wheels on the shoulder after negotiating a curve at high speed, drifting off the road or leaving the road by obstacle avoidance. The vast majority of rollovers involve the vehicle departing the road, so handling tests need to include a transition from a road surface to a shoulder where there may be a drop off of approximately 50 mm and an attempt to recover back onto the road with various degrees of steering or an attempt to maintain a straight heading during braking under a varying coefficient of friction road condition. Since current tests are carried out on a flat road, a new suite of handling maneuvers should be considered where the wheels leave the road surface to a simulated shoulder. Dry conditions should first be captured, followed by wet conditions.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Viano, D. and Parenteau, C., "Case Study of Vehicle Maneuvers Leading to Rollovers: Need for a Vehicle Test Simulating Off-Road Excursions, Recovery and Handling," SAE Technical Paper 2003-01-0169, 2003, https://doi.org/10.4271/2003-01-0169.Also In
SAE 2003 Transactions Journal of Passenger Cars - Mechanical Systems
Number: V112-6; Published: 2004-09-15
Number: V112-6; Published: 2004-09-15
References
- Bahling GS Bundorf RT Moffatt EA Orlowski KF 1995 The Influence of Increased Roof Strength on Belted and Unbelted Dummies in Rollover and Drop Tests Journal of Trauma - Injury Infection and Critical Care 38 4 557 563
- Chen BC Peng H 2001 Differential-Braking-Based Rollover Prevention for Sport Utility Vehicles with Human-in-the-Loop Evaluations Vehicle System Dynamics 36 4-5 359 389
- Cooper ER Moffatt EA Curzon AM Smyth BJ Orlowski KF 2001 Repeatable Dynamic Rollover Test Procedure with Controlled Roof Impact SAE- 2001-01-0476 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA
- Federal Register 2001 Consumer Information Regulations Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards; Rollover Resistance 66 128
- Garrott WR Howe JG Forkenbrock G 1999 An Experimental Examination of Selected Maneuvers that may Induce On-Road Untripped Light Vehicle Rollover - Phase II of NHTSA's 1997-1998 Vehicle Rollover Research Program July
- Goldman RW El-Gindy M Kulakowski BT 2001 Rollover Dynamics of Road Vehicles: Literature Survey Heavy Vehicle Systems - International Journal of Vehicle Design 8 2 103 141
- Jones IS Wilson LA 2000 Techniques for the Reconstruction of Rollover Accidents Involving Sport Utility Vehicles, Light Trucks and Minivans SAE- 2000-01-0851 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA
- Malliaris C Digges, K 1999 Crash Exposure and Crashworthiness of Sport Utility Vehicles SAE- 1999-01-0063 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA
- Marine MC Wirth L Thomas TM 1999 Characteristics of On-Road Rollovers SAE- 1999-01-0122 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA
- NHTSA 1999 An Experimental Examination of Selected Maneuvers That May Induce On-Road Untripped Light Vehicle Rollover - Phase II of NHTSA's 1997-1998 Vehicle Rollover Research Program
- NHTSA 2000 Traffic Safety Facts 1998 NHTSA
- NHTSA 2001
- Parenteau C Gopal M Viano DC 2001 Near and Far-Side Adult Front Passenger Kinematics in a Vehicle Rollover SAE- 2001-01-0176 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA
- Parenteau C Thomas P Lenard J 2001 US and UK Field Rollover Characteristics SAE- 2001-01-0167 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA
- Parenteau C Viano D Shah M Gopal M Davies J Nichols D Broden J 2002 Field Relevance of a Suite of Rollover Tests to Real-World Crashes and Injuries Accident Analysis and Prevention
- Parenteau CS Shah, M 2000 Driver Injuries in US Single-Event Rollovers SAE- 2000-01-0633 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA
- Robertson LS Maloney A 1997 Motor Vehicle Rollover and Static Stability: An Exposure Study American Journal of Public Health 87 5 839 841
- Rossey M 2001 Test Method for Simulating Vehicle Rollover SAE- 2001-01-0475 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA
- Strickland RR McGee HW 1998 Evaluation Results of Three Prototype Automatic Truck Rollover Warning Systems Human Performance, User Information and Highway Design Transportation Research Record 1628 41 49
- Takubo N Mizuno K 2000 Accident Analysis of Sport Utility Vehicles: Human Factors from Statistical Analysis and Case Studies JSAE Review 21 2 103 108
- Whitefield RA Jones IS 1995 The Effect of Passenger Load on Unstable Vehicles in Fatal, Untripped Rollover Crashes American Journal of Public Health 85 9 1268 1271
- Wielenga, TJ 1999 Tire Properties Affecting Vehicle Rollover SAE- 1999-01-0126 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA
- Wigglesworth EC 1991 Motor-Vehicle Rollovers and Spinal-Cord Injury International Journal of Vehicle Design 12 5-6 609 617
- Zellner JW Kebschull SA Van Auken RM 2000 Analysis of Vehicle Tip Stability in Side Impact Tests SAE- 2000-01-1650 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale PA